Cell Antenna Battle to Resume Next Year

December 20, 2013 at 10:50 PM

CHATHAM, NJ - The battle lines have been draw between AT&T and the residents in the area of Buxton Road and Huron Drive.

AT&T wants to place 12 cell antennas on the NJ American Water tower located behind 63 Buxton Road because it will give the cell phone company the greatest coverage in the area. Home owners in the area don't want the antennas placed in their neighborhood and believe AT&T should find another site that is not in a residential setting.

The AT&T application was the fourth case heard on Thursday at the Board of Adjustment meeting and it took up most of the time until the meeting was adjourned at 11 p.m., without any decision. The next time the parties will be together is Jan. 16 at the next scheduled board meeting.

Sign Up for E-News

Before the Board of Adjustment hearing began, board chairman Tony Vivona warned everyone that the variances being requested would be decided on the facts.

"We're all on the same team here," Vivona said. "The decision can't go on speculation. It has to go on the physical proofs that the defense is going to put on and the other team is going to put on. That's what we're going to base our decision on."

Judy Fairweather, lawyer for AT&T, was still presenting her first expert witness when the meeting ended and Yvan Joseph, the radio frequency engineer, will still be on the spot when the meeting resumes. Joseph presented an overlay of the coverage AT&T would get for its customers with the installation of the antennas on the water tower.

Joseph pointed out that the water tower location would give the best coverage because it is on a ridge that provides elevation of 580 feet. Robert F. Simon, lawyer for Brad and Katie Weisgerber, and other residents urged the company to consider other sites since New Providence and Summit would benefit more from the antennas than the residents of the Buxton Road neighborhood.

Simon got some assistance from Ola Lotfy of Kincaid Lane, who provided a question that could not be answered by AT&T.

"I basically wanted them to provide propagation maps for alternative locations in areas where they are really targeting, the white spots on the map, in New Providence and Summit," Lofty said. "Industrial locations or areas that are less residential, where they can build towers that would accomplish their goals while mitigating the effect on home owners in a residential area."

The board agreed and AT&T will return with the propagation maps for other possible sites.


TAP Into Another Town's News:

TAP Into Another Town's News:

Sign Up for E-News


Upcoming Events


Fri, December 2, 2:00 PM

Madison Area YMCA - Kids Central, Madison

Kids Central Playgroup

Education Giving Back

Sat, December 3, 9:30 AM

Morristown Unitarian Fellowship, Morristown

13th Annual "Gifts of Conscience" Holiday Fair

Arts & Entertainment Other


Sat, December 3, 10:00 AM

Madison Area YMCA, Madison

Christmas Tree Lot at the Madison Area YMCA Opens

Giving Back Home & Garden

Chatham Borough Council can Eliminate the Waiting List for Train Station Parking Permits

November 22, 2016

To the Editor: 

To the 151 Chatham Borough residents who are on the waiting list for permit parking at the train station, which is a minimum of a 3-year wait, and also to Borough residents seeking daily parking spots that all seem to be gone by about 6:30 a.m: GOOD NEWS! Please attend the next Borough Council meeting on Monday, Nov. 28, 7:30 p.m., Borough Hall, third ...

Emma Einhorn: Being Herself and Finding a Place to Belong


Emma Einhorn is still in disbelief of the honor bestowed on her. “Amazing,” says the vivacious, chatty 18 year old, describing how she felt when she attended the New Jersey YMCA State Alliance dinner to accept the Madison Area YMCA’s 2016 Youth Volunteer of the Year award. “To do good for people makes me feel good,” she says.

Sitting behind her handiwork ...

Chatham Emergency Squad Launches 2017 Cadet Program

December 1, 2016

The Chatham Emergency Squad is looking for current Sophomores who are residents of Chatham Borough or Chatham Township and will turn 16 by September 1st to join our thriving Cadet Program! 

The purpose of this program is to provide high school students the opportunity to help their community and learn more about the healthcare delivery system. Interested Sophomores can find ...