Law & Justice

Montco Domestic Violence Program Reacts to Rice Punishment

After the NFL released Ray Rice with a two-game suspension after a domestic violence case, Maria Macaluso, director of the Montgomery County Women's Center, felt compelled to comment. Credits: MC Women's Center

The sports world has been abuzz with news of Ray Rice. Back in February, the Baltimore Ravens football star was involved in a domestic violence incident while staying at a hotel in Atlantic City. His then fiancé is seen, according to USA Today’s report, on video security cameras, pulling an “apparently unconscious Janay Rice (nee Palmer) out of an elevator.”

The news spread quickly and on July 24, the NFL handed down a “sentence” of sorts. The NFL star will lose three game checks and be suspended from two games. Since the announcement, many negative reactions have followed.

Commissioner Roger Goodell has called the punishment “consistent with other cases,” said a USA Today report. Rice himself has said “I was wrong,” according to Goodell, and the league feels he has been able to “take responsibility and be accountable for it.”

Sign Up for E-News

Locally, many community members disagree. Maria Macaluso, the executive director of the Women’s Center of Montgomery County, Domestic Violence Program, disagreed to the extent of sending a comment to local press. Macaluso called the decision a “black eye” and a “lenient punishment.”

The following is the full letter by Macaluso.

“National Football League Commissioner Roger Goodell took a public relations black eye over his lenient punishment of Baltimore Ravens player Ray Rice. Putting it in perspective, that’s a lot less than the physical assault endured by Janay Palmer, Rice’s fiancée, who was apparently knocked out during an altercation with Rice on an Atlantic City casino elevator. Video shot by a bystander shows Rice dragging a seemingly unconscious Palmer off the elevator and into a hotel hallway.

A New Jersey grand jury indicted Rice and charged him with third-degree aggravated assault, but the running back adroitly avoided prosecution by marrying Palmer and entering a pretrial program in May.

Nevertheless, Goodell found Rice guilty of violating the NFL’s personal conduct policy and slapped him with a two-game suspension. Rice will forfeit $470,000 in salary, but will be permitted to participate in the Ravens’ training camp and preseason games.

Putting this in perspective, Rice’s two-game suspension is precisely what Cleveland Browns’ wide receiver Josh Gordon received for testing positive for marijuana. And it’s less than what he would have received had he tested positive for steroids.

So there you have it. According to the NFL’s value system, a woman’s life and dignity is worth the same as a marijuana cigarette but less than a needle-full of human growth hormones.

As the executive director of the Women’s Center of Montgomery County, I am heartened by the vociferous public backlash against Goodell’s verdict, especially from men -- for if we are to eliminate the scourge of domestic violence from our society, men must play a leadership role.

Which brings us to Goodell.

Several media outlets reporting on the public backlash against the Rice decision have posed rhetorical questions such as “Does the NFL Have a Women Problem?’’ and “Does the NFL Have a Domestic Violence Problem?’’

Yes and yes. But more significantly, the NFL has a leadership problem.

The Ray Rice case would be appalling enough if it were an isolated instance, involving one player on one team. But it is not.

According to the U-T San Diego newspaper, which maintains a database of NFL arrests, 21 of 32 NFL teams employed a player with a domestic or sexual violence charge on their record last year. What makes this statistic so shocking is that this was the state of the NFL a year after Kansas City Chiefs linebacker Jovan Belcher shot dead his 22-year-old girlfriend before driving to the Chiefs’ training facility and fatally shooting himself in the head on Dec. 1, 2012.

So, yes, the NFL has a women problem. And a domestic violence problem. And a gay problem. And maybe even a race problem.

Less than a year ago, the league was scandalized when Miami Dolphins player Jonathan Martin quit his team over alleged racial bullying by several teammates. A league investigation found that the players bullied not only Martin, but a Japanese-born assistant trainer who was, according to the NFL report, “repeatedly targeted with racial slurs and other racially derogatory language.’’ At least two of the bullies are still employed by the NFL.

More recently, former Indianapolis Colts Coach Tony Dungy made comments about Michael Sam, the first openly gay player to be drafted into the NFL, that were perceived as derogatory. While Dungy has attempted to walk back his controversial remarks, there is no indication that his comments will affect his role as a commentator on NBC’s Sunday Night Football telecasts, the league’s premier primetime showcase.

NFL training camps have opened for a new season, but the league’s internal culture remains little changed. The tone-deaf comments by Goodell and the Ravens’ front office personnel regarding Rice’s punishment only reinforce that impression.

“I believe you are sincere in your desire to learn from this matter and move forward toward a healthy relationship and a successful career,’’ Goodell said in a letter to Rice that was released by the NFL.

Ravens’ Coach John Harbaugh said, “I stand behind Ray. He’s a heck of a guy. He’s done everything right since.’’

Ozzie Newsome, the Ravens’ general manager and a former NFL player, praised the league office for its “thorough process’’ in reviewing the Rice “incident’’ and for taking “extra steps’’ when deciding “discipline issues.’’

“While not having Ray for the first two games is significant loss to our team, we respect the league’s decision and believe it is fair,’’ Newsome added.

Last year, 158 Pennsylvanians died in domestic violence incidents. The victims ranged in age from 2 to 91. Sixty-three were shot, 24 were stabbed, 6 were beaten, 4 were strangled, 2 were burned, and 1 was shot with an arrow, according to PCADV’s annual fatality report, which is available to the public here.

Professional football is America’s favorite sport. Its players are viewed as role models, and most of them live up to that role. Sadly, some do not.

The only way the NFL can avoid further damage to its image is if its leaders – Commissioner Goodell, the owners, general managers and head coaches – lead by example and say NO MORE to domestic and sexual violence. And back it up with comprehensive programming to address the sexism, racism, and heterosexism that is the oppressive and life damaging culture of the NFL. We owe it to our boys as well as to our women and girls. None of us are equal until all of us are.”

Local Lower Providence Township residents can seek assistance through the local women’s center via a 24-hour hotline at 800-773-2424 or visit the Center’s website here for more information.

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News

Lower Providence