Law & Justice

Raritan Wins Motions in Gannett Lawsuit

July 9, 2014 at 5:00 PM

RARITAN, NJ - The case continues between Gannett New Jersey and Raritan Borough, which recently saw some wins concerning motions filed in the more than four-year-old lawsuit between the two entities.

Gannett filed a lawsuit against the borough more than four years ago over access to information about employee salaries and overtime information.

According to reports on the lawsuit, Gannett wanted the information in electronic format, instead of paper or PDF, as it was looking to compare and analyze salary information among different municipalities.

Sign Up for E-News

The borough had denied the existence of the records and sought to pass on a $1,100 service charge to conver the data. After Gannett proved in 2012 that the borough had access to the records in the requested format, the judge ruled that Raritan had unlawfully denied access to it.

The service charge was eventually waived.

As of May, a superior court judge in Somerville said Raritan Borough owes Gannett more than $590,000 in legal fees, and the borough appealed the decision.

In June, according to Raritan Mayor Jo-Ann Liptak, the Appellate court granted the borough's motion to reverse the requirement that Raritan sequester funds to pay Gannett's attorney fees. In addition, she said, a motion from Gannett that would require Raritan to pay the fees immediately was denied by the Appellate court.

Read Liptak's full update from June 24 below:

"It's been a long road so far, but we have today excellent news from the Appellate Division. This is on the motions that we and the League filed and motions that Gannett filed in response. The results below were provided to us orally this morning by Appellate Division staff.

Our motion was to preserve the stay of judgment pending appeal but reverse Judge Ciccone's requirement that Raritan appropriate and sequester funds to secure the payment of Gannett's attorneys' fees. We have been advised that the motion has been GRANTED. Raritan will not be required to take any steps to pay or secure payment of Gannett's fees while the underlying case is considered by the Appellate Division. This result is as we fully expected, but it is still good to know that the Appellate Division agrees.

The League's motion was to continue its role as amicus curiae at the Appellate Division level. That motion was GRANTED.

Gannett filed two motions. The first was to strike parts of our brief (for what we thought were bogus reasons) and to dissolve the stay of judgment pending appeal. If successful, the result would have required Raritan to pay Gannett's attorneys' fees immediately. Both parts of that motion were DENIED.

Gannett's second motion was directed to the League's request and its brief supporting Raritan's position. Both parts of that motion were DENIED.

Gannett also asked for oral argument. Granting oral argument might have implied that the questions of granting a stay of judgment pending appeal or requiring security were more difficult than we thought that they should be. 
Gannett's request was DENIED.

In sum, four motions, addressing six issues, and one request, all decided in Raritan's favor.

These Appellate Division decisions will be incorporated in written orders.

It remains much too early to have a result on the underlying issues in the Gannett case, most importantly the attorneys' fees issue, but the Appellate Division's understanding of and willingness to reverse one of Judge Ciccone's more egregious errors gives us renewed expectation that we are on a path to a favorable result."

TAP Into Another Town's News:

TAP Into Another Town's News:

Sign Up for E-News


Upcoming Events

Wed, January 18, 9:30 AM

Duke Island Park Visitor's Center, Bridgewater

Duke Island Park Walking Group

Health & Wellness

Sat, January 21, 9:30 AM

Scherman Hoffman Wildlife Sanctuary, Bernardsville

NJ Audubon: Nature-Infused Yoga Winter Series

Green Health & Wellness

Sat, January 21, 12:00 PM


Launching of Central Jersey Community Coalition

Where's the Replacement?

January 17, 2017

To the Editor:

As a chair of the Rare Disease Congressional Caucus, Congressman Leonard Lance has been a strong advocate for those who have been stricken with uncommon health issues and last year helped to pass the 21st Century Cures Act. Yet on Friday, Congressman Lance voted to take away the health insurance of those very souls he claims to be on the side of.

The Affordable Care Act makes ...

Bridgewater Police Investigating Report of Stolen Phone at Microsoft Store

January 13, 2017

BRIDGEWATER, NJ - Bridgewater Township Police are investigating a report of a theft of a phone from the Microsoft Store at the Bridgewater Commons Mall Jan. 6, according to a report from police.

According to the report, an employee reported that a white male at about 6 feet 1 inch tall, who was wearing baggy jeans and an Adidas gray colored hooded sweatshirt, removed an HP Elite X3 ...

Area Teen Magician Receives Performing Arts Award

January 14, 2017

Evan Brochinsky, a local teenage magician, was recently honored by Somerset County 4-H with a county award in Performing Arts.

Brochinsky is a member and past officer of the Somerset County 4-H Magicians Guild, the county’s magic club.

When asked about Brochinsky and the award, club leader Conrad Colon said, “Evan is amazing! He is a natural entertainer and has a passion ...

Somerset County Sheriff's Office: New Officers, Promotions and Awards

January 15, 2017

SOMERVILLE, NJ – Somerset County Sheriff Frank J. Provenzano swore in new officers and presented awards to both officers and civilians during a ceremony held at the county’s historic courthouse.

Provenzano asked for a moment of silence to open the ceremony, “for our fallen brothers and sisters who made the ultimate sacrifice and the brave men and women in the armed ...

Are Giant Football Players at Risk for Heart Disease?

Football, by many measures, is America’s favorite sport. Over the holidays, many people spent their time rooting for their favorite college or professional football team. While cheering for your team's 300-pound linemen to protect your quarterback and pick up the pass rush, consider the effects of playing the sport on an athlete's heart health. It is known that obesity and ...

New Jersey Wins Under Lance Mental Health Law

January 10, 2017

WASHINGTON, D.C. ---  Congressman Leonard Lance (NJ-07) today announced that New Jersey has been selected to participate in a demonstration program to expand access to community mental health services and strengthen the quality of care for those living with mental and behavioral health issues. The demonstration program was created under Lance’s Excellence in Mental Health Act, ...