Food & Drink

Westfield's Own ‘Cake War?’ Locals Debate After Carlo’s Opens Near a Longtime Staple

October 7, 2013 at 8:35 PM

WESTFIELD, NJ — When Carlo’s Bakery opened in Westfield on Sept. 1, fans of “Cake Boss” Bartolo “Buddy” Valastro Jr. lined up for hours to catch a glimpse of the TLC reality show star and try some of the bakery’s famous treats.

But not everyone was so happy to see Carlo’s open shop down the block from Bovella’s Pastry Shoppe, a town staple since 1949 with a very similar menu, from their Italian pastries to their novelty cakes.

In person and on social media, many locals expressed outrage—even hostility—in response to the television personality claiming his latest location as Westfield’s new “hometown” bakery.

Sign Up for E-News

"Westfield doesn't need another bakery," said one Facebook user in a local group in response to a story posted there from The Alternative Press.

Many said they planned to show their support for Bovella’s by shopping there Sept. 1, instead of heading to Carlo’s. One Bovella’s supporter even told the group that he was “going to egg the opening,” though no such egging was reported.  

Carlo’s Chief Brand Officer Adam Bourcier told The Alternative Press that Carlo’s proximity to Bovella’s was unintentional.

“We looked at a few spaces in town and it just happened that 21 East Broad Street was the best fit for our needs,” Bourcier said. “We're not looking to take over the town. We both have our own specialties to offer the community.”

One difference between the two shops is Carlo’s open kitchen. Six-year Westfield resident Caroline Sutton said that her family enjoys the setup because it allows her daughters to watch the bakers make chocolate-covered strawberries. Sutton, a “Cake Boss” fan, also said that it was Carlo’s that opened her eyes to Italian pastries.

“I never ate cannolis, and I do now,” she said.

Jim Baker, interviewed at Westfield’s Rockn’ Joe Coffeehouse and Bistro nearby, said that he was impressed with Carlo’s assortment of baked goods and their presentation.

“This is economic Darwinism,” Baker said, “If [Bovella’s] can’t cut it, they’ll go under.”

Thirty seven-year Westfield resident Ed Cruikshank agreed with Baker, after recalling waiting on long lines at Bovella’s during holidays past.

“I like to see the old survive, but business is business,” Cruikshank said.

With lines for its fresh treats and breads still forming each day and the unmistakable sweet scent of Italian desserts still luring customers through its doors, many doubt Bovella’s will go under any time soon.

Meanwhile, Carlo’s may be helping to put Westfield on the world’s map—Bourcier said that though there are “no official plans yet” to film episodes of “Cake Boss” in Westfield, it’s certainly a possibility.

Additional reporting by Erin Scialabba.

TAP Into Another Town's News:

TAP Into Another Town's News:

Sign Up for E-News


Newark Man Shot in Roselle Dies, Police Charge Suspect with Murder

January 22, 2017

ROSELLE, NJ — Twenty  one-year-old Tyquan Johnson of Newark, who was shot in the early morning hours on Saturday in Roselle, died later that afternoon. Authorities are searching for 25 year-old Nathaniel Price from Roselle and have charged him with murder and other related weapons offenses, according to acting Union County Prosecutor Grace H. Park.

Roselle Police officers were ...

Thank You, Westfield PD

January 22, 2017

Dear Editor,


It is imperative that Chief of Police David Wayman and the entire Westfield Police Department are recognized for the utterly outstanding job they performed at the Westfield Washington's Women's March yesterday, Jan. 21. 


As we realized the numbers of marchers were reaching unexpected, epic proportions the day before, they quickly ...

Upcoming Events


Mon, January 23, 1:30 PM

Westfield Area YMCA, Westfield

Free Ageless Grace Class


Tue, January 24, 7:00 PM

Municipal Building, Westfield

Westfield Town Council Meeting

Community Calendar Government

Tue, January 24, 7:30 PM


Westfield Board of Education Meeting


Free Public Wi-Fi in Union County Parks and Facilities

January 19, 2017

The Union County Board of Chosen Freeholders is pleased to announce that free public Wi-Fi access is available now in 6 new parks throughout the county. There are now a total of 11 county parks and facilities that offer free Wi-Fi.

“We are committed to ensuring that our recreation facilities are up to date and welcoming to a broad range of activities.” said Chairman Bruce Bergen.

12 Homes Sold Last Week in Fanwood, Scotch Plains & Westfield, NJ

January 23, 2017

Courtesy of Keller Williams Realty, Westfield.*
For more information on these or other real estate matters, contact Laura Brockway 908-456-3093;
416 Jerusalem Rd, Scotch Plains, NJ $305,000        
405 Westfield Rd, Scotch Plains, NJ $430,000        
431 Union Ave, Scotch Plains, NJ $435,000         ...

Tax Season Starts Today

The Internal Revenue Service announced that the nation's tax season will begin Monday, Jan. 23, 2017, and reminded taxpayers claiming certain tax credits to expect a longer wait for refunds. Some refunds will not be released until after Feb. 15. The IRS still anticipates issuing more than nine out of 10 refunds in less than 21 days, but there are some important factors to keep in ...

Westfield Area YMCA Offers Programs for Children and Young Adults with Special Needs

The Westfield Area YMCA is pleased to offer programs for children and young adults with special needs. 

The Dragonfly program for young adults 18-26 with special/adaptive needs offers physical, recreational and social programs free with membership. Classes include:

Strength & Conditioning:  Ambulatory participants learn about muscle ...

A Winning Real Estate Strategy

If you’ve been thinking of selling your home, consider this …

Interest rates are still historically low and home prices are at record highs.  With predictions that interest rates will adjust upwards in 2017, there is presently an abundance of buyers looking to capitalize on these low rates.  Low interest rates mean more buying power.

We are in the hottest selling ...

Doing Too Much for Our Children

January 20, 2017

As parents, we all have that innate desire to protect and provide for our kids. Yet, at some point we must ask ourselves, Are we doing too much for them? 

We are all guilty of mild and extreme acts of over-protectiveness and over- parenting that can be very damaging to our children. Many parents are willing to overextend themselves in catering to their children and excessively ...

Westfield High School Students Selected for Region Band & Orchestra

Seven Westfield High School Band students were accepted to the 2017 New Jersey Music Education Association Region Band or Orchestra.  Three of the seven students placed first overall in their instrument: Dale Beyert - Wind Ensemble and Orchestra, Trumpet; Michael Hauge - Wind Ensemble, Eb & Bb Clarinet, and Brooke Walden - Wind Ensemble and Orchestra, Piccolo & ...

Testing Your Resolve

Now that the ball has dropped in Times Square it is time for another annual tradition – New Year’s resolutions. So, along with improving your diet and exercising more, consider adding these:

“Will” you? – I have lost count of how many clients with whom I have met that have a spouse, children and substantial assets but an outdated or even no will at all.

Closed Fund Open Mind

Closed-end funds (CEFs) can play an important role in a diversified investment portfolio. They offer benefits similar to those of an open-end mutual fund, but also sport unique advantages.  

Unlike a traditional open-end mutual fund, CEFs have a fixed number of shares available to trade. Their price is not tied to the value of the underlying portfolio. The only way the number of shares ...

Video: Mistreated, Harassed, Abused, Discriminated Against or Retaliated Against at Work?

Have you been mistreated, harassed, abused, discriminated against or retaliated against by your employer?

Watch this video to learn how Westfield employment attorney Fred Shahrooz-Scampato, who for the last 25 years has aggressively represented employees, can help you.

If you are the victim of prejudice or spend every day in a hostile work environment, you can give him a call for ...

Holy Trinity School Spotlight - 6th Grade

Sixth grade is a transitional year for students as they enter middle school.  Holy Trinity School embraces this change through its continued commitment to creating an environment in which its students can grow and develop academically, socially, and spiritually. 

In sixth grade, the curriculum becomes more departmentalized with students rotating classes for various subjects and ...

Imagine Receives Grant of $20,000 from the Northfield Bank Foundation

“We are so grateful to The Northfield Bank Foundation for their generous grant of $20,000 for the expansion of our bereavement support programs at our new center in Mountainside!” said Stuart Arnold, Imagine Board Chair.  “We are moving in the nick of time as all of our Green Groups (ages 10-12 approximately) are full.  Moving into this new space will allow us to ...

South Orange Middle School Students Walkout of School in Protest of Inauguration

January 20, 2017

SOUTH ORANGE, NJ - South Orange Middle School (SOMS) students walked out of school today at about 12:30 p.m. in protest of the Presidential inauguration of Donald Trump.

According to reports, SOMS students began protesting inside the halls at about 12:15 p.m., with the walkout happening shortly afterwards. The protest, which was student-led and organized, was largely organized ...