The Perth Amboy School District Scuffle Illustrates the Need to End Local Control

April 27, 2012 at 5:57 PM

The current turmoil in the Perth Amboy public schools serves as an illustration of why it is time to end local community control of education. Nepotism and political malfeasance is rife in local districts, with little or no oversight by State officials. School Superintendent Janine Caffrey has been relieved of her duties and placed on paid administrative leave, in an apparent political struggle over control. Furthermore, the reasons for her administrative decapitation leave more questions than answers.

This writer disagrees with Janine Caffrey’s position on teacher tenure. Without tenure, classroom teachers will be subject to the local political whims of school board members who want to replace them with their friends, relatives and political cronies, As it is, New Jersey’s schools are still rife with nepotism. Without tenure, teachers will be terminated because they supported the wrong political party or because they spoke up on issues that were in disagreement with school board members.

Caffrey did not receive the support of local teachers when the Perth Amboy school board voted to place her on administrative leave. Nevertheless, she was initially hired to engage in education reform end she was clear about how she was going to do it. Radical change will inevitably ruffle some feathers, and it certainly did in Perth Amboy. The community is still trying to recover from the misdeeds of public officials. Former Perth Amboy Mayor and State Assemblyman Joe Vas is in prison for accepting graft and betraying the public trust. Current school board President Samuel Lebreault is under investigation for fraudulently applying for the free school lunch program for his children when his family was not qualified. Furthermore, the original application for the school lunch program mysteriously disappeared from the files, but a copy was nevertheless recovered. Lebreault was at a loss to provide an explanation.

Sign Up for E-News

Perth Amboy parents have protested the Board’s action against Caffrey, citing the need for the reform that the Superintendent was sponsoring.

Yes, this writer disagrees with the bulk of the reform issues that Caffrey was fostering. Nevertheless, she is a highly qualified school administrator who was badly needed in a community that has been beset with scandal. The Board initially hired her to engage in radical reform and that is what she was doing.

This current Perth Amboy scuffle is a clear indication of the dangers of local control. For decades, school districts have engaged in nepotism and political cronyism, with little or no oversight by State officials. The time to end local control of public school districts is now.

 The Guest Column is our readers' opportunity to write about a given issue or topic in an in-depth and educational manner.

The opinions expressed herein are the writer's alone, and do not reflect the opinions of or anyone who works for is not responsible for the accuracy of any of the information supplied by the writer.

TAP Into Another Town's News:

TAP Into Another Town's News:

Sign Up for E-News


Upcoming Events


Sat, December 10, 9:00 AM

Charlie Brown's of Chatham, Chatham Township

Breakfast with Santa

Food & Drink Giving Back Police & Fire


Sat, December 10, 5:00 PM

Madison Area YMCA - Kids Central, Madison

Parents' Night Out: Date Night

Education Giving Back

Tue, December 13, 11:30 AM

SAGE Eldercare, Summit

Tai Chi

Health & Wellness

To Be a Better Investor, Be More Rational!

Many posit the theory of rational man, who coolly and carefully calculates his self-interest in a logical manner. We all fall somewhat short of that ideal.  In the financial markets, irrationality can be costly. What are some of the common foibles, and what can we do to minimize their damage to our portfolios?

Don’t Make Decisions Based on What You Paid For an Investment

How ...

Chatham Borough Police Make Arrest for Theft, Possession

December 7, 2016

CHATHAM, NJ - A Chatham man was charged with Theft of moveable property, Possession of CDS (Xanax) with the intent to distribute, and Possession of CDS without a valid prescription.

On Nov. 6 at approximately 2:30 p.m., officers responded to the 100 block of Hillside Avenue on a report of a male taking packages from a front porch. A resident reported that she was alerted to the ...

January Open House at the F.M. Kirby Children’s Center of the Madison Area YMCA

December 6, 2016

The F.M. Kirby Children’s Center of the Madison Area YMCA, located at 54 East Street in Madison, will hold an open house on Monday, January 9, and Wednesday, January 11, from 9:30-11 a.m. and 4:30-6:30 p.m.

The F.M. Kirby Children’s Center of the Madison Area YMCA offers curriculum-based, comprehensive childcare and early childhood educational programs for infants, toddlers, ...