FLORHAM PARK, NJ - Saturday morning brought quite the shock to Nonna's Pizza in Florham Park when Barstool Sports President and Founder Dave Portnoy surprised them with a visit!

In addition to running Barstool Sports, Dave Portnoy is also very popular for his 'One Bite Everybody Knows the Rules' pizza reviews. Throughout quarantine Dave was stuck giving reviews of frozen pizzas but as everything begins to return to normal he has started to venture out and review pizzerias again.

On Saturday Portnoy gave his review of Nonna’s. In the review he gave Nonna’s regular slice of pizza a score of 7.7 out of 10 and gave the Margarita pizza a score of 8.1 out of 10. Both of these scores are very good scores for Portnoy who prides himself on being unbiased.

Our newsletter delivers the local news that you can trust.

Portnoy also tried Nonna’s fried pizza dough donuts and said they were good.

During the review the owner of Nonna’s came out and talked with Portnoy about his pizza and why pizza slices are never as good on Saturday mornings. Portnoy is famous for his no nonsense commentary and there was no shortage of it in this review. It started with him making fun of Frankie’s facial hair (Frankie is the cameraman). It then proceeded with him making fun of the owner of a parked monster truck. You can view the whole review by clicking here