Law & Justice

Jury To Decide If New Brunswick Man Murdered a College Student

January 9, 2017 at 1:58 PM

NEW BRUNSWICK, NJ - A jury is deciding whether a city man beat and left for dead Billy McCaw, a 22-year-old college student, on a cold, snowy weekend three years ago in a New Brunswick backyard.

Timothy Puskas, who lived a block from the Hartwell Street property where McCaw was found on Feb. 15, 2014 after being bludgeoned to death, has pleaded not guilty to murdering the Kean University student.

Both the defense and the prosecution presented closing arguments on Friday, painting vastly-different pictures of what happened the night of the slaying and during the subsequent police investigation.

Sign Up for E-News

“There is not a hair. There is not a fiber. There is not a drop of blood,” defense attorney Joseph Mazraani said. “There is nothing connecting Tim to the crime scene, nothing connecting Tim to this victim.”

The police investigation of the murder was flawed since its inception, Mazraani claimed. He said pressure from higher-ups and the Rutgers community pushed detectives to target an “innocent local” who was incapable of killing McCaw, a former Rutgers student.

The investigation relied on the word of several “rats” who lived with Puskas on Plum Street, Mazraani said. He claimed some people tried to frame Puskas because he planned to inform police of a burglary ring with which they were involved.

“Folks, a foundation built by rats cannot withstand this storm,” Mazraani told the jury. “It just cannot.”

Meanwhile, the defense attorney said, police overlooked leads that could have nailed the killer. Other possible perpetrators included a man who was found in possession of McCaw’s cellphone, young men who were jealous of McCaw spending time with their girlfriends and individuals who were involved with drugs, Mazraani claimed.

He said police and prosecutors merely performed a “surface scratching” of these other leads and instead let their “narrative” decide the course of the investigation.

In her closing statement, Middlesex County Assistant Prosecutor Bina Desai decidedly disagreed with Mazraani’s portrayal of the murder investigation.

“This was not a rush to judgment like the defense would have you believe,” she said. “The evidence led to the defendant’s arrest, not the other way around.”

Detectives looked into other possible killers and scenarios, but Puskas emerged as the killer, Desai claimed.

Some of his roommates claimed to have heard someone, presumably Puskas, leave his home around the believed time of the murder, a claim cast into doubt by Mazraani.

Although some of the prosecution’s witnesses were not exactly upstanding citizens, they were the people who lived with and knew Puskas, she said.

The defense theorized that McCaw may have met up with other friends before being attacked. Desai noted that no one has come forward with such information.

“You’d also have to believe that the people he was drinking with were the ones that killed him,” she added.

The prosecution and the defense disagreed on the likely time of McCaw’s death and the route he took to get to Hartwell Street.

McCaw was killed after a night of partying at two Rutgers frat houses. From there, prosecutors believe he walked down Hamilton Street and encountered an enraged Puskas on or near Hartwell.

Desai portrayed Puskas as an enraged man who was upset after a divorce and a theft from his bank account. He walked the streets of New Brunswick that night, “seeking someone to hurt,” she claimed.

But the defense said Puskas was a sick, sad man dealing with his mother’s ailing health. He had already known about the thefts against him for weeks by the time McCaw was killed and was more prone to whining than battering people, Mazraani said.

Police have neither identified nor found the weapon used to murder McCaw. The defense said Puskas never saw it, while the prosecution claims he hid or destroyed it.

Many of McCaw’s family members have traveled from Tennessee to watch the trial unfold, wearing red-and-black clothing and Rutgers gear. Some held their faces as the two sides presented their closing statements, while others teared up.

For them—and the shocked Rutgers community—the jury’s looming verdict could offer a sense of closure.

Being found not guilty would end a years-long “nightmare” for Puskas, who was found guilty two years ago of a fatal hit-and-run crash.

TAP Into Another Town's News:

TAP Into Another Town's News:

Sign Up for E-News

New Brunswick

Jaffe Morning Briefing - January 20, 2017

January 20, 2017


TRENTON - As America becomes great again, a Democratic assemblyman from Cape May says it's now time that New Jersey get a big dose of patriotism. Assemblyman Bob Andrzejczak is calling for a state law that requires any public meeting to open with the Pledge of Allegiance, with an American flag prominently displayed. To recite the pledge is perfectly ...

Upcoming Events

Wed, January 25, 8:00 PM

INC American Bar & Kitchen, New Brunswick

New Brunswick Jazz Project Presents the Kyle ...

Arts & Entertainment Food & Drink

Thu, January 26, 8:00 PM

Hyatt Regency New Brunswick, New Brunswick

New Brunswick Jazz Project Presents the Todd ...

Arts & Entertainment Food & Drink

Rutgers Helps to Form “Big Data” Alliance

January 18, 2017

NEW BRUNSWICK, NJ — Rutgers University is helping to build a team of state colleges and nonprofits known as the New Jersey Big Data Alliance, which aims to find ways to best use the information harnessed from smartphones and computers.

Along with eight other schools, Rutgers recently signed a memorandum of agreement to formally establish the tech-heavy group.

“The signing of the ...

For Murder Victim’s Family, A Guilty Verdict Means Justice

NEW BRUNSWICK, NJ — Few in the courtroom this morning expected to hear the words so soon.

After making sure a juror who fell ill last week was better, state Superior Court Judge Dennis Nieves announced around 10 a.m. that the jury had reached a verdict in the trial of Timothy Puskas. The New Brunswick resident had pleaded not guilty to killing Billy McCaw, a former Rutgers student, in ...

BREAKING: Jury Finds New Brunswick Man Guilty of Killing Former RU Student

Note: This story has been updated. Click here to read more.

NEW BRUNSWICK, NJ - A jury this morning found Timothy Puskas guilty of murdering Billy McCaw, a former Rutgers student, on a cold night in February 2014.

The verdict, which found Puskas guilty of four murder and weapons charges, came after five days of tense deliberations. Shortly before 10 a.m., the court was informed that ...

Police Link South Brunswick, Edison Storage Burglaries

January 20, 2017

SOUTH BRUNSWICK, NJ – Police in two Middlesex County towns are considering the possibility that break ins at two storage businesses, impacting almost 100 units, are related, officials said Thursday.

Some 43 storage units at the Public Storage location on Route 1 in South Brunswick and another 50 units at the J&M Self Storage facility on Oak Tree Road in Edison were broken into during ...

Rutgers Responds to Union “Wage Theft” Complaints Filed With Feds

January 12, 2017

NEW BRUNSWICK, NJ – Four unions that say they represent thousands of Rutgers University employees have filed complaints with the U.S. Department of Labor, claiming that the school violated federal law in neglecting to pay medical school staffers for one week of work.

The affected employees worked for the University of Medicine and Dentistry of New Jersey and the Robert Wood Johnson ...


Women's March on Washington: Why, and Why Now

January 11, 2017

As Donald Trump’s inauguration draws near, a number of groups are planning various events and rallies – perhaps most notably, the Women’s March on Washington. I have read a number of opinion pieces and spoken to many people about the March, and several questions and criticisms seem to consistently arise. I would like to address two of the major themes.

(Q) The election is ...

Newcomer to politics, Quinn seeks election to ensure children's future

January 20, 2017

NEW BRUNSWICK, NJ – Robert A. Quinn, a newcomer to Somerset County politics, announced today that he is seeking the Republican nomination for New Jersey Assembly in the 17th Legislative District next November, 2017.

Quinn said of his decision to run, "Like many people who are new to politics, it is the future that my children face that motivates me to run for office."   ...

Opinion: Ex-N.J. education commissioner: Trump's pick is on the right side of history

January 19, 2017

New Jersey's U.S. senators, Robert Menendez and Cory Booker, must put partisanship aside and support the nomination of Betsy DeVos for secretary of education. She's earned their support with her advocacy for public education reform and better educational opportunities for children. It also would be in their best political interests.

In the early 1990s, I was elected Jersey City's ...