Law & Justice

Yorktown BJ’s Gas Station Approvals Upheld by Court

January 11, 2017 at 3:51 PM

YORKTOWN, N.Y. - BJ's Wholesale Club in Yorktown can move forward with its plan to build a six-pump gasoline filling station after town approvals were upheld Monday by a state Supreme Court justice.

The lawsuit was filed in 2015 by three Yorktown gas station owners and Yorktown Smart Growth—a non-profit organization concerned with development and preservation. The challenged approvals rezoned a portion of the property and granted a special-use permit and site plan amendment for the filling station.

Judge Gretchen Walsh, presiding judge of the Environmental Claims Part for the New York State Ninth Judicial District, wrote in her 79-page decision that the town’s approvals were rational, consistent with the town’s comprehensive plan and zoning code, and were not “arbitrary or capricious,” according to David Steinmetz, who represented BJ’s and Urstadt Biddle, owner of Staples Plaza.

Sign Up for E-News

“We are pleased that BJ’s can move forward with providing this amenity to its members,” Steinmetz, said. “This gasoline filling station will be a welcome addition to the Staples Plaza, and will continue to bring economic growth, aesthetic improvements and vitality to the Town and surrounding community.”

Walsh also upheld the town’s determination under the New York State Environmental Quality Review Act that the gasoline filling station would not have the potential for any significant adverse environmental impacts. The member’s only station would be built in BJ’s existing parking lot in the Staples Plaza at 3303 Crompond Road.

“The court meticulously analyzed the record in this case and observed, in a 79-page decision, how carefully and thoughtfully both the town board and planning board went through the environmental and land use process,” Steinmetz said.

The gas stations and Yorktown Smart Growth also sued Breslin Realty, which owns property at 3200 Crompond Road, where a Costco Wholesale Club was once proposed. Like BJ's, the town also granted approvals for a gasoline filling station at Costco. The parties agreed to dismiss the lawsuit in October 2016 if a revised plan, with a Lowe's as the centerpiece, was approved. The revised plan includes no filling station.

TAP Into Another Town's News:

TAP Into Another Town's News:

Sign Up for E-News


Who Rescued Whom?

After giving birth to our first two kids, Lauren and I decided to adopt our third child, Justin, who came home with us on Dec. 23.

The third child was a bit furrier than the first two. He also walks on four legs.

We don’t know too much about Justin. Paw Safe Animal Rescue in Patterson told us that he was rescued from a kill-shelter in Alabama. We’re not sure why anyone would ...

Action Needed to Stop EpiPen Price Gouging

January 13, 2017

Editor's Note: This op-ed, though published today, was submitted by Assemblyman Kevin Byrne on Thursday, Jan. 5. Yesterday, CVS announced that it will now offer a cheaper, generic version of the EpiPen. Byrne said he applauds the efforts of CVS and Cigna for stepping in and looking to provide a more cost-effective alternative for consumers.

For people with severe ...

King Andrew Has Spoken

So, there is now a deal to close down Indian Point by the year 2021. None of the local elected officials were part of these discussions. After all, why should they be? They only represent the people who will be affected, mostly negatively, by this deal. If there is anything we have learned during the reign of King Andrew the First, it is, “So it is written, so it shall be done.”

He ...

Never Take Democracy for Granted

In 1962, science fiction writer Phillip K. Dick published an amazing novel entitled “The Man in the High Castle.” Amazon has turned it into a truly captivating series. Set in 1962, it depicts an “alternate universe” with the alarming premise that Japan and Germany had won World War II. The victorious Axis nations carved up our country, with Germany controlling the East ...

Taking the Plunge, for a Good Cause

On any New Year’s Day since 2013, if you happened to be at Riverfront Green in Peekskill, looking toward the Hudson River, you might think you hadn’t fully recovered from the prior evening’s festivities and were hallucinating.

But even stone cold sober, your eyes wouldn’t be deceiving you. Yes, that was a large throng of people running into the icy waters in summery ...

Once Upon a Sagging Mattress

“Help!” I cried out meekly.

“Where are you?” asked my husband, looking around the bedroom.

“I’m in here,” I responded. “In the mattress.” Truth be told, I wasn’t actually in the mattress. It was more like I was on it, but I was sunk down so low, it looked like I had been swallowed up by the mattress. Our very pricey and ...

Helping Students Discern Between Fact and Fiction

Dear Dr. Linda,

My wife and I have been trying to explain the difference between fact and fiction to our children, who are 9, 12 and 15. There has been so much misinformation and rhetoric coming from both of our major political parties in the past couple of years, we want to make sure that the future leaders of our amazing country are able to do the sort of analysis they need to make decisions ...

Thank You for the Support

January 11, 2017

I would like to start by saying thank you to all the residents of Yorktown for a fantastic evening with our second annual New Year's Eve ball drop.

The amount of people who came out to enjoy the evening with us was truly sensational. Many thousands of people were there enjoying a great night with music, food and friends. It only goes to show you when the time comes, nothing is impossible.

Upcoming Events

Tue, January 24, 7:00 PM

Support Connection, Yorktown Heights

Breast and Ovarian Cancer Support Group

Health & Wellness

Thu, January 26, 1:30 PM

United Methodist Church, Shrub Oak

Tri-State IBM Retirees Club


Fri, January 27, 7:00 PM

Westchester County Center, White Plains

Westchester Knicks vs. Raptors 905

Arts & Entertainment

What Are Learning Modalities?

Dana Stahl, a learning specialist and educational consultant, will address educational questions and concerns that parents may have regarding their children’s academic development and progress in school. Topics can center on how to handle homework dilemmas to what questions to ask at a CSE meeting. Questions can range from “How best do parents advocate for their children?” to ...

I Want to Redecorate, but Where Do I Begin? 

Since decorating mistakes can be very costly and time consuming, I always urge my clients to do their homework before undertaking any redecorating project.

What kind of homework?  A good way to begin is to flip through design and decorating magazines, and visit websites dedicated to interior décor. Start collecting pictures of various design products and styles that appeal to you ...

TAPinto Launches Free TAPinto App for iPhone and Android: Download it Today

January 18, 2017 launched a free TAPinto App today for iPhone and Android, enabling readers to obtain their local news and events in a fast, easy-to-use application.  With this launch, TAPinto becomes one of the only local news publications in the country to have its own App.

The TAPinto App not only features news and events, but also enables readers to receive push notifications regarding ...