Religions and Spirituality

ISBR Anticipates Planning Bd. Vote at Tuesday Mosque Site Plan Meeting

A crowd gathered at town hall even though the initial settlement discussions with the ISBR were closed to the public. Credits: By Linda Sadlouskos
The site of a proposed mosque at 124 Church St. in Liberty Corner Village in Bernards Township. Credits: By Linda Sadlouskos

BERNARDS TWP., NJ - The Planning Board is expected to vote on a revised application for a mosque in Liberty Corner at a special meeting set for 7 p.m. this Tuesday, Aug. 8, said the attorney for the Islamic Society of Basking Ridge, which has been seeking to build the 4,250-square-foot structure on Church Street since 2012.

However, Adeel A. Mangi, attorney for the Basking Ridge-based ISBR, said in an email last Friday that he was not in a position to answer such questions as which experts the ISBR will call to testify at the special meeting and public hearing scheduled to be held in the Ridge High School Performing Arts Center at 268 S. Finley Ave., Basking Ridge.

The special meeting is the result of Bernards Township's legal settlement earlier this summer with the ISBR and the US Department of Justice in which the township - along with paying $3.5 million in damages and costs - agreed to modify the township's application requirements to facilitate the construction of the mosque. 

Sign Up for E-News

As part of the settlement, approved in late May by a majority of the Bernards Township Committee and the Planning Board, the Planning Board is required to hold a special hearing to discuss the settlement action, and also the ISBR's application for preliminary and final site plan approval of the Settlement Site Plan (the “Whispering Woods hearing”). No unrelated business will be included on the agenda for the special meeting. 

Both lawsuits were filed in 2016 as a result of the Planning Board's rejection in December 2015 of plans to tear down a residential home and instead build the home-sized mosque on slightly more than four acres off Church Street.

The board and those who opposed a mosque in a residential section of the historic village asserted the decision was based on land use requirements, while the ISBR and DOJ claimed that religious discrimination was the basis for the Planning Board's rejection, particularly unprecedented parking requirements that exceeded what would have been asked in the case of a church.

The hearing, referred to in the settlement as the "Whispering Woods" hearing, based the requirements set in a previous court case, will have no time limit, according to information published as part of the settlement hearing. The settlement with the ISBR is published on the township website, and the details on the hearing requirements are under the "Whispering Woods Hearing" section.

'Interested parties' living within 200 feet to have three minutes to speak

The hearing terms require the Planning Board to provide all "interested parties" with the right, through their attorneys if represented, or directly if not represented by an attorney, to cross examine the witnesses for the ISBR and the Planning Board subject to "reasonable limitations" as to amount of time allowed for such cross examination, in accordance with state law, according to the settlement.

State law for this type of hearing identifies an “interested party” is defined as any person owning property within 200-feet of the property. Prior to being able to cross examine witnesses, all interested parties shall identify themselves and provide under oath the address of the lot(s) they own within that distance. The settlement states that all interested parties will have three minutes to ask cross examination questions per witness.

A majority of Township Committee and Planning Board members voted to accept the settlement as costs mounted for the township defense, and a key ruling came down from a federal judge saying that the township had treated the mosque application unfairly by asking for more than double the number of parking spaces that would have been required for a church. The number of parking spaces had been set early in the hearing, when experts testified that attendees at worship services at the mosque were more likely to arrive alone or in pairs directly from their jobs. The rule of thumb for church parking is that an average of three attendees will arrive in each vehicle for religious services.

Township Committeeman John Carpenter voted against the settlement. Without specifying why, three Planning Board members resigned from the board about a week or so before the settlement vote in May.

No new Bernards Planning Board members were to be appointed to fill the vacancies created by three resignations a few months ago until after the Aug. 8 hearing, Bernards Township Mayor Carolyn Gaziano said in July.

Gaziano said last month that she does not feel that it would be fair for new board members to be required to preside at that public hearing without having served on the board during any of the three-year-plus history of hearings on the ISBR's application.

She also said that she would not want new board members with no background knowledge on the application to serve at the August hearing.

On May 18, prior to the final vote on the legal settlement, Planning Board Chairman Jeffrey Plaza and two other board members, Paula Axt and Leon Harris, tendered brief resignations that did not mention the mosque.

The township's insurance coverage paid for a $3.5 million payout from the township that is part of the settlement agreement, Township Administrator Bruce McArthur said in response to a question following a Township Commitee meeting last month. The insurance also covered much, but not all, of the cost of the township's representation as well, officials said.

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News

Basking Ridge

Sleep out at Covenant House

June 18, 2018

I can enjoy the same movies over and over like it were the first time to see them.  My kids roll their eyes at this.  Well, many unimaginable things happen as you become a certain age, and you tend to learn to accept those things graciously as gift.   But I remember the movie “The Blind Side.”  Until I saw that movie, I didn’t know homeless children ...

Upcoming Events

Fri, June 22, 9:00 AM

The Wayrick Gallery, Scherman Hoffman Wildlife Sanctuary, Bernardsville

NJ Audubon: NJ Audubon Photography Instructors’ ...

Arts & Entertainment Green

Sat, June 23, 9:00 AM

The Wayrick Gallery, Scherman Hoffman Wildlife Sanctuary, Bernardsville

NJ Audubon: NJ Audubon Photography Instructors’ ...

Arts & Entertainment Green

Sun, June 24, 9:00 AM

The Wayrick Gallery, Scherman Hoffman Wildlife Sanctuary, Bernardsville

NJ Audubon: NJ Audubon Photography Instructors’ ...

Arts & Entertainment Green

Horse Care Workshops at Lord Stirling Stable Start June 23

June 17, 2018

BASKING RIDGE, N.J. — Somerset County Park Commission Lord Stirling Stable is offering Horse Care Workshop 101 for adults and youth seeking to gain experience and confidence around horses through a combination of non-riding activities and hands-on practice.

Horse Care Workshop 101 will be held at Lord Stirling Stable, 256 South Maple Avenue in Basking Ridge, NJ beginning Saturday June ...


AtlantiCast Episode 17

On this week’s AtlantiCast, it’s National Men’s Health Month, so check out important health tips for you or the men in your life, learn about groundbreaking research into breast cancer treatment that could mean an end to chemotherapy for some patients, meet a local sports hero who’s living his baseball dreams thanks to Goryeb Children’s Hospital and much ...