Law & Justice

Judge: State Court has Jurisdiction On Resident’s Complaint that Planning Board, Committee Votes on ISBR Settlement Violated OPMA

5739bd208ff6f93bba43_ISBRTreesbyHouse.jpg
A sprawling home at 124 Church St. in the Liberty Corner section of Bernards Township is the location of a proposed 4,250-square-foot mosque to be built by the Islamic Society of Basking Ridge. Credits: By Linda Sadlouskos
5739bd208ff6f93bba43_ISBRTreesbyHouse.jpg

BERNARDS TWP. , NJ - A federal judge has sent back to state Superior Court a citizen’s complaint surrounding the township’s settlement of a lawsuit with an Islamic group seeking to build a mosque in Bernards Township.

U.S. District Judge Michael A. Shipp ruled in favor of township resident Cody Smith’s motion on Nov. 29.

Smith filed a motion May 25 in Superior Court claiming the township violated the state Open Public Meetings Act by failing to provide proper notice of a meeting on May 23 when the Planning Board and Township Committee voted to enter agreements settling a case brought by the Islamic Society of Basking Ridge.

Sign Up for E-News

Smith’s suit claims the public was not informed of the terms of the settlements nor allowed to comment on the vote until after it had been taken.

On May 30 U.S District Court incorporated the township bodies’ passage of settlement agreements into the federal lawsuit brought by ISBR. The township claimed the lawsuit interfered with a federal order in the action brought by ISBR.

Shipp ruled that the burden failed to meet the legal standard to overcome the legal presumption that Smith’s action should be remanded to state court. The judge noted the legal presumption is that the OPMA matter should be, if possible, determined in state court. 

The township’s legal brief argued the agreement was incorporated into the federal ISBR litigation and the court had kept jurisdiction “for all purposes” related to the terms of the agreement.

Shipps’ ruling said it found “unpersuasive” the township’s argument that because the federal court has jurisdiction over the ISBR’s suit, it has ancillary jurisdiction over a challenge to the validity of the case’s settlement.

 In March 2016, the Islamic Society of Basking Ridge (ISBR) sued Bernards Township alleging it had discriminated against the Islamic Society when it declined to approve construction of a mosque on a Liberty Corner area lot that opponents argued was too small. A few months later, the U. S. Department of Justice filed a second lawsuit against the township.

The Township Committee and Planning Board at a public meeting on May 23 voted to settle the two lawsuits.  The agreement required the payment of $3.25 million to the ISBR and its attorneys, as well as grant zoning variances to allow the mosque to be built.

Smith’s lawsuit alleges the township entered into the settlements with the mosque proponents without publicly disclosing the terms beforehand, as required by the OPMA.

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News

Basking Ridge

Library System Embarking on New Strategic Planning Process for 2018

April 25, 2018

BRIDGEWATER, NJ - The Somerset County Library System is ready to embark on a process to improve experiences for its patrons.

With the most recent strategic plan having been completed in 2017, the system is preparing to create a new one.

“It’s time for us to look again at what our communities need, and how the library can respond in a way that has an impact,” said ...

Travels Spotlight - New Brunswick Ciclovia opens 2018 Season

April 18, 2018

NEW BRUNSWICK  – New Brunswick Ciclovia will open its 2018 season on Sunday, April 22 for another fun day of open streets and active living for all. 

Now in its fifth year, New Brunswick Ciclovia is a family-friendly event that emphasizes healthy living and community building by opening our streets and offering programming for all to enjoy. From 11 a.m. to 4 p.m., more ...

Reduce Your Risk for Colorectal Cancer

April 25, 2018

Morristown Medical Center’s Carol G. Simon Cancer Center presents “Protecting Your Colorectal Health” on Tuesday, May 1 from 6:00 to 8:00 p.m. at the Morristown Medical Center Health Pavilion, 333 Mount Hope Avenue in Rockaway. Admission is free.

This popular, educational program presents an opportunity to hear up-to-date presentations from ...