Belmar Reaches Agreement with Water Contractor in Dispute over Pared-Back Contract

Belmar has settled a lawsuit over the cost of a contract for a water infrastructure project in this southwestern section of town, bounded by 16th Avenue, pictured here, and Routes 71 and 35. Credits: Cathy Goetz

BELMAR, NJ — Belmar has agreed to pay $230,000 to settle a lawsuit with a contractor hired for a major water infrastructure project in the southwestern corner of the borough.

The borough council on November 8 authorized the settlement with Metra Industries of Little Falls, which was awarded a $900,000 contract in 2013 to clean and reline the water pipelines in the residential area commonly known as the Rhode Island Point. For years, residents of Briarwood Road, Pine Tree Way, Maplewood Road and Oakwood Road have been plagued by brown water running through their taps.

However, shortly after the water improvement project began, it was discovered by Metra and the Belmar Public Works Department that the discolored water was not being caused by the aging lines. Instead, the valves on the underground pipelines had been shut off, causing them to be dead-ended and resulting in the rusty-looking water. “The water had nowhere to go and created the brown water,” said Borough Administrator Colleen Connolly. “Now that the system is working as it should; the water is clear.”

Sign Up for E-News

Since the major part of the work was no longer needed, the borough sought to have the contract reduced — triggering legal action by Metra. While it was determined Metra completed about $150,000 worth of the work, the company maintained it should be paid no less than $400,000 due to “reasonable expectations” of the contract, according to former borough attorney William Northgrave, who represents Belmar in the litigation.

Under the proposed settlement recommended by Northgrave, the borough has agreed to pay Metra $230,000 rather than go to trial, which would have meant $30,000 to $50,000 in additional legal fees and no guarantee of a judgment in its favor. “This is the very best we could have done at trial,” said Northgrave.

Although Mayor Matthew Doherty voted to approve the settlement, he voiced his frustration over “having to pay (Metra) $80,000 for work they didn’t do.”

Connolly pointed out that the settlement is being paid through the water utility’s account without incurring debt. That’s because the borough’s recent renegotiation of its water contract with New Jersey AmericanWater Co. has resulted in substantial savings that is reflected in the water utility’s 2017 budget, she explained.

TAPinto Belmar/Lake Como is Belmar and Lake Como’s only free daily newspaper. Accredited by the New Jersey Press Association, it is a locally owned news organization serving the community. Sign up for our free daily e-News, and follow us on Facebook and Twitter.


TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News

Belmar/Lake Como

Belmar and Lake Como

November 20, 2017

Belmar Police Department reported the following arrests occurred in Belmar and Lake Como from October 1, 2017 to October 28, 2017.


Paige Brandao, 24, of Milltown was arrested on 16th Avenue on October 1 by Police Officer Joseph Clayton, charged with driving while under the influence.

Vincent Calogero, 61, of Belmar was charged with contempt on an outstanding warrant after his ...

Upcoming Events


Tue, November 21, 6:30 PM

Belmar Arts Center, Belmar

Belmar Arts Center Writers Group


Fri, November 24, 1:00 PM

Belmar Arts Center, Belmar

Escapism: A Solo Exhibit by Brittany James


Fri, December 1, 5:30 PM

Pyanoe Plaza, Belmar

Belmar Tree Lighting


Sat, December 2, 4:30 PM


Third Annual Main Street Experience


Sat, December 2, 6:00 PM

Lake Como Borough Hall, Lake Como

Lake Como Holiday Tree Lighting


Sun, December 3, 12:00 PM

The Stone Pony, Asbury Park

Beach Music Studios 13th Annual Holiday Party

Model Train Show in Union: 'Decades-Long Labor of Love' for the Holidays

November 17, 2017

UNION, NJ — The Model Railroad Club's annual Holiday Sound and Light Show will open on Friday, November 24, featuring its sprawling, meticulously detailed HO scale model train layout at the A. Paul Mallery Model Railroad Center in Lenape Park, off Route 22 East.

For the event, the railroad center is transformed into a living theater, complete with sound and lighting effects, and ...

Glimmer Glass Bridge in Brielle to Remain Closed

November 17, 2017

BRIELLE, NJ — The Glimmer Glass Bridge which connects Brielle and Manasquan along Fisk Avenue, will remain closed while Monmouth County evaluates what work is still needed before it can be reopened.

The bridge had been slated to reopen on November 16, but the need for additional repair work was discovered during scheduled routine maintenance of the 279-foot span, which serves as a vital ...

DEP: Defends Its Role in Protecting New Jersey’s Environment

November 16, 2017

To the Editor:

The November 14 op-ed by New Jersey Audubon’s lobbyist Kelly Mooij titled, “Sustained, Severe Cuts Equal Setbacks at NJ DEP” paints a misleading picture of how effectively the N.J. Department of Environmental Protection (DEP) is carrying out our mission. Ms. Mooij’s false assertions demonstrate a fundamental misunderstanding of how DEP operates to protect ...

Sustained, Severe Cuts Equal Setbacks at N.J. Department of Environmental Protection

November 14, 2017

Long-term budget and staff cuts have severely impacted the ability of the N.J. Department of Environmental Protection to carry out critical work to protect New Jersey’s environment and residents. This has serious implications for wildlife, public health and our economy. DEP is charged with managing and protecting the state’s environment and natural resources.

This requires an ...

JCP&L Completes Inspections, Maintenance Prior to Winter Weather

November 16, 2017

MORRISTOWN, NJ — In preparation for winter, Jersey Central Power & Light is completing inspections and conducting equipment maintenance on weather-sensitive equipment across its service area.  

Winter’s cold temperatures can produce increased demand for electricity, and heavy snow and wind have the potential to cause damage to poles, wires and substations, requiring crews ...