Law & Justice

McAtasney Pleads Not Guilty to Robbing, Killing Longtime Friend Sarah Stern

Liam McAtasney of Neptune City pleaded not guilty in connection with the murder of longtime friend Sarah Stern, whose body has yet to be recovered.

FREEHOLD, NJ — Liam McAtasney of Neptune City pleaded not guilty on all charges in connection with a robbery plot that led to the murder of longtime friend Sarah Stern.

The plea was entered on May 15 during an arraignment before Superior Court Judge Richard English, who set a pretrial conference date of July 10.

Monmouth County Assistant Prosecutor Meghan Doyle said the state will seek a life sentence without parole in the case against the 19-year-old, who was indicted in April on charges of first-degree murder, first-degree felony murder, first-degree robbery, second-degree conspiracy, second-degree disturbing or desecrating human remains, third-degree hindering apprehension and fourth-degree tampering with physical evidence.

Sign Up for E-News

Because of the aggravating factors, McAtasney is facing life without the possibility of parole.

McAtasney was charged on February 2 in connection with the murder of Stern, who last seen alive on December 2. Detectives determined that he was responsible for killing Stern and stealing property from her on that date. The investigation also revealed that Preston Taylor, 19, of Neptune City provided assistance to McAtasney in moving and ultimately disposing of Stern's body in order to avoid detection.

In April, Taylor pleaded guilty to robbery, conspiracy to commit robbery, hindering apprehension (two counts), tampering with physical evidence and disturbing or desecrating human remains. As part of the plea arrangement, Taylor will testify against McAtasney.

According to the Prosecutor’s Office, Taylor said he knew McAtasney would rob and kill Stern, a longtime friend of McAtasney and Taylor. As part of that plan, Taylor said he always knew that he would get $3,000 of Stern’s money when she was robbed. The pair split up Stern’s money and buried her safe in Shark River Park, Neptune.

Taylor, who was Stern’s junior prom date several years earlier, said he never called police and never backed out of McAtasney's plans to rob and kill her, according to prosecutors.

It is alleged that the men threw Stern’s body into the Shark River from the Route 35 bridge, which connects Belmar and Neptune City and is just minutes from Stern’s home. Their actions were to make it appear that Stern committed suicide.

Meanwhile, investigators said last month they will continue to search the waters of the Shark River below the Route 35 bridge for Stern’s body — in hopes of giving closure to her family.

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News

Belmar/Lake Como

Health Alert: Child with Measles Traveled to Newark Airport on March 12

March 15, 2018

TRENTON, NJ — If you were at Newark Liberty International Airport on Monday, March 12 between 12:45 and 9 p.m., you may have been exposed to measles and should contact your health care provider.

The N.J. Department of Health has issued a public health alert after a child with a confirmed case of measles — a highly contagious disease — arrived in Terminal B at Newark Liberty ...

Upcoming Events


Mon, March 19, 7:00 PM

Belmar Municipal Building, Belmar

Belmar Planning Board


Tue, March 20, 6:00 PM

Belmar Municipal Building, Belmar

Belmar Mayor and Council Meeting


Tue, March 20, 7:30 PM

Lake Como Borough Hall, Lake Como

Lake Como Council Meeting


Wed, March 21, 9:30 AM

Lake Como Borough Hall, Lake Como

Lake Como Mommy and Me Play Date


Thu, March 22, 7:00 PM


Belmar Zoning Board of Adjustment


Sat, March 24, 9:00 AM

Bar Anticipation, Lake Como

Kilt Run to Benefit the Belmar/Lake Como St.


Sat, March 24, 11:00 AM

Second, Third and Fourth Avenue Beaches

Belmar Easter Egg Hunt


Sat, March 24, 12:00 PM

Jake's Downtown, Belmar

Jake's Downtown Slider Saturdays

Building Meadow's Garden & Playground: A Father's Vision to Honor His Daughter

March 11, 2018

PARKLAND, FL — For Andrew Pollack, the loss of his daughter Meadow Pollack in the Marjory Stoneman Douglas tragedy has spurred him to focus his energies on improving school safety and build a playground to honor his daughter.

"I had a vision of, instead of going to the cemetery, I wanted to do something that Meadow would have liked to go to, Pollack said. "I had a vision of ...

Electronics: The Negative Impact on Literacy

March 6, 2018

To the Editor:

As speech-language pathologists across New Jersey prepare to mark National March into Literacy Month,  let’s address the alarming number of young children who spend countless hours a day on a handheld screen.

According to a study from the Pediatric Academic Societies Meeting, the more time that children under age 2 spend on smartphones, tablets and electronic ...

Belmar Firefighters Put Out Bedroom Fire in 16th Avenue Home, Rescue Trapped Dog

March 10, 2018

BELMAR, NJ — Firefighters were successful yesterday, March 9, in containing a house fire at 205 16th Avenue to one bedroom, including rescuing a dog trapped in that room, according to Belmar Fire Marshal Ryan Dullea.

Because the door to the bedroom where the fire occurred was closed, the Belmar Fire Department was able to bring the blaze under control within 30 minutes after receiving ...