Berkeley Heights Board of Ed Not to Pursue Gov. Livingston Physical Education Opt-Out Policy

The Board decided to take the recommendation of Judy Rattner and her administration to not pursue the Option II policy. Board member Bill Cassano initiated the request to administration. Credits: Bobbie Peer
Athletic Director Ann Clifton presented the data behind the administration's decision to not recommend Option II. Credits: Bobbie Peer
GL Student representatives to the Board of Education: senior Amanda Johnson and junior Jimmy Pitingolo. Credits: Bobbie Peer
About 50 students were in attendance at Thursday's BOE meeting. With the majority of students stating they would not choose to opt-out of phys ed. Credits: Bobbie Peer
Full room came out to hear the discussion regarding the Option II policy at Thursday's BOE meeting. Credits: Bobbie Peer
Credits: Bobbie Peer
Team members of multiple GL sports came out to be part of the discussion of the Option II policy. Credits: Bobbie Peer
Board President Doug Reinstein Credits: Bobbie Peer
Superintendent Judy Rattner did not recommend pursuing the Option II policy. Credits: Bobbie Peer

BERKELEY HEIGHTS, NJ - After much discussion at Thursday evening's meeting, the Berkeley Heights Board of Education will not pursue the Physical Education Opt-Out Policy at Gov. Livingston High School. 

The Gov. Livingston administration was asked to explore the opportunity to provide an "Option II" alternative for physical education to students who participate in high school athletics. This would allow students the opportunity to take a study hall while they are participating in a team sport. "Option II" permits boards of education to establish alternative curricular activities/programs aimed at achieving the Core Curriculum Content Standards for promotion and graduation purposes. "Option II" may include, but is not limited to, one or more of the following: co-curricular or extra curricular programs, and/or other structured learning experiences. 

When looking to make a recommendation to change programs or policy, Superintendent Judy Rattner said she looks at the data provided and is required to ensure that all aspects of the district's operation are the board policy, state law and meet graduation requirements. She also advised the standing room only crowd at Thursday's board meeting that the educational programs are focused on educating the whole child and find opportunities for all students. 

Sign Up for E-News

"We feel very strongly that our physical education program and curriculum that we have developed are an integral part of helping produce students that are really truly well rounded children," said Rattner.

Athletic Director Ann Clifton presented the data that backs up the administration team's decision to not recommend that "Option II" be offered to Gov. Livingston student athletes at this time.  Click here to view the presentation. 

The presentation outlined the state requirements stating that state law mandates students grades 1 through 12 must participate in a health, safety, physical education course. The grade, as in other courses or subjects, and the standing of the pupil shall be a part of the requirements for promotion or graduation.

The pros to the Option II policy would provide a student athlete with time to dedicate to pursuing academic rigor and provide a student athlete with time in a busy day to allow them to complete academic assignments.

However, there are many logistical cons to pursuing this policy including:

  • How to manage the continuous flow of students in and out of Physical Education classes. The students will need to report back to Physical Education class immediately after their last athletic competition concludes.
    • Grading completed by non-physical education certified staff (e.g. coaches).
    • Attendance records and crowded study halls.
    • Potential for students to have 172 minutes without direct instruction versus 116 minutes.

The Gov. Livingston handbook states that students must carry 35 credits or seven classes per semester out of an 8 period day. Students have the choice to take a study hall or alternatively, they can take a full course or an elective course. The 2015-16 Gov. Livingston Student Athlete statistics show that 80 percent of student athletes take a study hall and 20 percent of student athletes did not have a study hall.

Many students and parents stood in line to have their turn to approach the board on the topic. While many students showed their support of keeping their phys ed class, stating their various reasons as to why they believe attending phys ed is important to the "whole student." There were a handful of students that stated they would like the opportunity to have an option.

Jimmy Pitingolo, the Gov. Livingston representative to the Board said that he is in favor of having an option. "I swim and have a pretty tough course load, so for me personally, this would be a good program because I chose to take other classes instead of study hall," said Pitingolo. ---"I think it would be useful for any student that choose to opt out without really hurting  the phys ed program because there aren't many students that would. Students get exercise and learn teamwork and sportsmanship from the school sport. For the student athletes that choose not to take study hall for whatever reason, they are already giving up 8 to 10 hours a week towards their sport outside of school and this time could be used for homework, especially for juniors. They would probably find this time very valuable if they use it well. Maybe not a lot of students will do this and will arguably make it easier to implement. But at least the opportunity is there for the students that might really need it and I'm sure there are students that would use it."

Gov. Livingston senior and board representative Amanda Johnson stated that she has benefited from having a study hall in her schedule to get work done. "Throughout high school I have always been able to take all of the academic classes that I wanted and still have room in my schedule for study hall.  And I would personally not want to opt out of gym and replace gym with a study hall. I wouldn't want to lose study hall during health which is an entire marking period or in between sports season," said Johnson. "I know that some other athletes feel the same and have the same concerns. But I can also understand that other situations might benefit with this option." 

Board Members Christine Reilly, Helen Kirsch, Robert Cianciulli and Mountainside representative Jeane Parker agreed with the recommendation of the Superintendent and her administration to not pursue the "Option II" policy at this time.

Board member Chris Reilly was on the fence about the decision because she sees both sides, however, she had concerns of stigmatizing non-athletes or treating athletes differently. "At the end of the day, I have enormous respect for Judy Rattner and her team, and I would be inclined to go with their recommendation." 

Board member Jeane Parker, who also agreed with Rattner's recommendation, suggested the administration incorporate some of the suggestions into the curriculum.

"On the whole, I support keeping the curriculum the way it is and not having an opt out," said Board member Helen Kirsch. "I have real concerns about changing the policies and have great respect for our administrative team."

Board member Denis Smalley believes there are a lot more questions and he would have liked to send back to the administration for more review. "I'd like to make an informed decision with all the information in front of us," said Smalley.

Board member Bill Cassano addressed the misunderstanding of the implications of the "Option II" policy. "It is an option," said Cassano. "The thought was not to add a second study period.. it is to add a study period when there was not one. Or give that student that is taking a study period to give that student the option to take another class instead. Again, an option. If you are not taking a study period, it would alleviate the pressure during the season. When I saw this elsewhere, it seemed like there was no downside to it. Purely optional. Everyone could make it do what they need it to do for them. Or not utilize it."

Board President Doug Reinstein brought the discussion to a close. "I will accept the majority of the board, we should accept the recommendation of the Superintendent," said Reinstein. "I had a chance to speak with many people, in my 12 years on the Board, I am not sure if we have had such direct feedback on many topics as this one."

Reinstein reassured the room that the board does listen to the people on both sides. "There are other creative options -- ways we can get to the spirit of what Bill [Cassano] was trying to do and provide options. I encourage [the administration] to think creatively of how we can do the best for options." 

"I personally think there are merits," said Reinstein. -- "Take those thoughts and continue our entire program including our physical education program the best it can be." 

Next, the Finance Committee will meet on January 31 at 7 p.m. in the Music Room at Columbia Middle School to discuss the High School, Middle School, Athletic, Technology and Administration budgets.

TAP Into Another Town's News:

Sign Up for E-News

Berkeley Heights

I will draw on my experience to deliver a great future for Berkeley Heights

May 22, 2018

I am impressed with the day-to-day leadership of our Mayor and Town Council and I hope to help them continue to do great work. As I have been doing my research since deciding to run for a seat on our Town Council, I have learned a few things about all the work that has been happening in recent years.  For example, while plans for the Stratton House development were recently announced, our ...

Christopher Rinaldi for Town Council - Leadership, Judgement, Experience

My name is Christopher Rinaldi.  As a long-time member of the Republican Party, I am running in the Republican Primary on June 5th for Township Council and Republican Municipal Committee of Berkeley Heights.

As a follow-up to my Candidate Statements from the last two weeks, I would like to share with you a few areas of direct work experience garnered over the past 25 years that I believe ...

Redevelopment: Taking the First Step Together While Protecting Berkeley Heights

Redevelopment. It’s something that takes careful planning, foresight, the ability to negotiate for the most favorable outcome, and, of course, patience. I’m proud to say that we’ve been able to reach all of these milestones. Tomorrow, on Wednesday, May 16, 2018, we as a community will take the first step together in the culmination of these efforts, when the ...

How the Holi Color Festival Came to Summit; Event Planner Shares Her Story

May 21, 2018

Back in India, Holi was a holiday observed by almost all states. The holiday would be declared at all educational institutes and offices. It's a two day spring festival also known as the festival of colors. The festival signifies the victory of good over bad, the arrival of spring with the fragrance of flowers in the air and aura of warmth and happiness.

Holi festival is the time ...

Rain Didn't Dampen Our Vision for Art in the Park

The rain did not dampen our vision for Art in the Park!! Columbia Middle School was transformed into an art paradise, filled with an array of artists whose talents are nothing short of magical! The Peppertown Park Art in the Park Committee would like to thank all of the artists who came to our very first Art in the Park event. We are in awe of your creativity and immeasurable talents! You all ...

Mindfulness Meditation Session Begins Program on Nutrition at New Providence Library

May 23, 2018

Dr. Kavita Kewalramani, a board certified Internist at K Primary Care and Medical Nutrition Center in New Providence, will start with a short mindfulness meditation session, followed by the latest research on how mindful nutrition helps to improve your health and weight. Dr. K will also share a recipe for healthy protein bites which will be sampled by the audience, and discuss her weight loss ...

Amazon’s Career Choice program wins “Community Excellence” award

EDISON, NJ - Amazon’s Career Choice program recently received the “Community Excellence” award from the New Jersey Community College Consortium for its impact on the local community.

Steven Johnson, Amazon’s Director for Associate Development, was on hand to accept the award and lead a panel discussion on how the program provides trained, motivated employees for ...

Michelle Greco: The Logical Choice

Credentials and Expertise.  These are basic qualities that any headhunter, supervisor, manager, or hiring partner demands when looking for a new work colleague to bring on board.  

It comes as no surprise, then, that the Berkeley Heights Republican Municipal Committee (RMC) engaged in the same analysis and looked for these essential criteria to fill Republican ...

Fallout Continues from Lawsuit Against Mountainside; Police Chief on Administrative Leave

May 19, 2018

MOUNTAINSIDE, NJ – Police Chief Allan Attanasio is the latest member of the police department to suffer repercussions from a complaint filed against the borough on May 11.  Attanasio, who is not named as a defendant in the lawsuit, was “placed on administrative leave,” on Thursday by Borough Administrator and former Police Chief James Debbie, said  Lt. Joseph ...

Video Shows School Board Member In Altercation With Police at Traffic Stop in South Orange

May 16, 2018

SOUTH ORANGE, NJ - South Orange Maplewood School Board Member Stephanie Lawson-Muhammad got into an altercation with a South Orange police officer who stopped her for speeding last month, in which she used profanity, complained when she was issued a ticket and called South Orange Police Chief Kyle Kroll “a skinhead cop.”

Lawson-Muhammad also appeared to suggest that she would ...

Upcoming Events


Wed, May 23, 12:00 PM

Passaic River Park, Berkeley Heights

The Ducks Are Here

Arts & Entertainment Giving Back

Thu, May 24, 9:30 AM

Junior League of Summit Thrift Shop, Summit

Here Comes Summer! Junior League of Summit Thrift ...

Giving Back Green

Fri, May 25, 9:30 AM

Junior League of Summit Thrift Shop, Summit

Here Comes Summer! Junior League of Summit Thrift ...

Giving Back Green

Sat, May 26, 9:00 AM

Miller-Cory House Museum, Westfield

Aunt Carrie's Attic Sale

Giving Back Other

Sat, May 26, 2:00 PM

New Providence

Memoir Writing Workshops @ NPML

Arts & Entertainment

Thu, May 31, 11:30 AM

Canoe Brook Country Club, Summit

Fortnightly Club Scholarship Luncheon

Food & Drink Giving Back

Don’t Make These Three Mistakes About Social Security

Social Security has been around for decades and it’s not about to disappear. Why? Social Security is not an entitlement ("gift") that can be taken away - it’s a forced savings scheme that Americans pay into in their working years in order to secure a pension for life. Ideally, Social Security should not be your sole source of income in retirement but even comfortable ...