Berkeley Heights Board of Education Investigated by NJ Department of Education for Turf Field Donations at Governor Livingston

BERKELEY HEIGHTS, NJ - The Berkeley Heights Board of Education is being investigated by the New Jersey Department of Education for allegations that the district gives a yearly donation to a foundation for construction of a turf field.  In a letter to board president Paul Beisser from Robert Cicchino, director of the Office of Fiscal Accountability and Compliance at the State Department of Education, the state received complaints that the district gives a yearly donation to the Highlander Foundation, a non-profit organization established to fund the installation of a synthetic turf field at Governor Livingston High School in Berkeley Heights.

According to the executive summary that accompanied the letter, after a public bond referendum in 2005 defeated the funding of the synthetic turf field, the Highlander Foundation was formed in an effort to raise the necessary funds. The foundation was unable to collect all of the necessary funds through donations and obtained a $252,838 loan for the balance needed to fund the project.

During June 2006, the board voted to allocate $23,000 of its capital improvement school budget to be paid to the foundation for 10 years, ostensibly in lieu of cost savings in maintenance charges for the field and to assist the foundation in the repayment of its debt.

Sign Up for E-News

During September 2006, the board accepted the foundation's donation of the synthetic turf playing surface at Governor Livingston, plus new football goal posts, soccer goals, sleeves and netting for lacrosse goals, pavement of the "D" zones, and the installation of the rubberized surface for the long jump, high jump and pole vault pits.

The district made the first of its scheduled $23,000 payments to the foundation on Sept. 26, 2006. The description of the payment is "annual payment for the GLHS Athletic Field." The yearly payments are charged to three separate accounts and the amount charged to each account is approximately one-third of the $23,000. The district has charged different accounts each year, but none of the payments have been charged to Capital Outlay - Construction Services. The payments are split between custodial and landscaping maintenance, supplies and athletic supplies.

According to the state's investigation, the payment of the $23,000 has not been for maintenance or supplies but would be more accurately described as a capital improvement.

"The use of district funds for capital improvement requires voter approval," the report states. "Additionally, the payments to the foundation cannot be traced to a line item in the budget that accurately represents the use of the funds."

The report goes on to say that expenditures related to the turn field installation should be charged as Capital Outlay - Construction Services, which is used to record activities funded by current revenues concerned with, among other things, improving sites.

The state now wants the Berkeley Heights school district to refund $4,724.65 in state aid to the Department of Education.

At its meeting on Thursday, Sept. 16, the Board of Education approved a resolution stating its intention to appeal the findings of the Department of Education. The resolution says the board's payments to the Highlander Foundation do not constitute a donation of public funds, and that the board received value in the form of the donated synthetic turf field far in excess of any funds paid to the Highlander Foundation. The resolution also states that the board did not enter into a contract with the Highlander Foundation, so it did not violate the state's bidding requirements.

The resolution goes on to say that even if the board did enter into an implied de facto contract with the Highlander Foundation, it was for a single project relative to the construction, reconstruction or rehabilitation of public property and therefore did not violate the provisions of the statute.

The resolution also claims the board's records accurately reflect the nature of the payments made. It also questions two of the statutes the state quoted in its findings, one of which the board claims doesn't exist.

In a letter to Superintendent Judith Rattner from Charles Heard, Jr., of Noke and Heard, LLP, Certified Public Accountants, Heard said the board's agreement with the foundation calls for a payment of $23,000. Since the board has a "qualified purchasing agent," the statutory bid threshold is $29,000 so, in his opinion, the expenditure was less than the bid requirement.

Heard goes on to say that the board's original resolution did not bind the board to future payments and as a result, each year's payment would be approved or not approved in future year's budget proposals. He added that the payment of $23,000 annually did not result in the purchase of a capital item and, as a result, should not be classified as a capital item.

"It was the intent of the board to reimburse the foundation for the annual savings which resulted from the donation of the turf field," Heard's letter says. "These savings resulted in lower costs for supplies, maintenance, labor, etc. It would seem, therefore, prudent to reflect these expenditures against budget categories from which the cost would have been applied had these been incurred under the uniform chart of account, established by the Department of Education."

The board's legal counsel is preparing the necessary paperwork to file an appeal with the state.

Click here to read the Board of Education resolution and the opinion of the certified public accountants.

Click here to read the letter from the New Jersey Department of Education in its entirety.

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News

Berkeley Heights

Honoring Sacrifice and Service on Memorial Day

May 25, 2018

On Monday, May 28, 2018, our Nation celebrates our most solemn event, Memorial Day.  In Berkeley Heights tradition, we will honor those who sacrificed themselves so that we may continue to live in the greatest country on earth.  I invite all residents to join us for the parade festivities and, most importantly, gather at our Veteran’s Park for a brief ceremony.

America has ...

Logic and Sensible Spending Take Priority

Logic.  It's what people use when endeavoring to complete things in the most sensible order.  Everyone knows that "logic" means sequencing events in a formulaic, predictable manner.  We learned this at a young age, as we observed Star Trek on TV and came to understand why Captain James T. Kirk relied on Spock as his first officer because his strategic plans were ...

I will draw on my experience to deliver a great future for Berkeley Heights

I am impressed with the day-to-day leadership of our Mayor and Town Council and I hope to help them continue to do great work. As I have been doing my research since deciding to run for a seat on our Town Council, I have learned a few things about all the work that has been happening in recent years.  For example, while plans for the Stratton House development were recently announced, our ...

How the Holi Color Festival Came to Summit; Event Planner Shares Her Story

May 21, 2018

Back in India, Holi was a holiday observed by almost all states. The holiday would be declared at all educational institutes and offices. It's a two day spring festival also known as the festival of colors. The festival signifies the victory of good over bad, the arrival of spring with the fragrance of flowers in the air and aura of warmth and happiness.

Holi festival is the time ...

Rain Didn't Dampen Our Vision for Art in the Park

The rain did not dampen our vision for Art in the Park!! Columbia Middle School was transformed into an art paradise, filled with an array of artists whose talents are nothing short of magical! The Peppertown Park Art in the Park Committee would like to thank all of the artists who came to our very first Art in the Park event. We are in awe of your creativity and immeasurable talents! You all ...

Jewish Transgender Activist Abby Stein Speaks at Summit's Congregation Beth Hatikvah June 10

May 27, 2018

SUMMIT, NJ - Congregation Beth Hatikvah (CBH) will celebrate 'LGBTQ Pride Month' with a visit from Abby Stein, who will share her unusual and inspirational story of transition from Hasidic rabbi to transgender activist during a wine and cheese reception held June 10 at 4:30 p.m.

Stein, a direct descendant of the Baal Shem Tov -- founder of the Hasidic movement ...

Union County 4-H Teens Pitch in for Geology Open House

Members of the Union County 4-H Teen Service Club volunteered as docents at the Rutgers Geology Museum last Saturday for a National Science Foundation program called In Search of Earth’s Secrets: A Pop-Up Science Encounter.

The students helped visitors navigate the interactive exhibits, as part of a collaborative project including the Rutgers University Department of Marine & Coastal ...

Union County College President Received Prestigious Award from Phi Theta Kappa International Honor Society

CRANFORD – Union County College’s President Dr. Margaret M. McMenamin was one of 35 college presidents from throughout the nation to receive a Phi Theta Kappa (PTK) Shirley B. Gordon Award of Distinction during PTK Catalyst 2018, the Society’s annual convention, in Kansas City, Missouri, held from April 19-21.

The award honors college presidents who have demonstrated ...

A Better Summer with the Y: Join by May 31 and Have Your Joiner Fee Waiver!

From now through the end of May, new members joining the Berkeley Heights YMCA will have their joiners fee waived, because at the Y we believe that everyone deserves to reach their health and wellness goals. With a savings of up to $95, you can focus on the perks of being a Berkeley Heights YMCA member:

Unlimited attendance to more than 100 group fitness classes a week
• State of ...

Fallout Continues from Lawsuit Against Mountainside; Police Chief on Administrative Leave

May 19, 2018

MOUNTAINSIDE, NJ – Police Chief Allan Attanasio is the latest member of the police department to suffer repercussions from a complaint filed against the borough on May 11.  Attanasio, who is not named as a defendant in the lawsuit, was “placed on administrative leave,” on Thursday by Borough Administrator and former Police Chief James Debbie, said  Lt. Joseph ...

Cycling Champ Laura Van Gilder Returns to Somerville Memorial Day to Defend Race Title

May 26, 2018


SOMERVILLE, NJ – Laura Van Gilder, 54-year-old cycling champion from Cresco, Pa., will return to defend her title at the 75th annual Tour of Somerville on Memorial Day, attempting an unprecedented fifth win in the 25-mile women's race, just one of several races that begin at 10:30 a.m..

The Kugler-Anderson Tour of Somerville, often referred to as the Kentucky Derby of ...

Upcoming Events

Thu, May 31, 11:30 AM

Canoe Brook Country Club, Summit

Fortnightly Club Scholarship Luncheon

Food & Drink Giving Back

Thu, May 31, 1:30 PM

Coppola Ristorante, New Providence

Lunch and Learn: Dental Implants and the ...

Health & Wellness


Thu, May 31, 7:00 PM

Gov. Livingston Cafeteria, Berkeley Heights

Gov. Livingston Hilltop Players Host Annual Relay ...


Thu, May 31, 7:00 PM

Gov. Livingston Cafeteria, Berkeley Heights

Gov. Livingston Hilltop Players Host Annual Relay ...

Arts & Entertainment


Fri, June 1, 6:00 PM

Senior Center of the Chathams, , Chatham Township

Senior Center of the Chathams Glorious Garden ...

Food & Drink Home & Garden

The Evaluation of the College Search

It’s is a bizarre time of year as a college counselor as I find myself at both the beginning and end of this process.  Sophomores and juniors are excitedly and idealistically starting to consider what will be important to them in a school.  At the same time, while only separated by a year or two, my seniors have all committed within the past month to a school and have spent the ...

How to Design Your Ideal Retirement

Would you like to design your ideal retirement? Where do you begin? First of all, what does retirement mean to you? If you’re in a relationship, does retirement mean the same to you as it does to your partner? Do you know if your “ideal retirement” is affordable or just a pipe dream?

In past generations, retirement planning didn’t involve very much. You stopped work ...

Don’t Make These Three Mistakes About Social Security

Social Security has been around for decades and it’s not about to disappear. Why? Social Security is not an entitlement ("gift") that can be taken away - it’s a forced savings scheme that Americans pay into in their working years in order to secure a pension for life. Ideally, Social Security should not be your sole source of income in retirement but even comfortable ...