Berkeley Heights Board of Education Investigated by NJ Department of Education for Turf Field Donations at Governor Livingston

BERKELEY HEIGHTS, NJ - The Berkeley Heights Board of Education is being investigated by the New Jersey Department of Education for allegations that the district gives a yearly donation to a foundation for construction of a turf field.  In a letter to board president Paul Beisser from Robert Cicchino, director of the Office of Fiscal Accountability and Compliance at the State Department of Education, the state received complaints that the district gives a yearly donation to the Highlander Foundation, a non-profit organization established to fund the installation of a synthetic turf field at Governor Livingston High School in Berkeley Heights.

According to the executive summary that accompanied the letter, after a public bond referendum in 2005 defeated the funding of the synthetic turf field, the Highlander Foundation was formed in an effort to raise the necessary funds. The foundation was unable to collect all of the necessary funds through donations and obtained a $252,838 loan for the balance needed to fund the project.

During June 2006, the board voted to allocate $23,000 of its capital improvement school budget to be paid to the foundation for 10 years, ostensibly in lieu of cost savings in maintenance charges for the field and to assist the foundation in the repayment of its debt.

Sign Up for E-News

During September 2006, the board accepted the foundation's donation of the synthetic turf playing surface at Governor Livingston, plus new football goal posts, soccer goals, sleeves and netting for lacrosse goals, pavement of the "D" zones, and the installation of the rubberized surface for the long jump, high jump and pole vault pits.

The district made the first of its scheduled $23,000 payments to the foundation on Sept. 26, 2006. The description of the payment is "annual payment for the GLHS Athletic Field." The yearly payments are charged to three separate accounts and the amount charged to each account is approximately one-third of the $23,000. The district has charged different accounts each year, but none of the payments have been charged to Capital Outlay - Construction Services. The payments are split between custodial and landscaping maintenance, supplies and athletic supplies.

According to the state's investigation, the payment of the $23,000 has not been for maintenance or supplies but would be more accurately described as a capital improvement.

"The use of district funds for capital improvement requires voter approval," the report states. "Additionally, the payments to the foundation cannot be traced to a line item in the budget that accurately represents the use of the funds."

The report goes on to say that expenditures related to the turn field installation should be charged as Capital Outlay - Construction Services, which is used to record activities funded by current revenues concerned with, among other things, improving sites.

The state now wants the Berkeley Heights school district to refund $4,724.65 in state aid to the Department of Education.

At its meeting on Thursday, Sept. 16, the Board of Education approved a resolution stating its intention to appeal the findings of the Department of Education. The resolution says the board's payments to the Highlander Foundation do not constitute a donation of public funds, and that the board received value in the form of the donated synthetic turf field far in excess of any funds paid to the Highlander Foundation. The resolution also states that the board did not enter into a contract with the Highlander Foundation, so it did not violate the state's bidding requirements.

The resolution goes on to say that even if the board did enter into an implied de facto contract with the Highlander Foundation, it was for a single project relative to the construction, reconstruction or rehabilitation of public property and therefore did not violate the provisions of the statute.

The resolution also claims the board's records accurately reflect the nature of the payments made. It also questions two of the statutes the state quoted in its findings, one of which the board claims doesn't exist.

In a letter to Superintendent Judith Rattner from Charles Heard, Jr., of Noke and Heard, LLP, Certified Public Accountants, Heard said the board's agreement with the foundation calls for a payment of $23,000. Since the board has a "qualified purchasing agent," the statutory bid threshold is $29,000 so, in his opinion, the expenditure was less than the bid requirement.

Heard goes on to say that the board's original resolution did not bind the board to future payments and as a result, each year's payment would be approved or not approved in future year's budget proposals. He added that the payment of $23,000 annually did not result in the purchase of a capital item and, as a result, should not be classified as a capital item.

"It was the intent of the board to reimburse the foundation for the annual savings which resulted from the donation of the turf field," Heard's letter says. "These savings resulted in lower costs for supplies, maintenance, labor, etc. It would seem, therefore, prudent to reflect these expenditures against budget categories from which the cost would have been applied had these been incurred under the uniform chart of account, established by the Department of Education."

The board's legal counsel is preparing the necessary paperwork to file an appeal with the state.

Click here to read the Board of Education resolution and the opinion of the certified public accountants.

Click here to read the letter from the New Jersey Department of Education in its entirety.

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News

Berkeley Heights

2018 Gov. Livingston Highlander Softball Clinic Set for March 19

February 20, 2018

Come join and learn from the 2017 Union County Softball Champion Gov. Livingston coaches and varsity players on Monday, March 19, 2018 from 6:30 to 8 p.m.

Activities will include the following fastpitch softball skills:

Batting Techniques
Throwing Mechanics
Base Running

Who: Children grades 1-7 of any skill level or ability

Where: Gov. Livingston High School, 175 ...

Mike Zuko at Salem Roadhouse Cafe

Raised on a diet of The Beatles, Buddy Holly and The Doors, Michael Zuko was exposed first hand to the thrilling music of the legendary 70s NYC club scene. Zuko and the band show a skilled singer-songwriter who is backed by solid musical talent, bringing original, fresh and intelligent lyrics to the stage. A true entertainer, Mike engages the audience fully and leaves them wanting more. Mike and ...

German Language School of Morris County Raises $1,000 for Market Street Mission

February, the month of all things red and romantic with red, hearts, roses, and chocolates, is also a time to show our love of friends and community. Students from the German Language School of Morris County ( and, took that lesson to heart and raised $1,000 for The Market Street Mission (, a Morristown haven for the needy for more than ...

Kick Off for the Relay for Life of Berkeley Heights, Mountainside, New Providence & Summit 

BERKELEY HEIGHTS, NJ - There will be a Kick Off for Relay for Life on Thursday, March 1st. It will be held at the Gov. Livingston High School Cafeteria at 7pm.  The theme of Kick Off is Back TO GL - we envision a future that is cancer free. Everything you need to know about Relay for Life will be presented in an interactive setting. Relay ...

We Need More Women Like Colleen Mahr in Municipal, County and State Government

February 19, 2018

Dear Editor:

I’m proud to support Colleen Mahr for Chair of the Union County Democratic Committee  (UCDC) and am encouraging my Scotch Plains peers to join me.

I was a first time candidate wanting to make a difference in my hometown of Scotch Plains, when Mayor Mahr of neighboring Fanwood stepped in to help me campaign and win my election to be Councilwoman three years ago.

Democratic Party Would Be Making a Big Mistake by Not Recognizing Colleen Mahr's Talents

Dear Editor:

Mayor Colleen Mahr has been a valuable friend to the Township of Cranford. Whether it’s offering advice and assistance during devastating flood cleanup, supporting the Mayor's Council on the Rahway River, or her insight and assistance in meeting our affordable housing obligations, Mayor Mahr is always there for Cranford.

Colleen’s fairness and integrity is ...

Colleen Mahr Is The Leader Our Party Needs

Dear Editor:

My name is Patti Murgo. I am Committeewoman in Linden’s Eighth Ward. I am a life-long  DEMOCRAT, a party activist, and a believer in what being a democrat stands for. Last week, I received a piece of literature from our municipal chairman, Nick Scutari, regarding his “plans” for the County Democratic Party if he is elected county chairman.


Chatham Borough Police Chief Crosson has Retired; Captain Gibbons is Acting Commander

February 12, 2018

CHATHAM, NJ - Phil Crosson Jr., who has been a member of the Chatham Borough Police Department since 1992, retired from his position as the police chief on Feb. 1.

"It came on pretty quickly," Crosson said when reached by phone on Sunday. "I was on vacation for six weeks and I bought a business. I came back for one day and retired."

According to Crosson, ...

‘Reefer Madness’ Comes to Chatham Borough Council; Cannabis Advocates Make Pitch for Chatham Marijuana Shop

February 14, 2018

CHATHAM, NJ - A group of pro-cannabis activists came to the Borough of Chatham Council meeting on Monday night and used the public commentary portion of the meeting to ask the council to support a marijuana dispensary in town.

The advocates, who say they have attended more than 80 town meetings to inform about the benefits of medical cannabis, mentioned the 1936 movie "Reefer ...

Upcoming Events

Tue, February 20

Scherman Hoffman Wildlife Sanctuary, Bernardsville

NJ Audubon: Volunteer Art Show!

Arts & Entertainment Green

Wed, February 21

Scherman Hoffman Wildlife Sanctuary, Bernardsville

NJ Audubon: Volunteer Art Show!

Arts & Entertainment Green

Wed, February 21, 2:00 PM

New Providence Memorial Library, New Providence

The Underground Railroad Documentary

Arts & Entertainment

Thu, February 22

Scherman Hoffman Wildlife Sanctuary, Bernardsville

NJ Audubon: Volunteer Art Show!

Arts & Entertainment Green

Thu, February 22, 6:00 PM

UCEDC, Cranford

Next Level Business Planning

Business & Finance

Fri, February 23

Scherman Hoffman Wildlife Sanctuary, Bernardsville

NJ Audubon: Volunteer Art Show!

Arts & Entertainment Green

Invest Like a Tortoise -- Not Like a Hare

Aesop’s “The Tortoise and the Hare” is a perfect metaphor for the way people go about investing their money. As you recall in the fable, the hare brags about his ability to beat the tortoise and is overly confident about winning. In the investment world, the hare is someone who thinks he or she is great at selecting “winners” and avoiding “losers.” The ...