Education

Berkeley Heights Schools Attorney Explains Ins and Outs of Send-Receive Relationships

MOUNTAINSIDE – Mountainside school officials may be seeking another high school to send its students to instead of Governor Livingston in the Berkeley Heights district, but actually implementing such a move is no easy task.

Speculation abounds as to why Mountainside has asked several other school districts within a 15-mile radius if they would be willing to receive Mountainside freshmen, sophomores, juniors and seniors at their high schools. Reasons range from disappointment by some in Governor Livingston High School's academic ranking, to residents questioning the per-pupil tuition rate Mountainside pays to send its high schoolers to Berkeley Heights.

Despite Mountainside's investigation into other receiving-district options, Helen Kirsch, President of the Berkeley Heights Board of Education, said back in June that her school district and Mountainside are currently in negotiations to renew a contract known as a send-receive agreement, which expires after the 2016-17 academic year.

Sign Up for E-News

Mountainside has been sending its public school students to Governor Livingston for roughly the past 20 years.

Watchung Hills Regional High School school district is the only other district in the area publicly known to be discussing whether to answer a request for proposal (RFP) sent to it by Mountainside on the matter. See related article.

Timothy Stys, the business administrator at Watchung Hills, wrote in an email to TAPinto.net that it is “undecided at this time” if his school district will answer the Mountainside RFP, the deadline for which has been extended to mid-October..

However, should Watchung Hills decide to answer, he said, “at a minimum, the Board would have to prepare a revised demographic study.”

But even if another district, like Watchung Hills, is ready, willing and able to receive Mountainside students, Mountainside would first have to notify the state commissioner of education that it intends to sever its current send-receive relationship, according to Vito Gagliardi, attorney for the Berkeley Heights Board of Education. Notifying the commissioner means that Mountainside would then have to go to court.

“The law says that you cannot end a send-receive relationship without filing a contested case before the state commissioner of education, in which you prove that there would be no substantial negative educational, racial or financial impact on any of the communities involved,” Gagliardi said by phone on Aug. 20. “Whoever wants to end the relationship must file the lawsuit.”

Such lawsuits are argued before an administrative law judge, who acts as a hearing officer for the  commissioner of education, Gagliardi said. Once arguments are heard from attorneys and testimony is given by expert witnesses, the administrative law judge reports his or her “recommended findings of fact and conclusions of law” to the commissioner of education.

If the parties involved are not happy with those findings, the parties can file exceptions with the commissioner, Gagliardi said. The commissioner then looks at the administrative law judge's recommendations, looks at the parties' exceptions and makes a decision on whether to approve ending the current send-receive relationship. Approval from the commissioner is also required to enter into a new relationship.

The commissioner's “decision is a final decision appealable to the appellate division of Superior Court, just as you can appeal at trial court,” Gagliardi said. “There are cases when both parties agree to end a relationship but the commissioner of education would not allow the relationship to be ended.”

Gagliardi described filing a lawsuit to end a send-receive relationship and enter into a new one as “a fairly expensive proposition.” Besides legal fees, lawyers have to be paid, along with experts to write reports and appear in court. 

“It's certainly a couple of hundred thousand dollars, depending on the nature of the dispute,” he said. “That's why you don't see a lot of these cases, because they're expensive and the outcome is somewhat uncertain.”

“The process is set up in such a way to protect children,” Gagliardi said. “You want to have stability. You don't want to see these relationships beginning and ending and children being shuffled from one high school to another.”

Gagliardi did confirm that there have been recent discussions between the Berkeley Heights and Mountainside school districts regarding their existing send-receive agreement. 

He was also emphatic about explaining the difference between a send-receive “agreement” and a send-receive “relationship.”

“They are different,” Gagliardi said.

As an example, he asked hypothetically what would happen starting in the fall of 2017, after the send-receive agreement between Mounatinside and Berkeley Heights expired, if there was no new agreement in place and nobody filed anything with the commissioner of education.

“The law answers that question,” Gagliardi said. “Mountainside kids would still go to Berkeley Heights. Berkeley Heights would charge Mountainside a per-pupil cost. Mountainside would be obligated to pay the per-pupil cost.”

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Like

Sign Up for E-News

Berkeley Heights

TAPinto Berkeley Heights Directory of Advertisers

TAPinto Berkeley Heights is locally owned and operated. We are able to provide you with original, objective and always FREE local reporting of Berkeley Heights news and events thanks to our advertisers. We encourage you to patronize our advertisers and tell them you saw their ad on TAPinto Berkeley Heights:

Adams Fine Clothing, 908-665-0800

Allstate Insurance, Lori Cicali, ...

Blessing of the Animals at All Saints

September 22, 2017

SCOTCH PLAINS, NJ -- Do you have a beloved companion that just happens to be a non-human?

Many of us have friends of all shapes, sizes, and species--and they deserve our gratitude and a special blessing! Bring them to the front lawn of All Saints' Episcopal Church on Sunday, Oct. 8 at 12:00 p.m. for a great celebration. Special treats will be on hand for our ...

Concert for Change: A Musical Fundraiser for Berkeley Heights Democrat Council Candidates

Editor's Note: Wharton Institute for the Performing Arts has issued the following statement regarding the community's use of their facility: 

The Wharton Institute for the Performing Arts’ mission is to provide the highest quality performing arts education to a wide range of students in a supportive and inclusive environment, where striving for personal excellence ...

Fourth Annual Union County Day of Prayer

In the challenging time of racial and religious intolerance as displayed in Charlottesville, fevered anti-immigrant xenophobia and political discord of historic extremes there comes the balance of a nation pulling together to support the victims of Hurricane Harvey.

With this backdrop the Fourth Annual Union County "Day of Prayer and Reflection: Unifying Our Community through Prayer" ...

Imagine Offers Support Groups for Caregivers

MOUNTAINSIDE, NJ -- Imagine is offering support groups for adult caregivers under 60 who are living with a family member’s chronic or terminal illness. The groups are safe spaces in which people can express their feelings, and gain support from fellow caregivers. 

The criteria for participation includes: caring for any person with a diagnosis of physical illness, injury or ...

Kenilworth Student Approached by Stranger asking to Give Her a Ride Home, Police Say

September 17, 2017

KENILWORTH, NJ – A David Brearley High School student was approached by an unknown man who asked if she wanted a ride home while she was walking home from school this week.

According to Kenilworth police, the driver was a white male with gray hair who was between 30 and 40-years-old. The man approached the student near the Boulevard and Coolidge Drive at approximately 4:30 p.m. on ...

Robbery Suspect Flees Getaway Car After Fiery Wreck in Short Hills

September 22, 2017

SHORT HILLS, NJ — The afternoon calm along Route 124 in Short Hills was broken when police responded to a report of a vehicle on fire Thursday. Police investigating found that a robbery suspect in a 2006 Mercedes Benz fled the mall parking lot after the driver, Marquis Dixon stole a $500.00 necklace from an individual he met through an app, police said.

As Dixon fled the car he ...

Roselle Park Loves Arts Festival - Schedule of Events for Saturday

September 21, 2017

ROSELLE PARK, NJ - If you are looking for something fun to do this weekend, Roselle Park will be hosting their 3rd annual “RP Loves Arts Festival. This event is all arts, all day, and all free! The fun takes place this Saturday from 1 p.m. to 9 p.m. in the downtown area on Chestnut Street. 

Entertainment will be from the Kean University Dance Theatre, ZCO Dance, Michael Montemurro, ...

An Urban Garden Grows In Elizabeth

ELIZABETH, NJ - Take a stroll on Westfield Avenue in Elizabeth and you will come upon an unusual, lush little farm brimming with tomatoes, peppers and eggplants. The garden, with its perfectly arranged beds, is thriving just feet away from the busy four-lane street.

The garden is one of 18 that are funded by the Union County Means Green Community Garden grant program. The garden helps fund the ...

How to be a Doctor in Seven Years

Who wouldn’t be completely at ease with a 25-year-old performing their open-heart surgery? Joking aside, many students and parents are attracted to accelerated undergraduate/graduate degree programs.  While some of the most common exist in the realms of medicine, engineering, and business, more and more are cropping up in fields like physical therapy, teaching, counseling, and ...

'Be the Change You Wish to See in the World'

September 20, 2017

“You must be the change you wish to see in the world.” These words by Mahatma Gandhi ring so true for us.

We are running for Berkeley Heights Township Council not as Democrats or Republicans, but as representatives of the people who make this town so great, and who would like to see in the Council a true reflection of the people who call Berkeley Heights home.

We live in a ...

Mandelblatt Calls on Rep. Lance to 'Come Clean' on GOP Tax Cut

Lisa Mandelblatt, a Democratic candidate for Congress in the 7th District, today called on U.S. Rep. Leonard Lance to come clean on whether he supports a Republican tax plan that would harm New Jersey taxpayers. 

The American Action Network has launched television ads encouraging voters to call Lance and tell him to “keep fighting for tax reforms.”

The ad is really part of ...

Upcoming Events

Carousel_image_27ffa21d2f7b2b5adcdd_2deab8b3acea97fddccf_photo_20100609_ymca_18_0041_hr

Fri, September 22

Berkeley Heights

Art from Around the World

Arts & Entertainment Education

Carousel_image_27ffa21d2f7b2b5adcdd_2deab8b3acea97fddccf_photo_20100609_ymca_18_0041_hr

Fri, September 22

Berkeley Heights

Art from Around the World

Arts & Entertainment Education

Fri, September 22, 7:00 AM

Berkeley Heights YMCA, Berkeley Heights

Speak 4 Silent Voices Collection Drive

Giving Back

Fri, September 22, 7:00 AM

Berkeley Heights YMCA, Berkeley Heights

Speak 4 Silent Voices Collection Drive

Giving Back

Carousel_image_1643d2a8a911c4a14d33_every_brilliant_thing_graphic

Fri, September 22, 8:00 PM

Dreamcatcher Repertory Theatre, Summit

Every Brilliant Thing by Duncan Macmillan with ...

Arts & Entertainment

Carousel_image_27ffa21d2f7b2b5adcdd_2deab8b3acea97fddccf_photo_20100609_ymca_18_0041_hr

Sat, September 23

Berkeley Heights

Art from Around the World

Arts & Entertainment Education

High Exposure to Company Stock in Your 401K: Good or Bad?

Is it good or bad to have a lot of employer stock in your 401k plan? It depends. Some employees accumulate company stock quickly because their company match is 100% company stock. Other employees load up on company stock because they’re bullish on their employer (and don’t fear an Enron-type recurrence). On balance, employees are holding a declining share of their 401k assets in ...