Real Estate

Berkeley Heights Tab for Acquiring Little Flower Property in Land Swap Placed at $2.8 million

  Real estate appraiser Paul Beisser outlines his methods for assessing the Little Flower and township-owner properties involved in the proposed "swap."   Credits: Bobbie Peer
Real estate appraiser Paul Beisser outlines his methods for assessing the Little Flower and township-owner properties involved in the proposed "swap." Credits: Bob Faszczewski
Berkeley Heights residents pack the audience for Monday's hearing on the Little Flower proposal. Credits: Bob Faszczewski

Updated Thursday, Sept. 18, 2014 at 9:10 a.m.

BERKELEY HEIGHTS, NJ—The township would have to come up with at least an estimated $2,845,000 in order to acquire land currently housing the so-called “Upper Campus” of Little Flower parish in a “land swap” that possibly will result in a new municipal complex being built on the site.

That was the figure given in a memorandum of agreement that is forming the basis of negotiations between the township and the parish. That memorandum would expire on April 1, 2015 if the parties do not sign a formal sale agreement.

Sign Up for E-News

The values used in reaching the sum were outlined by real estate appraiser Paul T. Beisser of Value Research Group (VRG) at Monday’s first hearing into the discussions currently underway between the township and the Roman Catholic parish.

If a purchase agreement were to be finalized between Berkeley Heights and the parish, according to Beisser, the township would acquire a 15.6-acre site bordering on Hamilton Avenue that currently houses a former school building and the church rectory. The parish would take over the 1.33-acre site adjacent to the Little Flower Church on Plainfield Avenue on which the Berkeley Heights Public Library currently is located.

However, according to township attorney Joseph Sordillo, the state’s Local Land Buildings Law allows municipalities to exchange land with private entitiies, but the exchange must take into account the “full and fair value” of property to be exchanged after both entities have appraisals done on the parcels.

Since, in the proposed exchange with Little Flower, the township would be getting property worth more than the property it would be giving up if would have to pay the parish the difference.

The township’s appraisal was done by Value Research Group and Little Flower’s was done by Ard Appraisal Company.

In a May 20 letter to Berkeley Heights Township Administrator Linda Cavanaugh, Beisser said VRG placed the value of the Little Flower property at $4,000,000 and the value of the township library at $1,710,000. Using a somewhat different methodology, Ard set the value of the Little Flower property at $4,500,000 and that of the library property at $1,200,000. Based on those estimates, the amount the township would have to pay could range from $2,290,000 to $3,300,000.

Based on the fact that the township would need to make repairs to the Little Flower property to make it more useful to the township and in consideration of Ard’s considerations in making its proposal, Beisser, in the letter,  said the township should place the Little Flower property value at $4,162,000. Using similar yardsticks for the library property, the township appraiser set a value recommended for the library property at $1,296,000, resulting in a possible township payout of $2,866,000.

The township council has set the following additional hearings on the land swap discussion:

  • September 22 to discuss the agreement between the township and the public library as well as discussing the deficiences in the current library and what is needed to correct them, review of construction cost estimates for the library.
  • September 29 to recap the redevelopment study prepared by Harbor Consultants, the planning firm employed by the township which waz the first step in the Little Flower discussion. There also will be discussions and future needs for the police and public works departments along with a review of construction cost estimates.
  • Octobert 6 to present the draft of the redevelopment plan for the site, the impact of payments in lieu of taxes, a schedule for the project and conclusions on steps needed going forward.

All hearings will be held in the municipal building beginning at 7 pm.

In introducing Monday’s hearing, Michael Mistretta of Harbor Consultants noted Little Flower approached the township in May 2010 with the proposal for the land swap.

Mistretta said the memorandum of agreement between the township and the parish enabled discussions to proceed but it did not, in any way, finalize an agreement for the purchase.

Outstanding questions remaining, he said, include what the township was going to do with the current municipal building and the impact of the “swap” on township taxpayers.

Other items addressed in the memorandum of understanding, he said, are how the library facilities would be temporarily located during construction of a new facility, the status of the statutorily-required millage that the township must raise in support of the library and how much of any excess millage collected by the library could be used to offset some of these costs and overall funding for purchase and development of a new municipal complex on the Little Flower site.

In addition, the memorandum of understanding allows for the township to address any issues it may have with the Little Flower site.

Mayor Joseph Bruno announced that future hearings also will deal with other options that have been discussed for dealing with deficiencies in the current municipal complex facilities.

Contingencies included by Little Flower in the memorandum of understanding, the planning consultant said, are: Archdiocesan approval for the parish to undertake the plan, improvement of the current church and the library property should the plan go forward and any issues the church may have with the library property.

Sordillo said the memorandum also provides that all litigation surrounding the land swap discussions and all appeals surrounding that litigation should be resolved before any land purchase agreement is signed.

A lawsuit by resident Thomas Foregger questioning execution of the process of the redevelopment area designation has been filed but has not been heard in the courts.

A suit by resident Carol Matula calling for an injunction that would prevent the land swap discussions from going forward is in the state appellate division.

Matula pointed out at Monday’s hearing that her suit also alleges that four members of the township council have a potential conflict of interest because they are members of the Little Flower parish and council president Jeanne Kingsley was an officer of the church when the discussions began.

Sordillo said in appellate court the parties are awaiting a ruling on whether the court will require oral argument. Settlement of all litigation could take up to a year, he said.

The township attorney also explained a reverter clause in the original deed under which Little Flower acquired its property from the township.

He said state court cases seem to support the contention that the parish is continuing to fulfill a requirement that its property be used for educational purposes or it would automatically revert to the township. The parish, he noted, continues youth education and some other instruction in the Catholic religion on the site.

He also said the reverter clause would not necessarily prohibit an entity without a direct educational purpose from purchasing the site.

Sordillo told Foregger although case law he used in researching his arguments about the reverter clause currently was not in the packet that would be distributed to the public about the Little Flower agreements he would add references to the case law to the packets.

Former councilman John Bonacci asked Beisser if Little Flower was getting a “bad deal” because the township, many years ago, had purchased a plot of land on Snyder Avenue which contained no buildings for $5 million while the appraisal on the Little Flower tract, which contains buildings, is only $4.5 million.

The appraiser replied 257 apartment units could have been built on the Snyder Avenue site, while the Little Flower site is restricted because it is in an oper space area.

Bonacci also urged the township to spread any plan involving improvements to the municipal complex over several years, doing a little bit at a time, in order to save on the expensive cost of bonding for future improvements.


TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News

Berkeley Heights

Christopher Rinaldi for Town Council - Leadership, Judgement, Experience

May 17, 2018

My name is Christopher Rinaldi.  As a long-time member of the Republican Party, I am running in the Republican Primary on June 5th for Township Council and Republican Municipal Committee of Berkeley Heights.

As a follow-up to my Candidate Statements from the last two weeks, I would like to share with you a few areas of direct work experience garnered over the past 25 years that I believe ...

Redevelopment: Taking the First Step Together While Protecting Berkeley Heights

Redevelopment. It’s something that takes careful planning, foresight, the ability to negotiate for the most favorable outcome, and, of course, patience. I’m proud to say that we’ve been able to reach all of these milestones. Tomorrow, on Wednesday, May 16, 2018, we as a community will take the first step together in the culmination of these efforts, when the ...

I am Proud to be Your Mayor

Honesty and results. Those two principles characterize my service to our community for the last nine years. I served on Town Council for four years and have been your Mayor for five years. I appreciate the opportunity to serve you and our community, steering it in a positive direction. During this time, I have learned about our Town, identified areas for improvement and been privileged ...

Taxes up, Services down.....At least someone is listening

May 15, 2018

Do you feel as if you are getting good services from the town for what you pay in property taxes? I don’t, and wanted to thank the one Council person who voted NO on this year’s municipal budget which will increase your taxes by more than 3 percent, exceeding the cap.  Thank you, Susan Poage, for listening to taxpayers.

When our Mayor grants raises by executive order ...

Who Is Dmitriy?

Who Is Dmitriy?

That is the question I asked myself in the past year or two. I first chanced across him online in community conversation. When an issue seemed to go nowhere, people starting to get ugly and nasty, personal attacks escalating, in would pop Dmitriy and with one comment, he could sum things up. He based his  opinion on information he knew, coupled with what he could glean ...

The NO vote on the Budget

I read today's letter to the editor from Councilwoman Susan Poage regarding her reasons for voting "no" on the town's 2018 budget. As I attend most meetings of our Township Council, including the one on May 8, I want the public to be aware of some facts that are not contained in Mrs. Poage's letter.

The 2018 Budget development process included public meetings on Feb. 26, ...

Kids Can Change The World

May 20, 2018

Karen De La Maza is the founder of “Kids Can Change The World”, a program designed to instill humane values in children while developing essential life skills and positive leadership. Karen and her family relocated to NJ from her native Mexico City in 2008 for her husband’s job.

Karen has always had a strong passion for helping people in need. With ten years of experience in ...

Racing to the Finish and Supporting Cancer Survivors


MAY 13, 2018 SUNDAY | BERKELEY HEIGHTS, NJ—On May 13, the Summit Area YMCA welcomed over 1,000 participants to the 17th Annual Mother’s Day 5K Run/Walk at Memorial Field, in Berkeley Heights. This family-friendly event also hosted a fun magic show, invigorating Zumba dancing, a tot trot, face painting and music.

Matthew Byrne of Berkeley Heights won first place ...

Berkeley Heights Volunteer Rescue Squad Offers Free Community CPR Classes and Plant/Flower Sale to Raise Funds for Relay for Life

BERKELEY HEIGHTS, NJ - National EMS Week – a time to celebrate EMTs and the important work they work do for our nation’s communities was established in 1974 by President Gerald Ford.  This year National EMS Week is May 20 to May 26 and the Berkeley Heights Volunteer Rescue Squad (BHVRS) can think of no better way to celebrate EMS Week than by teaching YOU, our ...

Bee Day at Hanson Park!!

Please join the Hanson Park Conservancy on Saturday, June 23rd for Bee Day at Hanson Park!  At 2:00 PM Grant Stiles from Stiles Honey will be sharing his knowledge of bees with his presentation, “Fundamentals of Beekeeping and the Importance of Honey Bees in Our Society.”  Bring your blankets and chairs and enjoy the beautiful surroundings as Mr. Stiles answers all of your ...

Fallout Continues from Lawsuit Against Mountainside; Police Chief on Administrative Leave

May 19, 2018

MOUNTAINSIDE, NJ – Police Chief Allan Attanasio is the latest member of the police department to suffer repercussions from a complaint filed against the borough on May 11.  Attanasio, who is not named as a defendant in the lawsuit, was “placed on administrative leave,” on Thursday by Borough Administrator and former Police Chief James Debbie, said  Lt. Joseph ...

Video Shows School Board Member In Altercation With Police at Traffic Stop in South Orange

May 16, 2018

SOUTH ORANGE, NJ - South Orange Maplewood School Board Member Stephanie Lawson-Muhammad got into an altercation with a South Orange police officer who stopped her for speeding last month, in which she used profanity, complained when she was issued a ticket and called South Orange Police Chief Kyle Kroll “a skinhead cop.”

Lawson-Muhammad also appeared to suggest that she would ...

Upcoming Events

Sun, May 20, 11:00 AM

New Providence Community Pool parking lot, New Providence

CSA Community Yard Sale

Giving Back

Sun, May 20, 11:00 AM

New Providence Community Pool parking lot, New Providence

CSA Community Yard Sale

Giving Back


Sun, May 20, 11:00 AM

Berkeley Heights Volunteer Rescue Squad Headquarters, Berkeley Heights

Berkeley Heights Volunteer Rescue Squad Offers ...

Sun, May 20, 12:00 PM

Trailside Nature & Science Center in the Watchung Reservation, Mountainside

29th Annual Spring Garden Fair & Plant ...

Green Home & Garden

Sun, May 20, 2:00 PM

Miller-Cory House Museum, Westfield

History of Silhouettes & Craft for Children


Sun, May 20, 2:00 PM

Summit High School, Summit

Summit Symphony Orchestra Concert

Arts & Entertainment

Don’t Make These Three Mistakes About Social Security

Social Security has been around for decades and it’s not about to disappear. Why? Social Security is not an entitlement ("gift") that can be taken away - it’s a forced savings scheme that Americans pay into in their working years in order to secure a pension for life. Ideally, Social Security should not be your sole source of income in retirement but even comfortable ...