Business & Finance

Experts Debate State's Decision to Drop Mandatory Mechanical Inspections of Vehicles

Mike Gelormini

When Mike Gelormini inspected a Honda that was recently towed into his New Providence repair shop, he quickly discovered that the tie rod, a critical component of the vehicle’s steering system, had snapped when the driver—a first-time customer at Gelormini’s shop— swerved to avoid an animal. Despite the wear on the part, which would have been an early alert to most mechanics, the car had a valid New Jersey inspection sticker.

“A good mechanic could catch that before the part weakened to the breaking point,” said Gelormini, owner of Gelormini's Auto Repair. “But since the state dropped the mechanical inspection part of its mandatory inspection program [in August 2010], we’ve been seeing more incidents like this. Many people don’t bother to have their car checked periodically unless the state forces them to.”

The state hires a third-party company to do inspections, and reportedly saved millions of dollars a year by limiting the reviews to emissions-only, at least for most privately held vehicles.

Sign Up for E-News

But newly released data raise questions about the wisdom of that decision, according to a retailers’ organization. In contrast, the state’s decision to trim the inspection process was praised by a driver advocacy group that says safety is a matter of personal responsibility.

“New State Police statistics were recently made available that showed an uptick in the number of traffic related deaths in 2011,” according to Sal Risalvato, executive director of the New Jersey Gasoline, Convenience, Automotive Association (NJGCA). “Unfortunately for state motorists, this marks the end of a five-year trend in which fatalities decreased year-after-year. Looking back on 2011, I can’t help but question if there is any correlation between this new report and the elimination of safety inspections in August of 2010.”

Gelormini doesn’t doubt it, and says he sees the results of that decision almost every day.

“When parents pick up their kids at school, I see more bald tires than ever before,” he says. “People don’t know, or they’re just trying to cut back on expenses. But they’re putting lives at risk.”

Another observer disputes that.

“The automotive repair industry likes government mandated inspections because it spoon feeds them with customers,” according to Stephen G. Carrellas, the director of government and public affairs at the New Jersey chapter of the National Motorists Association. “State mechanical inspections penalize people who service their cars regularly. If they don’t address the problem early on, it will simply cost the owner more to fix it later on.”

Both sides can point to studies that appear to support their respective positions.

A 2009 study by the Pennsylvania Department of Transportation found that “states with vehicle safety inspection programs have significantly less fatal crashes than states without programs,” according to the NJGCA’s Risalvato. “The impact of mandated safety inspections cannot be understated in New Jersey, which boasts the most densely populated region in the country.”

But an earlier study by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration found that “there was no conclusive evidence in the literature that PMVI [Periodic Motor Vehicle Inspection] programs are, or are not, effective in reducing crashes.”

The task force found that PMVI was effective in limiting the number of poorly maintained vehicles on the highways, but “any attempt to correlate this with a reduction in crashes on the highways failed to show any significant effect of PMVI,” it noted.

“Mandating mechanical inspections burdens us all with unnecessary costs in time and money,” says Carrellas. “We think it’s great that New Jersey finally got rid of it.”

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News

Berkeley Heights

Lunch & Learn: 'Israel at 70: Its Meaning and Value in Jewish Identity' with Professor Kenneth W. Stein Apr. 22

April 19, 2018

SUMMIT, NJ - For four decades, Kenneth W. Stein has taught Middle Eastern History and Political Science at Emory University. His scholarship focuses on the politics of the modern Arab world, American foreign policy toward the Middle East, modern Israel, and the Arab-Israeli negotiating process. Stein earned awards at Emory for excellence in teaching and life-long mentorship of ...

Union County Senior Art Exhibit Now Accepting Applications from Artists Age 60 and Older

All senior residents of Union County, age 60 or older, are invited to register now for the Union County Senior Citizens Art Exhibit. Qualifying works of art will be on display at the Atrium of Liberty Hall Center at 1085 Morris Avenue in Union from May 29 to July 9, and the artists will be guests at a special reception at the Atrium on Wednesday, June 6.

The deadline to register is Wednesday, ...

Fourth Season of Live Music at the Ross Farm Kicks Off Sunday, April 22

Indie rocker Mike Mains returns to Basking Ridge to kick off the 2018 Ross Farm Music Series on Sunday afternoon, April 22. The doors open at 2:30 p.m. for the 3 p.m. concert but guests are welcome to come early and stroll the grounds of the historic Ross Farm at 135 N. Maple Ave. in Basking Ridge.

Mains has set himself apart in the world of indie rock, often mixing catchy lyrics and melodies ...

New Episode of “Berkeley Heights Here & Now” to Film Live at City Hall On Thursday, April 19

BERKELEY HEIGHTS, N.J., April 17, 2018 – The Berkeley Heights Communications Committee (BHCC) today announced the latest edition of its monthly show, Berkeley Heights Here & Now, will film live at Town Hall located at 29 Park Avenue on Thursday, April 19 at 7:00 pm.

Mayor Robert Woodruff will provide an update on the revitalization of downtown Berkeley Heights through the ...

Thank You, St. Joseph's Volunteers

April 16, 2018

Thank You from St. Joseph Social Service Center

In recognition of National Volunteer Week, we would like to express our gratitude to the countless volunteers that serve the poor and homeless at St. Joseph Social Service Center in Elizabeth (  Whether you make a sandwich, collect toiletries, tutor in the job program, make soup, wrap Christmas gifts, donate food, ...

New Providence Borough Council to Cultivate Relationships with County Officials

April 12, 2018

NEW PROVIDENCE, NJ – Councilman Robert Robinson touted the importance of personal relationships with Union County representatives at the Monday, April 9 council meeting.

Union County Freeholders Angel Estrada and Bette Jane Kowalski attended the Street Smart campaign kick-off event prior to the meeting providing the council members with the opportunity to chat face-to-face with the two ...

Chatham Township Committee Unanimously Adopts Ordinance to Ban Marijuana Retail Sales; Cannabis Advocates Disagree

April 13, 2018

CHATHAM, NJ - Chatham Township Mayor Curt Ritter began the new year by pledging to oppose Gov. Phil Murphy's plan to legalize the recreational use of marijuana and Thursday night he followed through by voting to adopt an ordinance that prohibits "marijuana cultivation, production testing, manufacturing facilities and retail stores' in the township.

The Chatham Township Committee ...

Upcoming Events

Thu, April 19, 10:00 AM

American Legion Post 433, New Providence

Summit College Club Book Donations

Arts & Entertainment Giving Back

Thu, April 19, 10:00 AM

American Legion Post 433, New Providence

Summit College Club Book Donations

Arts & Entertainment Giving Back

Thu, April 19, 10:00 AM

New Providence Memorial Library, New Providence

Thursday Morning Book Group @NPML

Arts & Entertainment

Thu, April 19, 7:00 PM

Summit Free Public Library, Summit

Think globally, act locally: What you can do to ...

Education Green

Thu, April 19, 7:00 PM

Museum of Early Trades and Crafts, Madison

METC hosting Travelers and Taverns: An Evening ...

Arts & Entertainment Education Food & Drink

Thu, April 19, 7:00 PM

summit free public library, summit

Celebrate Earth Day at Summit Public Library

Education Green Other

Getting Real About Retirement – Will You Have Enough Money to Remain Comfortable?

Let’s get real about retirement. Will you have enough to remain comfortable in retirement for 30 years or more?  Studies show this is a recurring fear many Americans have - and for good reason. Many Americans are completely unprepared to fund a comfortable retirement, and remain naive about the actual costs involved.  As a Fee-Only financial advisor, my number one priority is ...