High Exposure to Company Stock in Your 401K: Good or Bad?

Is it good or bad to have a lot of employer stock in your 401k plan? It depends. Some employees accumulate company stock quickly because their company match is 100% company stock. Other employees load up on company stock because they’re bullish on their employer (and don’t fear an Enron-type recurrence). On balance, employees are holding a declining share of their 401k assets in company stock: less than 7% versus 19% in 1999*. This is generally positive trend but…in some instances it can make tax-sense to leave an employer with a heavy dose of company stock in a 401k plan.

Let’s define some of the pros and cons of company stock concentration in 401k plans and other investment assets:   

  1. A good rule of thumb for all investors is to reduce exposure to any one stock – including company stock – to a maximum of 10-15% of total investments.
  2. This is especially true if you have more than 15% exposure to company stock (including options and Restricted Stock Units) and you are some years away from leaving your company.  

3.On the other hand, if you have more than 15% exposure to your company stock and you are close to leaving your employer, it may make sense to hold company stock to benefit from a special IRS tax break called “net unrealized appreciation.” This tax break affects employees who leave an employer with a heavy dose of company stock in their 401k plans. This strategy is attractive, for example, if your cost basis for company shares is relatively low (see example, below).

Sign Up for E-News

4.Here is the financial trade-off of having a large company position in your 401k: 1) the risk of concentrated company stock tanking and affecting your investment portfolio adversely vs. 2) the potential for tax savings on company stock in your 401k plan when you roll it over after you leave an employer.   

Example 1:

Cynthia works at ABC Inc. Her investments total $2 million: a) stock option grants from ABC ($300,000 value today) and b) her 401k account ($1.7 million) with 400K company stock. In total, Cynthia’s total investment exposure to ABC shares is 35% of her investment assets. Cynthia plans to work another 15 years. What should Cynthia do?

Answer: Cynthia’s overall 35% exposure to ABC shares is too high. She plans to hold her stock options for now but her 401k plan is a different matter. Since Cynthia plans to work another 15 years, it makes sense to cut her ABC company shares in her 401k to zero to reduce her ABC exposure to approx. 15% (the percentage varies since options are leveraged).

Example 2:

Cynthia’s situation is the same as Example 1 but she plans to leave the company within a year and roll her 401k over. Cynthia is willing to assume the risk of continuing to hold ABC shares in her 401k in exchange for the “net unrealized appreciation” tax break:

  1. If Cynthia does nothing and she rolls her entire $1.7 million 401k over to an IRA, all proceeds eventually will come out and be fully taxable at ordinary income tax rates – anywhere from 15% to 39.6% (current rates) when withdrawn. Let’s assume she will pay a weighted total of 25% taxes on her IRA when she takes Required Minimum Distributions, and her IRA does not change in value. She has $400,000 of ABC shares, so she’ll end up paying $100,000 of ordinary income tax on the ABC shares, assuming no change in ABC shares value  VERSUS
  2. Cynthia applies the “net unrealized appreciation” tax break for employees with concentrated company stock positions in 401k plans. Cynthia confirms that her “cost basis” for the $400,000 of ABC shares in her 401k is a low $125,000 (the initial price of ABC 401k company matches and ABC shares Cynthia “purchased” in her 401k total $125,000 vs. the current $400,000 value). Cynthia rolls her $400,000 ABC shares to a taxable account (not IRA), pays ordinary income tax immediately on the $125,000 cost basis, and will pay a lower long-term capital gain tax on ABC share gains when she sells them in the future. (note: the other $1.3 million Cynthia has in her 401k rolls over to an IRA and is taxed in the future at ordinary income tax rates when withdrawn in the future).

By using “net unrealized appreciation,” Cynthia pays a total of $86,250 in taxes on ABC shares that transferred to her taxable account vs. $100,000 taxes owed in the future. Cynthia has saved $13,750 of taxes on ABC shares by utilizing this IRS tax break.

For the sake of simplicity, I’ve assumed tax rates do not change, ABC shares and IRA values do not change, Cynthia’s cost basis for ABC shares is low and she sells her ABC shares relatively quickly.

In sum, it makes sense to limit your investment exposure to company stock but it may make good tax-sense to hold onto high company stock positions to enjoy the “net unrealized appreciation” tax break. Your financial advisor or CPA can help determine if your financial stars are aligned correctly and it’s worth holding out for a tax break while maintaining concentrated company stock risk in the interim. Like so many decisions in financial planning, there is no “one size fits all” answer.

* the Employee Benefit Research Institute and the Investment Company Institute. Data represent 48% of all 401k plan participants.

Eve Kaplan is a Fee-Only (no products sold) Certified Financial Planner® Practitioner with 30+ years of investment/planning experience. Kaplan Financial Advisors upholds the highest fiduciary standards in the planning industry.  Eve opened Kaplan Financial Advisors in 2004 to provide comprehensive financial planning and investment management services to single women and couples. Eve can be reached at 908-898-0549 or Eve@KaplanFinancialAdvisors.com.  Visit her website at  www.KaplanFinancialAdvisors.com


Copyright © 2011-2018 by Eve Kaplan

The opinions expressed herein are the writer's alone, and do not reflect the opinions of TAPinto.net or anyone who works for TAPinto.net. TAPinto.net is not responsible for the accuracy of any of the information supplied by the writer.

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News

Berkeley Heights

I will draw on my experience to deliver a great future for Berkeley Heights

May 22, 2018

I am impressed with the day-to-day leadership of our Mayor and Town Council and I hope to help them continue to do great work. As I have been doing my research since deciding to run for a seat on our Town Council, I have learned a few things about all the work that has been happening in recent years.  For example, while plans for the Stratton House development were recently announced, our ...

Christopher Rinaldi for Town Council - Leadership, Judgement, Experience

My name is Christopher Rinaldi.  As a long-time member of the Republican Party, I am running in the Republican Primary on June 5th for Township Council and Republican Municipal Committee of Berkeley Heights.

As a follow-up to my Candidate Statements from the last two weeks, I would like to share with you a few areas of direct work experience garnered over the past 25 years that I believe ...

Redevelopment: Taking the First Step Together While Protecting Berkeley Heights

Redevelopment. It’s something that takes careful planning, foresight, the ability to negotiate for the most favorable outcome, and, of course, patience. I’m proud to say that we’ve been able to reach all of these milestones. Tomorrow, on Wednesday, May 16, 2018, we as a community will take the first step together in the culmination of these efforts, when the ...

How the Holi Color Festival Came to Summit; Event Planner Shares Her Story

May 21, 2018

Back in India, Holi was a holiday observed by almost all states. The holiday would be declared at all educational institutes and offices. It's a two day spring festival also known as the festival of colors. The festival signifies the victory of good over bad, the arrival of spring with the fragrance of flowers in the air and aura of warmth and happiness.

Holi festival is the time ...

Rain Didn't Dampen Our Vision for Art in the Park

The rain did not dampen our vision for Art in the Park!! Columbia Middle School was transformed into an art paradise, filled with an array of artists whose talents are nothing short of magical! The Peppertown Park Art in the Park Committee would like to thank all of the artists who came to our very first Art in the Park event. We are in awe of your creativity and immeasurable talents! You all ...

Taxes up, Services down.....At least someone is listening

Do you feel as if you are getting good services from the town for what you pay in property taxes? I don’t, and wanted to thank the one Council person who voted NO on this year’s municipal budget which will increase your taxes by more than 3 percent, exceeding the cap.  Thank you, Susan Poage, for listening to taxpayers.

When our Mayor grants raises by executive order ...

Host an International Exchange Student

May 21, 2018

EF High School Exchange Year announces annual search for student exchange host families in communities across the New Jersey

EF High School Exchange Year—a division of EF Education First, the World Leader in International Education—has kicked off its annual nationwide search for caring host families to welcome exchange students into their homes. Last year EF connected over 3,000 ...

Berkeley Heights Community Pool Set to Open May 26!

Tired of the rain and ready for the sun? We sure are! The Berkeley Heights Community Pool at the YMCA is slated to open during the upcoming Memorial Day weekend on May 26! With only one month until summer starts, swimmers can get a headstart jump into the pool during our pre-season opening! 

Join the Berkeley Heights Community Pool at the YMCA today—there are no joining fees, and ...

Mountain Ridge Bible Chapel Presents Special Women’s program


Mountain Ridge Bible Chapel, 763 Mountain Avenue, Berkeley Heights, is very pleased to host a unique free seminar for women on Saturday June 2, from 10:00 a.m. to 2:00 p.m. 

The speaker will be Doctor Ruth Schwertfeger of Brookfield, Wisconsin. Ruth was born in Northern Ireland, is a retired Professor at University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee.  She speaks several languages, and ...

Kids Can Change The World

Karen De La Maza is the founder of “Kids Can Change The World”, a program designed to instill humane values in children while developing essential life skills and positive leadership. Karen and her family relocated to NJ from her native Mexico City in 2008 for her husband’s job.

Karen has always had a strong passion for helping people in need. With ten years of experience in ...

Fallout Continues from Lawsuit Against Mountainside; Police Chief on Administrative Leave

May 19, 2018

MOUNTAINSIDE, NJ – Police Chief Allan Attanasio is the latest member of the police department to suffer repercussions from a complaint filed against the borough on May 11.  Attanasio, who is not named as a defendant in the lawsuit, was “placed on administrative leave,” on Thursday by Borough Administrator and former Police Chief James Debbie, said  Lt. Joseph ...

Video Shows School Board Member In Altercation With Police at Traffic Stop in South Orange

May 16, 2018

SOUTH ORANGE, NJ - South Orange Maplewood School Board Member Stephanie Lawson-Muhammad got into an altercation with a South Orange police officer who stopped her for speeding last month, in which she used profanity, complained when she was issued a ticket and called South Orange Police Chief Kyle Kroll “a skinhead cop.”

Lawson-Muhammad also appeared to suggest that she would ...

Upcoming Events

Thu, May 24, 9:30 AM

Junior League of Summit Thrift Shop, Summit

Here Comes Summer! Junior League of Summit Thrift ...

Giving Back Green

Fri, May 25, 9:30 AM

Junior League of Summit Thrift Shop, Summit

Here Comes Summer! Junior League of Summit Thrift ...

Giving Back Green

Sat, May 26, 9:00 AM

Miller-Cory House Museum, Westfield

Aunt Carrie's Attic Sale

Giving Back Other

Sat, May 26, 2:00 PM

New Providence

Memoir Writing Workshops @ NPML

Arts & Entertainment

Thu, May 31, 11:30 AM

Canoe Brook Country Club, Summit

Fortnightly Club Scholarship Luncheon

Food & Drink Giving Back

Thu, May 31, 1:30 PM

Coppola Ristorante, New Providence

Lunch and Learn: Dental Implants and the ...

Health & Wellness

Don’t Make These Three Mistakes About Social Security

Social Security has been around for decades and it’s not about to disappear. Why? Social Security is not an entitlement ("gift") that can be taken away - it’s a forced savings scheme that Americans pay into in their working years in order to secure a pension for life. Ideally, Social Security should not be your sole source of income in retirement but even comfortable ...