The 3 Main Investment Styles: Pros and Cons


There are pros and cons to investing in the three main investment styles:  active,  passive and “evidence-based investing.The benefits of “evidence-based investing” will be clearer after reviewing “active” vs. “passive” investing styles.

1. Active Investing through Mutual Funds: “Active” investors aim to “beat the market” (or a portion of a market) by investing in a large number of holdings through mutual funds and some Exchange Traded Funds (ETFs). The theory of doing better than the market sounds great but does it work well in practice? As a former active mutual fund manager, I can say: “not sufficiently.” The very premise of “active” investing is making educated bets that some shares will do better than others. However, despite the best research in the world, stocks can disappoint. Having many holdings bundled together reduces some of the risk but some mutual funds do a better job than others. My particular beef  is the plethora of “A,” “B,” and “C” shares of actively managed funds. Investors typically don’t understand the cost of A, B and C shares and the insidious effect of eating away at performance.

Active Investing through Stock Picking:  The investment manager researches companies and markets and assembles stocks or Exchange Traded Funds that he/she believes will outperform in the future as other investors join the bandwagon and drive these shares higher. I once was an equities analysts and I visited individual companies for years and wrote long reports with investment recommendations. Management fees for stock-picking can be comparable to actively managed mutual funds. Does this approach work? Data suggest this is a hit or miss approach. Yes, you could have become an Apple millionaire if you invested in Apple at the right time. And yes, you could have gone bankrupt if you had invested in Enron at the wrong time. If you want to mitigate some of the risk, add up all of the companies in an index – by weight – and invest that way. It’s called passive investing.

Sign Up for E-News

2. Passive Investing:  Passive investors don’t believe it’s possible to outperform markets consistently so they embrace mirroring a market or index. The “passive” approach has gained traction in recent years because it’s clear to many that high fees for active management don’t always translate into better net performance. Passive investment fees are far lower and the chances of growing money as greater than the “active” investing. This approach has been embraced by both mutual funds and most Exchange Traded Funds (ETFs).

Active and passive investors have their proponents and critics. Long term data underscore the relative benefits of passive investing since the majority of active investment managers do not outperform an underlying index for enough time to compensate for the higher fees charged: salaries, administrative fees and A, B and C commissions.

3. “Evidence-Based Investing”: The third approach to investing, “evidence-based investing,” has been developed and refined by Dimensional Fund Advisors (, a formidable powerhouse informed by Nobel laureates. Dimensional Fund Advisors (DFA) began in 1981 and it has nearly $500 billion in mutual fund investments under management. Exhaustive DFA data show there are consistent market anomalies over time that can be captured in DFA mutual funds. In other words, DFA mutual funds are constructed to help investors outperform over longer periods of time.  These funds overweight smaller cap companies vs. larger companies, and they overweight “value” stocks (low book/market ratios) vs. “growth” stocks. This approach is consistent across US and international stock markets over longer periods of time.  DFA can and does deviate from indexes – as needed – to buy or sell “off market” to minimize affecting share prices; unlike passive investing, DFA does not need to mirror an index exactly.  

The success of DFA “evidence-based” investing rests upon some important assumptions:  1.  Market timing doesn’t work. The investor needs to sit through the entire dinner  – even the boring bits – to gain full advantage of long-term investment gains. 2. Investing with a “rear view mirror” (buying what’s already done relatively well) doesn’t work over the long term and 3.  Keeping investment costs low means the investor gets more of the gain (the same approach as Vanguard).

Individual investors can access Dimensional Fund Advisors mutual funds through approved Fee-Only Advisors, through some 401k plans and in some 529 College Plans (e.g. State of Utah). Important note: There is no mark-up by Fee-Only advisors to clients who invest in these phenomenal funds. Please contact my office for more information about DFA funds.

Eve Kaplan is a Fee-Only (no products sold) Certified Financial Planner® Practitioner with 30+ years of investment/planning experience. Kaplan Financial Advisors upholds the highest fiduciary standards in the planning industry.  Eve opened Kaplan Financial Advisors in 2004 to provide comprehensive financial planning and investment management services to single women and couples. Eve can be reached at 908-898-0549 or  Visit her website at


Copyright © 2011-2017 by Eve Kaplan

The opinions expressed herein are the writer's alone, and do not reflect the opinions of or anyone who works for is not responsible for the accuracy of any of the information supplied by the writer.

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News

Berkeley Heights

New Jersey Youth Symphony Announces 2018 Summer Camps

February 20, 2018

NEW PROVIDENCE—The New Jersey Youth Symphony announced today that it will hold two summer camps, Orchestral Camp from June 24 until July 7 and Junior Winds Camp from July 30 until August 3, at 570 Central Avenue in New Providence. Campers can take advantage of a 5% tuition discount by registering before the Early Registration deadline on June 1, 2018. For more information visit ...

Return Berkeley Heights Public Library's Books, etc.

Remember those book and DVDs and other materials borrowed from the Berkeley Heights Public Library before it closed? It's time to return them.

Staff will be at the Municipal Courtroom/Council Chambers at 29 Park Ave. from 10 a.m. to 3 p.m. on Saturday, Feb. 24 to accept them. Enter through the glass door, using the stairs by the Police Department.

For more information, email ...

2018 Gov. Livingston Highlander Softball Clinic Set for March 19

Come join and learn from the 2017 Union County Softball Champion Gov. Livingston coaches and varsity players on Monday, March 19, 2018 from 6:30 to 8 p.m.

Activities will include the following fastpitch softball skills:

Batting Techniques
Throwing Mechanics
Base Running

Who: Children grades 1-7 of any skill level or ability

Where: Gov. Livingston High School, 175 ...

Mike Zuko at Salem Roadhouse Cafe

Raised on a diet of The Beatles, Buddy Holly and The Doors, Michael Zuko was exposed first hand to the thrilling music of the legendary 70s NYC club scene. Zuko and the band show a skilled singer-songwriter who is backed by solid musical talent, bringing original, fresh and intelligent lyrics to the stage. A true entertainer, Mike engages the audience fully and leaves them wanting more. Mike and ...

We Need More Women Like Colleen Mahr in Municipal, County and State Government

February 19, 2018

Dear Editor:

I’m proud to support Colleen Mahr for Chair of the Union County Democratic Committee  (UCDC) and am encouraging my Scotch Plains peers to join me.

I was a first time candidate wanting to make a difference in my hometown of Scotch Plains, when Mayor Mahr of neighboring Fanwood stepped in to help me campaign and win my election to be Councilwoman three years ago.

Democratic Party Would Be Making a Big Mistake by Not Recognizing Colleen Mahr's Talents

Dear Editor:

Mayor Colleen Mahr has been a valuable friend to the Township of Cranford. Whether it’s offering advice and assistance during devastating flood cleanup, supporting the Mayor's Council on the Rahway River, or her insight and assistance in meeting our affordable housing obligations, Mayor Mahr is always there for Cranford.

Colleen’s fairness and integrity is ...

Colleen Mahr Is The Leader Our Party Needs

Dear Editor:

My name is Patti Murgo. I am Committeewoman in Linden’s Eighth Ward. I am a life-long  DEMOCRAT, a party activist, and a believer in what being a democrat stands for. Last week, I received a piece of literature from our municipal chairman, Nick Scutari, regarding his “plans” for the County Democratic Party if he is elected county chairman.


Chatham Borough Police Chief Crosson has Retired; Captain Gibbons is Acting Commander

February 12, 2018

CHATHAM, NJ - Phil Crosson Jr., who has been a member of the Chatham Borough Police Department since 1992, retired from his position as the police chief on Feb. 1.

"It came on pretty quickly," Crosson said when reached by phone on Sunday. "I was on vacation for six weeks and I bought a business. I came back for one day and retired."

According to Crosson, ...

‘Reefer Madness’ Comes to Chatham Borough Council; Cannabis Advocates Make Pitch for Chatham Marijuana Shop

February 14, 2018

CHATHAM, NJ - A group of pro-cannabis activists came to the Borough of Chatham Council meeting on Monday night and used the public commentary portion of the meeting to ask the council to support a marijuana dispensary in town.

The advocates, who say they have attended more than 80 town meetings to inform about the benefits of medical cannabis, mentioned the 1936 movie "Reefer ...

Upcoming Events

Tue, February 20

Scherman Hoffman Wildlife Sanctuary, Bernardsville

NJ Audubon: Volunteer Art Show!

Arts & Entertainment Green

Wed, February 21

Scherman Hoffman Wildlife Sanctuary, Bernardsville

NJ Audubon: Volunteer Art Show!

Arts & Entertainment Green

Wed, February 21, 2:00 PM

New Providence Memorial Library, New Providence

The Underground Railroad Documentary

Arts & Entertainment

Thu, February 22

Scherman Hoffman Wildlife Sanctuary, Bernardsville

NJ Audubon: Volunteer Art Show!

Arts & Entertainment Green

Thu, February 22, 6:00 PM

UCEDC, Cranford

Next Level Business Planning

Business & Finance

Fri, February 23

Scherman Hoffman Wildlife Sanctuary, Bernardsville

NJ Audubon: Volunteer Art Show!

Arts & Entertainment Green

Invest Like a Tortoise -- Not Like a Hare

Aesop’s “The Tortoise and the Hare” is a perfect metaphor for the way people go about investing their money. As you recall in the fable, the hare brags about his ability to beat the tortoise and is overly confident about winning. In the investment world, the hare is someone who thinks he or she is great at selecting “winners” and avoiding “losers.” The ...