The Evaluation of the College Search


It’s is a bizarre time of year as a college counselor as I find myself at both the beginning and end of this process.  Sophomores and juniors are excitedly and idealistically starting to consider what will be important to them in a school.  At the same time, while only separated by a year or two, my seniors have all committed within the past month to a school and have spent the past several weeks weighing the practical implications of this choice.  These families are living in two different universes, separated by the gauntlet of applying and being accepted to colleges.  Witnessing both simultaneously has made me realize how much they could each stand to benefit from the point of view of the other.

Underclassmen and their families are often very student-centered.  When considering what colleges are worth visiting they are often working from a very specific list of wants.  Is the school competitive enough?  Is it in the right environment?  The right size?  Does it offer exactly the right program?  Oftentimes the financial realities of paying for college have yet to enter the equation.  So too are some of the more day-to-day concerns of college life: what will the living situation be like for freshman?  What are the career outcomes?  What will the trip from home to campus be like? 

They are also not considering how colleges will perceive them.  Their “fit” is currently determined entirely on their own terms, instead of imagining how a college will interpret the student’s compatibility with campus culture.

Sign Up for E-News

On the other end of the spectrum are seniors during this spring season.  They are watching those decisions roll in and starting to see college as a tangible eventuality instead of the somewhat fuzzy conclusion of a five-year plan.  There may be some tears mixed in as a denial or two rock the plans they envisioned for themselves.  The conversation at the dining room table is now often dominated by price tags.  Who offered the most scholarship?  The most financial aid?  Are they loans or grants? 

Students are also thinking about whether they can stomach living in a triple to go to their #1 choice and what the walk from the dorm to the dining hall will be like every day.  Is a shuttle ride such a bad thing if it means living in an exciting city?  Will being isolated on a campus in the middle of nowhere be an issue?

For those just starting out, start weighing some of these more tangible aspects of attending college now.  Unless budget is truly unlimited, cost should absolutely be part of the search early on.  Allowing a student to fall in love with a school that is not a financial reality will only lead to heartbreak.  Students also need to look at colleges as if they were looking for a job and an apartment and not just a school.  Will you really be comfortable living there?  What sort of professions will be open to you with this degree?  Do you really want to be that far from (or close to!) home?

And conversely those poor, stressed out seniors and their overwhelmed parents could use a reminder about how excited they were to begin this search.  Try to remember the joy the first time you all fell in love with a school.  Will you be proud to talk about the college you’re attending?  Is it an alumni community you’ll want to stay connected with?  Choosing a school is like falling in love and that final choice shouldn’t be out of obligation alone.  Hopefully if your research was done properly in the beginning it won’t have to be!

I wish I could infuse the juniors with some of the level-headedness and the seniors with some of the optimism.  Aside from the wonderful resources of your college counselors talking with families who have recently finished the application process can be invaluable as you’re starting out.  What lessons have they learned?  What would they do differently if given the opportunity?  This isn’t about trading application secrets or recommending specific schools but more about figuring out where those stumbling blocks were and how they could be avoided.  Unfortunately there’s no way to eliminate the stress entirely but the right mixture of excitement, thoughtfulness, and FUN can help get you to the finish line feeling confident and optimistic for the fall!

Admissions Abridged distills news and trends from the college admissions world to provide college-bound students and their families with helpful tools to approach the application process.

Kate Balboni has earned a Master’s in School Counseling and is a certified New Jersey School Counselor.  She has served as an admissions counselor for Drew University and as a regional admissions coordinator at the University of South Carolina.  During her time in Undergraduate Admissions she has reviewed thousands of applications and student essays, conducted hundreds of student interviews, and has visited over 50 college campuses throughout the nation.  Kate is the owner of Balboni College Advising, a concierge college consulting service, providing one-on-one guidance and counseling throughout the college application process.  For more information please visit

The opinions expressed herein are the writer's alone, and do not reflect the opinions of or anyone who works for is not responsible for the accuracy of any of the information supplied by the writer.

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News

Berkeley Heights

Sleep out at Covenant House

June 18, 2018

I can enjoy the same movies over and over like it were the first time to see them.  My kids roll their eyes at this.  Well, many unimaginable things happen as you become a certain age, and you tend to learn to accept those things graciously as gift.   But I remember the movie “The Blind Side.”  Until I saw that movie, I didn’t know homeless children ...

Imagine Hosts Annual Breakfast Fundraiser

June 24, 2018

Nearly 350 guests attended Imagine’s 7th annual breakfast fundraiser, Seasons of Hope, on June 6th, 2018 at Shackamaxon Country Club in Scotch Plains.  “We especially want to thank our breakfast sponsors -- our platinum sponsor Merck, our bronze sponsors ConnectOne Bank and Northfield Bank, the volunteers and donors that contributed to the breakfast” said Imagine Board ...

Local at-risk youth celebrate year of achievements at Community Access Unlimited

Community Access Unlimited (CAU) last night celebrated the achievements of a number of at-risk youth who are members of the agency's Transitional Opportunities Program (TOP). Each of these youth are within New Jersey's child services system and faced a number of life challenges before coming to CAU and TOP and since then have made significant progress in plotting a brighter future with ...

Union County Residents Can “Recycle Right” without Plastic Bags

The Union County Board of Chosen Freeholders reminds residents that plastic bags and other excluded items cannot be recycled through their local curbside pick-up programs.

“Union County residents have a good recycling rate compared to other counties in our state, and we want to improve on this record and set a high bar,” said Freeholder Chairman Sergio Granados. “Every ...

Seth Meyers Attends Summit Medical Group Foundation's (SMGF) 5th Annual Gala & Auction

Seth Meyers, host of NBC’s Late Night with Seth Meyers, was recently a special guest at Summit Medical Group Foundation's (SMGF) 5th Annual Gala & Auction where a record-breaking $1.35 million was raised. 

SMGF’s Annual Gala & Auction raises critical funds to ensure the Foundation can continue to offer access to high-quality ...

Missing in North Plainfield: Have You Seen Angel?

June 21, 2018

NORTH PLAINFIELD, NJ - Have you seen Angel?

Angel is a seven year old black and white Husky last seen near Westervelt Ave. and Manning Ave. on June 16. Her family says she is very friendly. 

If found, call Andrea at  888-466-3242.


Linden Man Arrested After Explosion in Cranford

June 21, 2018

CRANFORD - On Wednesday, June 20, 2018 at 7:06 p.m. the Cranford Police Department received
information that an explosion was heard in the area of Raritan Road and Summit Terrace. Through
a joint investigation with the Union County Prosecutor's Office and Linden Police Department, the
Cranford Police Department Detective Bureau identified a suspect through surveillance video ...

Upcoming Events


Sun, June 24, 7:00 AM

Summit YMCA, Summit

Pet Supply Drive at the Summit YMCA to Benefit ...

Giving Back


Sun, June 24, 10:00 AM

eMedical Urgent Care, Berkeley Heights

eMedical Urgent Care to Hold Free Teddy Care ...

Arts & Entertainment Health & Wellness


Mon, June 25

Summit YMCA, Summit

June 2018 College Tour



Mon, June 25, 7:00 AM

Summit YMCA, Summit

Pet Supply Drive at the Summit YMCA to Benefit ...

Giving Back

Mon, June 25, 9:00 AM


Kids' Critter Camp


Mon, June 25, 10:00 AM

New Providence Memorial Library, New Providence

Summer Reading Kick-Off: Eyes of the Wild

Arts & Entertainment

What's Hot and What's Not

Summer is a great time to take a step back, sip a cool beverage, and take a look at what’s going on in the world of college admissions.  Departments use the summer to evaluate how their year went and plan on any changes they want to make for the fall.  Did they over-enroll? Under-enroll?  What application materials were useful to them?  Which were redundant or time ...

Cool Ways to Save Money This Summer

As the summer temperatures rise, home cooling costs rise as well. But there are ways to help save money without sweating the heat:

To increase your cooling system’s efficiency by as much as 20%, get it checked out for summer.  A technician will clean the condenser, make sure you have the optimal amount of refrigerant, and ensure the airflow over the coil is ...