Letters to the Editor

Former BOE Member Writes Letter to Board on Superintendent Search

3d1adfd24c5365b115d5_5b0969680de0a2b560de_letter_to_the_editor.jpg
3d1adfd24c5365b115d5_5b0969680de0a2b560de_letter_to_the_editor.jpg

Dear Members of the Board:

With the dust now settled following the resignation of Superintendent Dr. Victor Hayek, it is time to focus on the task ahead: identifying and hiring a superior candidate to lead our wonderful school district. As school board members, hiring a superintendent is perhaps the most important thing you’ll do. It can also be one of the most personally rewarding things you do. It was for me. 

During my tenure on the board, the district hired Dr. Michael Schilder as superintendent.  Mike served the district for almost seven years and, with the team he assembled, helped the district soar not just in national and state rankings but equally in academic and non-academic achievement, community involvement, staff morale and conservative budgetary practices. I suspect by most measures he was the most successful superintendent hire the district made in decades.

Sign Up for E-News

Hiring a superintendent is a daunting task. Because of Gov. Christie’s freeze on superintendent salaries, many qualified candidates have left the state for better paying jobs elsewhere, leading to a smaller candidate pool generally. Because of the size, complexity and quality of our district, the candidate pool shrinks more as the qualifications you should require hopefully further limit the cohort of qualified applicants.  And of course, there are many school districts in NJ that will be targeting the same applicants you may covet, making competition for the best applicants fierce.

You will also have to contend with Bridgewater-Raritan’s well-earned (but not wholly accurate) reputation as a school district that can’t keep a superintendent. Factors here that will impact the process include the short average tenure of superintendents in the district (other than Dr. Schilder), speculation surrounding Dr. Hayek’s quick departure, this board’s propensity for challenging superintendent-recommended programs and initiatives, and the level of management exercised by this board, as heard on recordings of board meetings this year and last in particular.    

The good news is that, notwithstanding the above, Bridgewater-Raritan remains a highly respected and desirable school district and one that candidates seeking a larger or higher achieving district or a bigger job within the district will still find appealing.  A successful search could very well be a wonderful opportunity for the district to not only survive the next transition, but to thrive as well.

Having co-chaired the search that resulted in the hiring of Dr. Schilder with Dr. Patricia Camp, BOE president at the time, and participating in the several searches that followed, I know the process and the players well. For the past 19 years, I’ve also run two successful recruiting firms. Because of my experience in the district and with this task, I share with you some suggestions you may want to consider as you perform the search.

  1.  Abandon your current position that specific criteria shouldn’t be required and instead establish objective criteria you will require in your next superintendent. With almost 9,000 students and almost 1,000 employees in the district, it is indeed important that you require a minimum level of applicable experience rather than rely solely on gut feelings. I believe a minimum of six years’ experience as a front office administrator and/or building principal should be required, more is even better. In addition, I urge you to exclude any candidate who has had more than two employers in the last seven years.  The most accurate indicator of success in a new job is the quality of the tenure an applicant had in previous jobs. 
  2. Insure that BOE reviews resumes of all qualified persons who apply. During the last search, utilizing the same search firm you’ve retained now, the board did not see the resumes of all qualified applicants. As a result a small pool was made even smaller and, after the process extended a full year, less than a handful of qualified candidates were presented to the board. With that as a backdrop, there is no reason to allow the search firm or perhaps board leadership to filter application and no downside to mandating that your retained search firm present to all board members eligible to vote resumes of all qualified candidates. I find it odd and bothersome that the current plan is to do just that; it makes no sense.
  3. Acting quickly is indeed a good goal but it should be a goal only and not a “done deal.” If history can be used as a guide, chances are there will be a very small pool of strong applicants, especially if you permit it to be reduced before you even see resumes. Your goal should be to make the right choice, not to make the quick choice due to coincide with the sudden resignation of Dr. Hayek. 
  4. Give due consideration to candidates that may emerge and who are currently working in the district. A candidate who is known to the board and who knows the district is much more likely to stay in the district, as she or he already knows the issues to overcome and the challenges he or she will likely face. A familiar candidate is also one who whose performance will probably be more in line with expectations. Hiring from within will also make the transition for the employees in the district easier. Not only will our loyal employees derive comfort from a decision to hire from within, the anxiety of “what will the next person do to materially impact my job?” will be lessened.
  5. Bridgewater-Raritan is not a school district that was or is in need of significant change. On the contrary, it is a superior school district as evidenced by our lofty position in state and national rankings, among other things. We are blessed with an outstanding and dedicated staff of teachers, administrators, and others. In the last 12 months there has been an alarming 80 percent turnover rate among senior administrators at Wade, and our staff has had to adjust to a very different leadership team than that which existed for many years’ prior as well as changing roles. Rather than seek another candidate who wants to put her or his stamp on the district from the start, I urge you to seek out a candidate who is content observing first and shaking the tree only after careful observation and deliberation. 
  6. Conduct the search in an open and transparent manner. Seek input from the public and staff. Student input could also be helpful. Find out what is important to them and consider it as you investigate options. Share progress of the process at board meetings. These can all be accomplished without betraying the confidentiality of candidates.
  7. Stay focused on the task at hand. You are seeking an individual to be the educational leader of a large and challenging school district. Your next superintendent must have strong academic chops and demonstrated managerial skills. The traits should be foremost in your minds rather than whether she or he shares your personal view on any specific curricular area that’s relevant to any particular subgroup of students. 
  8. The board needn’t be unanimous in its selection. Hiring a superintendent requires a majority vote from those eligible to vote. You needn’t secure the votes of a board member or two who may hold out for a candidate whose views match their own on any particular special interest as a prerequisite to making a choice.
  9. Morale matters. Too often decisions are made by boards of education that fail to take this simple tenet into account. A candidate who has a track record of working with employees collaboratively will acclimate more quickly than one who manages alone without taking into account the positions of those she or he oversees.   

Sincerely,

Evan Lerner

Bridgewater

The opinions expressed herein are the writer's alone, and do not reflect the opinions of TAPinto.net or anyone who works for TAPinto.net. TAPinto.net is not responsible for the accuracy of any of the information supplied by the writer. Click here to submit a Letter to the Editor.

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News

Bridgewater/Raritan

Upcoming Events

Tue, April 24

Scherman Hoffman Wildlife Sanctuary, Bernardsville

NJ Audubon: Les Photos de Bernie at the Wayrick ...

Arts & Entertainment Green

Tue, April 24, 9:30 AM

Scherman Hoffman Wildlife Sanctuary, Bernardsville

NJ Audubon: Teacher Naturalist Training

Education Green

Tue, April 24, 10:00 AM

Bridgewater Public Library, Bridgewater

Bridgewater Garden Club Meeting for April 24, 2018

Home & Garden

New Jersey Association of School Librarians Urges BRRSD to Keep All Librarians

April 18, 2018

To the Editor:

The following letter was sent to the Bridgewater-Raritan school superintendent as well as members of the school board from the New Jersey Association of School Librarians (NJASL).  

As the statewide organization for school library media specialists, the organization advocates for strong school library programs for all students.  NJASL is disheartened to learn that a ...

Car Fire in Wendy's Parking Lot Deemed Not Suspicious, Bridgewater Police Say

April 20, 2018

BRIDGEWATER, NJ - Bridgewater Township Police responded to a car fire in the parking lot of Wendy's, on Route 22 East April 9, but the fire was not deemed suspicious, according to a report.

According to the report, an unoccupied 2003 Infinity G35 caught fire. A 2010 Honda CRV, which was parked next to it, was also damaged in the fire.

North Branch and Green Knoll fire both ...

BAM Desserts Visits SCVTHS Culinary Arts Program

April 22, 2018

BRIDGEWATER, NJ – Melissa Jenkins, one of the owners of BAM Desserts in Somerset, and Chef Liz Hernandez visited the Somerset County Vocational & Technical High School (SCVTHS) culinary arts classes this week in hopes to recruit students for the growing bakery. 

Jenkins and Hernandez were looking for reliable students who were willing to learn new skills, get workplace ...

Whitehouse Wind Symphony Presents Free Concert in Somerville

April 22, 2018

SOMERVILLE, NJ - The Whitehouse Wind Symphony, a community band under the direction of Branchburg resident James P. Sheeley, Jr., will present a free concert on Sunday, April 29th at 3 p.m. at St. John’s Episcopal Church, 158 West High St.

The concert will feature a wide range of selections from wind band literature both new and old, such as the overture to “Die Frau ...

'The Sting' shimmers and shakes at Paper Mill

‘The Sting ‘slithers and shakes at Paper Mill Playhouse

By LIZ KEILL

MILLBURN, NJ – In a premiere production of “The Sting,” Harry Connick Jr. commands the Paper Mill Playhouse stage in Millburn.

Based on the sensational Paul Newman/Robert Redford film in 1973, the 1930s plot centers on a con game and gambling, sometimes on a train between New York and ...

Bateman Bill to Require Training, Licensing for Pet Groomers

April 15, 2018

TRENTON, NJ - Sen. Christopher "Kip" Bateman (R-16) will introduce legislation to increase protections for family pets by requiring pet groomers to be properly trained and licensed following the deaths of three dogs in five months at different New Jersey pet salons.

“It is sadly far too common for us to read of dog grooming deaths in the news,” said Bateman.