Letters to the Editor

Speed Dating for Medical School Admissions


To the Editor:

Many students who graduate Bridgewater-Raritan High School pursue careers in the health professions, myself among them. We aspire to one day satisfy the public and moral expectation that physicians be competent and compassionate, willing to practice medicine with integrity and a strong ethical code.

Yet although medical schools take every precaution in selecting benevolent individuals to be trained as physicians, there exists a dangerous minority of health care practitioners that may be negligent, lack compassion or in some cases even demonstrate criminal intent. These doctors are disciplined by state medical boards with consequences ranging from probation to license revocation, most often due to violations of professionalism. The Archive of Internal Medicine reported in an international study that 5 percent of doctors have recurrent issues in their medical practices that warrants such action.

Sign Up for E-News

With their very low rates of applicant acceptances, the admissions process is arguably the most critical evaluation medical schools can provide. Thus, this process is integral to ensuring benevolent individuals are accepted that hold the non-cognitive skills of interpersonal ability, maintenance of integrity, ethical behavior, and professionalism. Admissions committees largely rely on the interview for this purpose. Most medical schools use a traditional format much like that used in job interviews; a candidate sits in a room with either a single or a panel of interviewers and is typically evaluated for 20 to 50 minutes. Candidates are asked to answer questions or to elaborate on experiences described in their applications, after which the interviewers rate the students based on their responses. While this interview format is quite popular, its validity in assessing non-cognitive skills is questionable.

According to the journal Academic Medicine, ratings of candidates’ performances in personal interviews often depend more on the interviewers than the candidates themselves, with interviewer variability accounting for 56 percent of the variance in candidate ratings. A candidate’s score may largely be attributed to chance: being interviewed by an “easy,” compatible interviewer who influences the rest of the team positively will result in a higher score as opposed to a “hard” interviewer who does not see eye-to-eye with the candidate. Because these teams often receive a candidate’s background information beforehand, bias can be difficult to avoid. Furthermore, this interview format suffers from the halo effect, where a bad start to an interview can negatively color the interviewers’ perceptions throughout its entirety as responses cannot truly be considered independently in a single session. Such enormous biases and inter-rater variance should be considered unethical and unacceptable in an assessment tool designed to evaluate a candidate’s characteristics and not the interviewers’.

Recognizing this dilemma, McMaster University launched an alternative interview format: the Multiple Mini Interview. Rather than relying on a single evaluation session to assess a candidate’s non-cognitive skills, multiple stations are established in separate rooms operated by one interviewer and one examiner each. Every station presents a unique scenario which a student must address in less than ten minutes. After addressing a station’s scenario, the candidate rotates to the next one until all stations have been visited. This interview format dilutes the effects of interrater variance, reduces the halo effect and context specificity, and largely eliminates bias as interviewers do not receive background information on the candidates. Compared to the personal interview, the MMI correlates far better with scores on medical school Objective Structured Clinical Examinations, which largely evaluate non-cognitive skills.

For those planning to attend medical school, preparation for the MMI can include familiarization with medical ethics and contemporary issues in medicine, developing communication skills, and obtaining experience helping others. Considering the great efficacy with which the MMI is able to test for critical non-cognitive skills such as professionalism, perhaps the expansion of its implementation can prevent the aforementioned 5% of problem medical school graduates from becoming practicing physicians.

Tim Ganapolsky

The opinions expressed herein are the writer's alone, and do not reflect the opinions of TAPinto.net or anyone who works for TAPinto.net. TAPinto.net is not responsible for the accuracy of any of the information supplied by the writer. Click here to submit a Letter to the Editor.

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News


Upcoming Events

Fri, June 22, 9:00 AM

The Wayrick Gallery, Scherman Hoffman Wildlife Sanctuary, Bernardsville

NJ Audubon: NJ Audubon Photography Instructors’ ...

Arts & Entertainment Green


Fri, June 22, 7:30 PM

Crossroads, Garwood

Benefit Concert

Giving Back

Fri, June 22, 8:30 PM

Jacobus Vanderveer House & Museum, Bedminster

Movie In The Park

Voters have Spoken : Bridgewater BOE's Barry Walker fails in attempt to unseat Mayor Daniel Hayes for Municipal Committee Seat

June 11, 2018

To the Editor:

Usually primary elections hold very little political drama but this year in our town I was very surprised to learn that the Board of Education's Barry Walker unsuccessfully ran a campaign against Mayor Daniel Hayes in an attempt to unseat him from his District 10 Municipal Committee Seat.

Now I know why many Independent voters like me stay out of ...

Bridgewater Police Investigating Report of $2K Worth of Tools Stolen from Car, According to Report

June 17, 2018

BRIDGEWATER, NJ - Bridgewater Township Police are investigating a report of a theft of more than $2,000 from a vehicle parked at the Home Depot, in the Bridgewater Towne Center, according to a report.

A Hillsborough resident reported June 3 at about 5:58 p.m. that his vehicle had been burglarized while parked at the Home Depot. The theft occurred between 5 p.m. and 5:50 p.m.

According to ...

Alternatives, in Raritan, Wins Healthier Somerset Gold Award for Outstanding Worksite Wellness Programs

June 19, 2018

RARITAN, NJ – Alternatives, Inc., of Raritan, was recognized with a 2018 Healthier Somerset Healthy Workplace Recognition Award for implementing worksite wellness programs that improve the health and wellbeing of its employees and clients.

Alternatives earned a Gold Award, which distinguishes companies with programs in place for at least five years, and in 10 award ...

Thousands Expected in Hillsborough for Sourland Music Festival

June 20, 2018

HILLSBOROUGH, NJ – The Sourland Music Festival will be held Saturday, June 23 from 3-10 p.m. at the Hillsborough Golf & Country Club at 146 Wertsville Road, rain or shine, to benefit the Sourland Conservancy.

Discounted advance-sale tickets are available online only, Children under 12 are admitted free.

“We’ve got a really powerful lineup of the region’s most ...

'Half Time' lights up Paper Mill stage

‘Half Time’ turns the tables on aging in gleeful production

By Liz Keill

MILLBURN, NJ – The Paper Mill Playhouse is putting on a smashing new production of “Half Time” to round out its current season.

With actress Georgia Engel in an engaging performance, the cast also features Donna McKehnie, Andre De Shieilds and Lilias White, among a host of other ...