Government

AT&T Cell Antennas Face Legal Snag; Public Will Make its Case Sept. 18 Before Vote

AT&T Planner Jim Dowling leans over one of the photos he took of the NJ American Water Tower on Buxton Road Credits: TAP Chatham
The government's interpretation of 6409 (a) says that the installation of the cell antennas on the Buxton Road water tower would "substantially change the physical dimensions." Credits: TAP Chatham
Judy Fairweather, AT&T attorney, pleaded with the crowd "not to yell at her" before she agreed move the next meeting to Sept. 18 to accommodate residents who would be on vacation in August. Credits: TAP Chatham
Board member Jon Weston questioned the "benefit" the antennas would be to the community at Thursday's meeting Credits: TAP Chatham
Board member Thomas Polise noted that he hadn't heard any complaint about "Gaps in coverage" during the eight months the case for the variance has been made. Credits: TAP Chatham
Jim Dowling, AT&T licensed planner, makes the case for the installation of 12 cell antennas on the water tower located behind 62 Buxton Road. Credits: TAP Chatham

CHATHAM, NJ - In November of last year, AT&T attorney Judy Fairweather promised: "I will come back with an army (of experts)" in her bid to convince the Zoning Board of Adjustment to grant multiple variances that would allow her company to install 12 cell antennas on the NJ American Water Tower on Buxton Road.

At the end of the meeting on Thursday, Fairweather all but sounded retreat after bowing to the request by residents, who asked that the next meeting be moved to Sept. 18. Many residents said they would be away in August on vacation. Public comment for or against the antennas will be presented at the September meeting before the board votes on the matter.

"I know you all hate me," Fairweather said. "Please don't yell at me. We will agree to the Sept. 18 date."

Sign Up for E-News

The FCC interpretation of the 2012 law concerning wireless communication, however, could make everything that's gone before this moot. According to section 6409 (a), the addition of cell antennas must be approved as long as they don't "substantially change the dimensions" of a tower or base tower.

Board attorney Stephen H. Shaw read into the record the FCC interpretation of the law regarding "substantial change" and it allows for four new pieces of equipment. AT&T is requesting five cabinets to be installed on the site to power the antennas.

"You are requesting five new cabinets and the language specifically allows for four," Shaw said.

Up to this point, AT&T has presented its case with Fairweather objecting to the combative questioning from tenacious Chatham Township residents from Buxton Road, Kincaid Lane and Huron Drive. 

Fairweather's final witness, licensed planner Jim Dowling, presented a detailed review of the proposed AT&T plan to place 12 cell antennas on the 105-foot water tower behind 62 Buxton Road. The antennas would rise five feet above the top of the tower. AT&T is claiming there is a "gap" in its coverage and that the antennas would provide a benefit to the community, not a detriment.

Residents have countered those statements with assertions that there is no real gap in service and that the noise and view of the antennas in their neighborhood would be a detriment to their property values and aesthetics of the neighborhood. 

"Residents are opposed to this location because AT&T can improve their service by using alternate and acceptable options, where as by granting these variances it would impair the intent and purpose of our master and zoning plans. Our land use ordinances specify where cellular equipment may be placed and that is not in an R-3 zone," Buxton resident Haylee Messing said.

"Residents oppose granting the variances because the benefits do not outweigh the detriments. Neighbors surrounding the proposed site will have to deal with the 24/7 noise pollution or mechanical humming from the fans needed to cool equipment, the negative impact the antennas will have on their property value (thereby decreasing the taxable income for the town), the increase of traffic on a narrow residential street, the aesthetics, and the impact on their already stressed electrical service."

Dowling heard some comments from board members, pointing out their skepticism about the benefits to the community. Board member Jon Weston pointed out that the residents "haven't left here saying what a great idea this is." Board member Thomas Polise noted that he hadn't heard one "complaint about gaps in coverage" in the eight months the hearing has been open.

According to Shaw, AT&T will need five affirmative votes from the board to gain approval of its variances.

Katie Weisgerber questions Dowling's account that the cell antennas would not be a detriment in video below

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fJSRkOkO7FQ

 

TAP Into Another Town's News:

Sign Up for E-News

Chatham

Upcoming Events

Carousel_image_6d7e3245b896aa44bfae_f4df9a5838cb463aee90_camp_reg

Wed, February 22, 9:00 AM

The Connection, Summit

EarlyBird Camp Registration

Arts & Entertainment Education

Carousel_image_bf8996f630443823ae6f_bouncekids

Fri, February 24, 4:30 PM

Madison Area YMCA - Gymnastics Center, Madison

Bounce For A Cause

Giving Back Health & Wellness Other Sports

Carousel_image_6c69e1c84a8f5f2aacdb_66efa8654c7546e40f9e_img_5491

Sat, February 25, 10:00 AM

Warren

Camp Riverbend Open House is an Alien Invasion

The IRS Isn’t Calling

Receiving mail with the IRS listed in the envelope’s upper left corner induces fear in most people. Receiving a phone call with the IRS listed on caller ID is even scarier. Fear can cause you to act before you think—many people fall for criminal scams out of fear. Don’t be one of them.

Bottom line: The IRS does not phone taxpayers or communicate via email. The IRS does not ...

Parents' Concerns Off Base

February 11, 2017

To the Editor,

At the BOE meeting this week a group of organized Chatham residents addressed their concerns to the board regarding curriculum in the middle school. Essentially, they suggested that the school board was promoting the teachings of Islam and giving Christianity and Judaism short shrift. They believe that the 7th grade history class curriculum was putting too much ...

Why the Y: Three Y Centers Serve Three Generations

The Kirby bus, as it is affectionately called, pulls up to the Madison Area YMCA’s Family Center. The kids on the bus have just taken a short ride from the F.M. Kirby Children’s Center on East Street to do their sports, swimming, gymnastics, performing arts or enrichment classes. Five-year-old John Patrick Connolly, who is in the Young 5s program, hops off the bus and follows a line ...

Chatham Mother Chairs Summit Speech School Annual Spring Benefit April 4

February 21, 2017

The idyllic Fiddler’s Elbow Country Club in Bedminster is once again the perfect setting for non-profit Summit Speech School’s 27 th Annual Spring Benefit, which features two events in one day on April 4.

The 10 a.m. luncheon presentation and 6 p.m. dinner party will have fabulous silent and ticket auctions, grand raffle with cash prizes, a gourmet chocolate sale, and a ...