Chatham Board of Education, Administration to Remain Mum on Islam Lawsuit; Chatham Residents Express Support

BOE president Jill Critchley Weber said that the board members would remain silent about the lawsuit that claims the district is promoting the conversion to Islam Credits: TAP Chatham
Tracy Ness express support for the BOE during the public portion of the board of ed meeting on Monday Credits: TAP Chatham
Chatham resident Colleen Truppo read a letter that had 156 signatures, in support of the BOE in the federal lawsuit it faces Credits: TAP Chatham

CHATHAM, NJ - Chatham Board of Education President Jill Critchley Weber addressed the topic soon after the regular meeting of the BOE began Monday night, stating that the board members would be unable to legally comment on the federal lawsuit filed against the district last month.

But during the public portion of the meeting, Chatham residents expressed their support for the district curriculum, including Colleen Truppo, who read a letter into the record that was signed by 156 BOE supporters.

Chatham resident Libby Hilsenrath filed a federal lawsuit on behalf of her minor son, a Chatham Middle School student, charging that the district's curriculum advocated the conversion to Islam in its 7th Grade "World Cultures and Geography" class.

Sign Up for E-News

"If you do approach a board member in public, just know they are not trying to be dismissive or evasive, they just can't comment on an open active legal matter," Weber said. "We certainly don't want to have a misstep and cause the district, and quite frankly taxpayers, money unnecessarily because we've said something we shouldn't have or stepped out of line.

"Certainly, make your concerns known, but please don't take offense if we can't engage in an open and active dialogue on a matter that's outstanding. We are going to defend the lawsuit, as our attorney said, vigorously. We'll try to keep you informed as we possibly can. Unfortunately, our hands are tied."

BOE President Jill Critchley Weber addressed the lawsuit at the regular meeting of the board

In addition to supporting the curriculum of the district, Truppo's letter also asked for an accounting of what the lawsuit will cost taxpayers.

"We also have one request, the actions associated with defending this lawsuit will have clear, tangible costs to the School District of the Chathams," Truppo said in reading the letter. "As taxpayer dollars, which would be used to educate children in the district, will instead be used to fight this lawsuit.

"We respectfully request that the school district, the board of ed, keep detailed, line-item accounts of every expense associated with this lawsuit, including all legal, administrative and costs for additional security, and make that information public at each board of education meeting, if possible. In this way, Chatham residents can be informed of the costs we are all incurring as the result of the actions of one individual."

Colleen Truppo's full remarks and reading of the letter can be viewed in video below


Chatham resident Tracy Ness also spoke in favor of the BOE curriculum in the public portion of the meeting




TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News


Upcoming Events

Tue, July 17, 10:00 AM

Healing the Children, new providence

Summit Old Guard

Giving Back

Fri, August 10, 6:00 PM

Museum of Early Trades and Crafts, Madison

Downtown Concert Series: Mama D & The Vexations

Arts & Entertainment


Sun, September 30, 8:00 AM

College of Saint Elizabeth, Morristown

Walk to Fight Alzheimer's

Giving Back Health & Wellness

A Week at the Library of The Chathams Monday, July 9 – Sunday, July 15, 2018

Please note that the library will be closed on Sundays now through Labor Day weekend


Our summer program is in full swing.  This week we are starting some of our most popular children’s programs, Chess for Kids and sewing classes with Miss Polly.  Children will also enjoy a visit from a special guest, Queen Maria Isabella from Medieval Times.  Teens ...

Longtime Chatham Resident Passes the Torch to Current Residents

July 13, 2018

To the Editor,

I moved to Chatham from Ohio in 1961 and left just over a year or so ago. My daughters went through the school system and one of them still lives there with her son.

Clearly, we found the Library and local educational opportunities to our liking. 

When it came to giving back to the community, I chose to support the Library and served as a Board member for 15 ...

Chatham Residents Corry, Garavente, Myler, Radigan and Robbins are 2018 Graduates of Loyola University Maryland

July 14, 2018

BALTIMORE, MD -- Loyola University Maryland recognized the class of 2018 at its 166th Commencement Exercises on May 19, 2018, which included Chatham residents Bridget Corry, who received a BA degree in Communication; Elizabeth Garavente, who received a BBA degree in Business Administration; Jacqueline Myler, who received a BA degree in Communication; Leigh Radigan, who received a ...

5 Things You Should Know About Your Air Conditioner

How an air conditioner works

Air conditioners use refrigeration to cool indoor air. When a liquid converts to a gas, it absorbs heat. This process is called phase conversion. Air conditioners use phase conversion by forcing refrigerants to evaporate and condense over and over in a closed system of coils. 

What air conditioner filters do

Filters remove particles from the air, keeping ...