Cuttita Makes Touchdown Catch for Chatham on Final Play of Cougar Night Loss to Newton

The clock says the game is over, but Christian Cuttita made this catch and got into the end zone to give Chatham its only points on Cougar Night Credits: Glenn Clark
Chatham senior Christian Cuttita pulled in a 35-yard touchdown pass from Colin Petrullo on the final play of the game on Saturday night Credits: TAP Chatham
Christian Cuttita runs to the Chatham sideline after TD catch Credits: Glenn Clark
Max Schelling runs through a hole that Chris Strutt (52) helped open for Chatham Credits: Glenn Clark
Charles Cuneo makes the tackle for Chatham Credits: Glenn Clark
The view from the bleachers of Cougar Night Credits: Glenn Clark
Chatham senior Patrick O'Malley celebrates his sack on Cougar Night Credits: Glenn Clark
Christian Cuttita's kick return gave Chatham the ball on the Newton 26 Credits: Glenn Clark
Chatham band during halftime show Credits: Glenn Clark
Cougar Nation does the roller-coaster cheer Credits: Glenn Clark
The clarinet and flute section during the Chatham band's halftime show Credits: Glenn Clark
Luke Agnew, Max Schelling and George Fuentes gang up to make the tackle Credits: Glenn Clark
The Chatham cheerleaders got up for Cougar Night Credits: Glenn Clark
Kristian Roos keeps his eye on the ball as he punts for Chatham Credits: Glenn Clark
Christian Cuttita reacts as fellow captain Max Schelling is attended to by Chatham coach Jason Izsa. Schelling was able to walk off the field on his own. Credits: Glenn Clark
Colin Schroeder (2), Shane Carlin (8) and Ryan Lonergan (15) congratulate Christian Cuttita (14) after his TD catch on the game's final play for Chatham Credits: Glenn Clark

CHATHAM, NJ - On Cougar Night last year, Chatham scored a touchdown with 18 seconds left to pull out a stunning victory over West Essex.

Chatham fans who stayed to the end on Cougar Night in 2017 were rewarded with a touchdown on the final play of the game. This time, however, it only meant that Chatham would not be shut out in its 42-6 loss to undefeated Newton on Saturday at Cougar Field.

Chatham quarterback Colin Petrullo scrambled out of the pocket and threw a 35-yard touchdown pass that Christian Cuttita leaped to grab out of the air, falling into the end zone to give the Cougars six points. The catch was made with no time left on the clock.

Sign Up for E-News

"I was just happy to put some points up on the board for our team because it really is embarrassing to see a zero up there," Cuttita said. "It meant a lot to everyone, Colin (Petrullo), me, Max (Schelling) and everyone on the team.

"They're a good team. We played a tough game and I'm proud of that, but in the end we have to come out and we have to execute better than we did. "

It was the first touchdown of the season for Cuttita and he was clutching the ball in his hands after the game was over.

"My first touchdown of the year," Cuttita said. "The play was oh god, a hail-mary play. Colin scrambled around like he does best and he chucked it up in the air and somehow I went up and grabbed it. I couldn't have done it without the time the line gave me and Colin, too."

Chatham, now 1-5, next plays Nutley, 2 p.m. Saturday, Oct. 21 at Cougar Field.

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News


Upcoming Events

Tue, November 21, 6:30 PM

Florham Park Library - New Jersey Room, Florham Park

Type 2 Diabetes Question and Answer Session at ...

Education Health & Wellness Other

Fri, November 24, 8:30 AM

Madison Area YMCA, Madison

Black Friday at the Madison Area YMCA

Giving Back


Sun, December 3, 6:00 PM

Green Village

Santa is Coming to Green Village on Sunday, ...

A Week at the Library of The Chathams Monday, November 20 – Sunday, November 26, 2017


By Mary Kennedy

Our Books and Authors database is offering a new way to browse for your next great book to read.  It allows you to get creative by combining plot elements such as character, subject, location and time period to produce a fancy Venn diagram illustration to accompany your specialized list of reading suggestions.  With ...

In Praise of Chatham’s Main Street

November 17, 2017

To the Editor:

Could Chatham Borough’s Main Street commercial district be better? Of course, it could. But upon reflection, I’m amazed at how good it is!  

It’s cheerful and incredibly convenient. I’ve never failed to find parking behind the Post Office, which is such a short walk to the main strip. My family uses at least six of the restaurants ...

Chatham Residents will run for their Turkey at the 9th Annual Thanksgiving Day Turkey Trot

November 17, 2017


1 Mile Family Fun Run & 5K Race Will Benefit First Responders and Diabetes Research and Education

WHAT: As a kick-off to the Holiday Season The Chatham Turkey Trot (
will host its 9th Annual Thanksgiving Day Turkey Trot in the Highlands section of ...