Law & Justice

Lawsuit Over ‘Creepy’ Letters Puts Westfield in the Spotlight, Again

The owners of this home on Boulevard say disturbing letters prevented them from moving in. Credits: John Mooney
Chasing Jersey reporter Hank Flynn tweeted this photo of himself, “Watching over the house the Watcher watches. Weird & spooky.” Credits:

WESTFIELD, NJ — Back in May, Westfield made national news over a controversial “Police Brutality” art exhibit at the high school. This week, Westfield is all the talk once more, this time over “creepy” letters that the owners of a home on Boulevard said they received just after buying it in June for more than $1.3 million. “People Magazine,” Good Morning America,” the “Today Show” and even British tabloids have featured stories about “The Watcher.”

Why is the world obsessed with the now infamous house?

“When an anonymous someone sends dark notes referring to your children as ‘young bloods,’ indicating that he will ‘call to them and draw them to me,’ as the lawsuit alleges, it's scary, particularly to parents,” said Chasing Jersey reporter Hank Flynn, one of  many members of the media converging in Westfield this week. “Our children represent our greatest vulnerabilities, and when we feel they are threatened and we're at a loss to respond, that feeling is what readers/viewers are relating to. That said, there’s a lot more to the story — all may not be as it seems.”

Sign Up for E-News

What we know is this: The home’s new owners are suing the people who sold it to them because they say the sellers failed to disclose that it came with a stalker. The lawsuit says the family received three disturbing letters last summer signed “The Watcher.” The letters said that its author had been watching the house and its occupants “for the better part of two decades” and demanded “Stop changing it and let it alone.”

Another letter asked if they found what was in the walls yet. The author asks whose room will face the street, adding “It will help me knowing who is in which bedroom then I can plan better.”  

The lawsuit contends that the previous owners had also received a “disturbing” letter in May. (You can read the entire lawsuit on Gawker.)

At Tuesday’s town council meeting, Mayor Andy Skibitsky told news crews and reporters gathered there that Westfield police began investigating the letters last year and that “no stone was left unturned,” though he would not comment if the police had a subject in the case.

Flynn questioned the existence of the letters and wondered what results the investigation has yielded.

“There are many more questions, but the suit attaches a certain degree of claimed ‘ownership’ to the ‘Watcher,’ who's a defendant in the suit, despite the fact that no one knows who he is,” said Flynn. “That implied ownership seems to be the legal leverage that the plaintiff is depending on to get them out of a 1.3 million dollar deal. And there's a lot more.”

As the world continues to speculate, the mayor has urged anyone with additional facts or information relating to this matter to contact Westfield police at 908-789-4000.

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News


Union County's March For Our Lives - County Wide March Planned

March 18, 2018

On March 24 at 10 a.m. Students of Union County will march to make sure that our schools are safe. The march will start at Burnet Middle School (1000 Caldwell Avenue, Union). It will end at the Union Township City Council Offices (1976 Morris Avenue, Union). All looking to protect American children by strengthening our laws and standing with the victims of all shootings inside places of ...

Do You Know How Colleges Calculate How Much You Should Pay?

In his last few videos Chris Curran has talked about college financial aid.    In today's Takeaway Tuesday Chris talks about Expected Family Contribution (EFC), Cost of Attendance(COA) and the amount of need an individual family may have based on those components.   

If you want to know how these things are calculated and what they mean to your child-bound child ...

Are You Harnessing the Potential of the College Financial Aid Process?

Chris Curran works with families to plan for college.  A big part of what he does is help families reduce the overall cost of college by harnessing the power of the financial aid process.   

Do you know what assets should be listed on financial aid forms and which should not?  Did you know that retirement accounts and some other family owned assets don't have to be ...

Proud to support Tom Malinowski for Congress

March 8, 2018

Every single day, whether I want to be or not, I am reminded how important it is that Democrats gain control of the House of Representatives in November and check Donald Trump. Fortunately, there is a terrific candidate in New Jersey's 7th Congressional District who can beat incumbent Leonard Lance. That candidate is Tom Malinowski.

I'm a lifelong New Jersey resident -- including ...


AtlantiCast: Episode 13

On this episode of AtlantiCast, new clinical studies in the fields of cardiology and immunotherapy, national and statewide recognitions for Atlantic Health System medical centers and the inaugural AtlantiCast Collab Challenge!


State-of-the-Art Pain Relief Therapy Now Available at Cornerstone Physical Therapy of Clark

CLARK, NJ – Cornerstone Physical Therapy Health and Wellness Center is now offering the latest technology in therapeutic pain relief with the introduction of the LightForce™ EXPi Deep Tissue Therapy Laser.  This therapy offers the highest level of pain relief available using a new and enhanced 25 watt Class IV Laser.

Laser Therapy is a surgery-free, drug-free option for ...