Merry Lane Controversy Continues as Crucial Vote on Application to Build Warehouse in Residential District is Postponed


EAST HANOVER, NJ- East Hanover’s Land Use Planning Board meeting was packed with residents eager to make their opinions heard regarding an application by local land owner, Michael Zecca. This application would see a 20,000 sq ft warehouse built on 8 Merry Lane which sits in a preexisting residential area. With standing room only, a slew of legal minds present, and even a court stenographer brought in, this issue was set to reach a boiling point.

The application has been decried by the local community group “East Hanover Nightmare” who states on their website that “This is NOT in the best interest of the general welfare of the public. This development is purely PROFITS before PEOPLE and destroying the quality of life in a residential neighborhood.”

This message resonated with the community, spawning petitions, both handwritten and online, numbering in the hundreds. Their presence at the public hearing backed up these numbers, as the meeting room rocked with applause when objections to the application were brought before the board.

Sign Up for E-News

Givaudan Flavors Corp. of East Hanover owns the road, Merry Lane, where the proposed warehouse would be constructed. Nancy Lottinville, an attorney for Gibbons P.C. who is representing Givaudan, went up before the board and explained that the access the applicant is entitled to on Merry Lane is laid out in a specific access easement. This easement is a type of contract that is controlled by Givaudan and they must consent to any change to the contractual rights of the applicant to access the road.

According to Lottinville, the current easement has specific limits such as: that there are three residential lots which are conforming lots, that houses must be on the property, and where the driveways are located and how wide they might be. Based on the current agreement, the applicant does not have the access necessary to construct this warehouse, Lottinville said.

Lottinville declared to the board that “Givaudan has advised me to tell you that under no circumstance will it be altering the access easement.”

Rosemary Stone-Dougherty, who is representing Zecca, argued that they had been in negotiations with Givaudan over the access easement in 2015. It was their belief that Givaudan had put off making a decision until they knew that the Land Use Planning Board would even approve such a use of the property.

It was asserted by Stone-Dougherty that “this is a legal debate that is outside the jurisdiction of this board.” The application, which has been deemed complete by the townships engineering department on June 1st, did stipulate that the applicant would have to show that they would be able to provide the access for construction.

“Now that burden is on us.” Stone-Dougherty said. “Whether that means we have to litigate or that means we resolve whatever issues Givaudan has with this.”

According to Stone-Dougherty, the application has been completed with the stipulation that access would have to be attained. This would be a legal discussion outside of the board’s authority and separate from whether or not the board went forward with the application.

The board was not convinced. “The first thing we need to do is see whether or not we can move forward with this.” Land Use Planning Board Chairman William Salemme said. “Based upon the testimony from Givaudan’s council they are never going to give you access…I really think that issue needs to be clarified and clear and I think it should have been done well in advance of this evening.”

The board unanimously voted to postpone the vote on the application to allow the two parties time to resolve this issue. Another hearing has been set for September 8, where this issue will once again be brought before the public.

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News

East Hanover/Florham Park

Florham Park Prepares for the Fourth

Its time for one of Florham Park's shining moments. The Fourth of July parade is not only the kick of to summer, it continues the legacy of being among the oldest Independence day celebrations in New Jersey. this year the festivities are set and the schedule of events is as follows;

9:00am  Flag raising ceremony at the Florham Park Fire House

9:30am  Parade begins on ...

Important Message for Florham Park Residents Regarding the Fourth of July

Important July 4th Celebration Reminder - Please be advised in the interest of safety and security, the entire parade route will be CLOSED TO ALL TRAFFIC beginning at 8:30am on July 4, 2018. This will impact residents who live along the parade route and all of the side streets that connect to the parade route. (Please see the map attached to this post)

Please ensure that you plan accordingly ...

Freeholders Approve 21 Historic Preservation Grants Including Florham Park and Hanover Township Properties

July 16, 2018

The Morris County Board of Freeholders unanimously approved $2.2 million in county historic preservation grants to be financed by the county’s 2018 Preservation Trust Fund to help preserve, restore, or protect historic sites in 16 towns across Morris County.

The vote was taken at the Freeholder Board’s meeting held in Mount Olive, which will get $198 000 in construction ...

Belmar Parasail: Soar Into Summer with a High-Flying Adventure Along the Beachfront

July 12, 2018

BELMAR, NJ — As Belmar finally basks in picture-perfect weather, it may be time to check off a summer activity on your bucket list. And for many, parasailing is one of those “must-do” experiences.

At Belmar Parasail, the season is in full swing, offering boat trips from the Belmar Manutti Marina to the beachfront where passengers are lifted 500 feet above the Atlantic Ocean ...

New Jersey Average Gas Prrice Down Slightly; Record Holiday Travel Week Underway

Florham Park, N.J.- The average price at the pump in New Jersey is $2.88 today, one cent cheaper than last week ($2.89), according to AAA Northeast’s weekly survey of fuel prices. Today’s average price is 13 cents cheaper than one month ago ($3.01), but 60 cents higher than it was on July 2, 2017 ($2.28).


AAA’s July 2nd survey of ...

LBI Summer Soiree "Boardwalk Nights" on Friday, August 10 at the Sea Shell Resort and Beach Club to Benefit David's Dream and Believe Cancer Foundation

BEACH HAVEN - On August 10, the inaugural LBI Summer Soiree “Boardwalk Nights” (formerly Island Gala) will take  to the breathtaking Sea Shell Resort & Beach Club on Friday, August 10 to benefit David's Dream & Believe Cancer Foundation.

The LBI Summer Soiree is brought to you by key supporting company D. Finelli Construction. David Finelli was ...

Rutgers Football Zack Heeman Among the Allstate and AFCA 2018 Good Works Team Nominees

July 17, 2018

NEW BRUNSWICK, N.J.-Across America,  college football players receive praise for their superior performance on the field. Today, however, only a select group of those student-athletes have the honor of being commended for their distinguished accomplishments off the field when Allstate Insurance Company and the American Football Coaches Association (AFCA) announce 169 nominees for the 2018 ...

Upcoming Events


Tue, July 24, 7:00 PM

Livingston Public Library, Livingston

Meet the Author: Lucy Tan

Arts & Entertainment

Wed, July 25, 7:30 PM

Chatham United Methodist Church, Chatham

Masterwork’s Summer Sings Conclude with Verdi ...

Arts & Entertainment

Mon, July 30, 9:00 AM

Yogi Berra Museum & Learning Center, Little Falls

Yogi Berra Museum Summer Baseball Camp

Education Health & Wellness Sports

17 Fascinating Facts About Rutgers Athletics

July 10, 2018

NEW BRUNSWICK, NJ - For all the critics of the athletics program at New Jersey’s largest public university, there are more than a dozen reasons to cheer for successes of the sports programs and teams on the playing fields, in classrooms and beyond.

Here are 17 on the field and off the field things this took place this past academic year at Rutgers University:

1. Rutgers had four ...


Beverly Jean (Charlton) Weimar, of Ship Bottom, and Florham Park, New Jersey passed away on March ...
Read more

Education: A Bedrock of Democracy, Civic Engagement and Economic Prosperity

July 5, 2018

More than 240 years ago, our nation’s founders envisioned a country where individuals could forge their own destinies and not be constrained by the circumstances of birth. The essential concept was that people could govern themselves and participate in democracy, or what Benjamin Franklin and others called “a great experiment.” The vision was bold and has flourished as the ...

Murphy Administration Takes Action to Help Smokers Quit

July 17, 2018


TRENTON – The Murphy administration on Monday announced new steps to help New Jersey Medicaid recipients quit using tobacco by making it easier to receive tobacco cessation medications and counseling.

“Tobacco use is the leading preventable cause of death and disease in New Jersey, leading to chronic lung disease, heart disease, stroke and cancer,” said New ...