Merry Lane Controversy Continues as Crucial Vote on Application to Build Warehouse in Residential District is Postponed


EAST HANOVER, NJ- East Hanover’s Land Use Planning Board meeting was packed with residents eager to make their opinions heard regarding an application by local land owner, Michael Zecca. This application would see a 20,000 sq ft warehouse built on 8 Merry Lane which sits in a preexisting residential area. With standing room only, a slew of legal minds present, and even a court stenographer brought in, this issue was set to reach a boiling point.

The application has been decried by the local community group “East Hanover Nightmare” who states on their website that “This is NOT in the best interest of the general welfare of the public. This development is purely PROFITS before PEOPLE and destroying the quality of life in a residential neighborhood.”

This message resonated with the community, spawning petitions, both handwritten and online, numbering in the hundreds. Their presence at the public hearing backed up these numbers, as the meeting room rocked with applause when objections to the application were brought before the board.

Sign Up for E-News

Givaudan Flavors Corp. of East Hanover owns the road, Merry Lane, where the proposed warehouse would be constructed. Nancy Lottinville, an attorney for Gibbons P.C. who is representing Givaudan, went up before the board and explained that the access the applicant is entitled to on Merry Lane is laid out in a specific access easement. This easement is a type of contract that is controlled by Givaudan and they must consent to any change to the contractual rights of the applicant to access the road.

According to Lottinville, the current easement has specific limits such as: that there are three residential lots which are conforming lots, that houses must be on the property, and where the driveways are located and how wide they might be. Based on the current agreement, the applicant does not have the access necessary to construct this warehouse, Lottinville said.

Lottinville declared to the board that “Givaudan has advised me to tell you that under no circumstance will it be altering the access easement.”

Rosemary Stone-Dougherty, who is representing Zecca, argued that they had been in negotiations with Givaudan over the access easement in 2015. It was their belief that Givaudan had put off making a decision until they knew that the Land Use Planning Board would even approve such a use of the property.

It was asserted by Stone-Dougherty that “this is a legal debate that is outside the jurisdiction of this board.” The application, which has been deemed complete by the townships engineering department on June 1st, did stipulate that the applicant would have to show that they would be able to provide the access for construction.

“Now that burden is on us.” Stone-Dougherty said. “Whether that means we have to litigate or that means we resolve whatever issues Givaudan has with this.”

According to Stone-Dougherty, the application has been completed with the stipulation that access would have to be attained. This would be a legal discussion outside of the board’s authority and separate from whether or not the board went forward with the application.

The board was not convinced. “The first thing we need to do is see whether or not we can move forward with this.” Land Use Planning Board Chairman William Salemme said. “Based upon the testimony from Givaudan’s council they are never going to give you access…I really think that issue needs to be clarified and clear and I think it should have been done well in advance of this evening.”

The board unanimously voted to postpone the vote on the application to allow the two parties time to resolve this issue. Another hearing has been set for September 8, where this issue will once again be brought before the public.

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News

East Hanover/Florham Park

Improvements Planned for Two Busy 90 Year Old Morris County Bridges, One in Florham Park

April 19, 2018

Morris County, in coordination with the North Jersey Transportation Planning Authority and New Jersey Department of Transportation, is conducting studies to determine improvements needed for the Columbia Turnpike Bridge in Florham Park and the Valley Road Bridge in Long Hill and Bernards Township, at the Morris and Somerset counties’ border.

Columbia Turnpike ...

New Law Bans Offshore Oil and Gas Drilling in State Waters Off New Jersey’s Coast

April 21, 2018

TRENTON, NJ — Gov. Phil Murphy has signed into law a ban on offshore oil and gas exploration and drilling off the immediate coast of New Jersey.

The law, which drew nearly unanimous support from the New Jersey Legislature, counters the Trump administration’s plan to extend its offshore reach for oil and natural gas activities in ocean waters from Maine to ...

Surf City Hotel's Application Rejected By the Surf City Land Use Board for Outdoor Dining

SURF CITY - There has been a lot of positive change going on at the Surf City Hotel the last two years and especially this off season. New owner Greg Gewirtz, his wife Colleen and other family members have been working hard completing renovations to improve the hotel, bar, liquor store, restaurant and night club.

The owners were hoping those improvements would include approval to set ...

Travels Update - Long Beach Island Summer Shuttle No Longer A Free Ride

BRANT BEACH - The Long Beach Island Shuttle, an extremely popular service for visitors and residents of Long Beach Island, will have a fee for the first time beginning Memorial Day weekend. 

The Long Beach Township Board of Commissioners made the announcement at their meeting on Monday, April 9. 

Here is the overview on the fees:

One-way shuttle rides from 10 a.m. to 10 p.m.

Baby Seal Waddles Its Way onto Belmar Beach

BELMAR, NJ — A baby seal waddled its way onto the Fifth Avenue beach earlier today to enjoy one of the warmest days of spring so far.

Around noon on April 12, photographer Nancy Orlowski took these snapshots, which have also been posted on the Belmar Facebook page where it states that the Conserve Wildlife Foundation of New Jersey has been notified.

This is the second known instance ...

Save This Travel Date - The Asbury Park Music and Film Festival - April 27 - 29

TAPintoTravels - Asbury Park, New Jersey will host their 4th annual Music and Film Festival on April 27 - 29.

What is better than hanging out in a beach town while listening to good music, watching great films, and all while supporting some great charities? Okay, maybe doing in mid-summer is a little better.  We imagined they tried, but what ...

Travels - Friends of Belmar Harbor: Seeking Junior Sailors and Campers for Summer Programs

BELMAR, NJ — Children can learn how to sail or discover the wonders of the Shark River during two programs to be held weekly this summer by Friends of the Belmar Harbor.

Registration now is open for FOBH’s Junior Sailing and Discovery Camp programs, which will be held from June 18 through August 30 as weekly offerings. Sign up by April 1 and receive a 15 percent discount on ...

Upcoming Events


Thu, April 26, 6:00 PM

Florham Park

Ladies Night at Lucy's Gift with Special Guest ...

Thu, April 26, 7:00 PM

Livingston Public Library, Livingston

"Speaking From Spirit"

Other Religions And Spirituality


Fri, April 27, 12:30 PM

Madison Area YMCA - Buttenheim Hall, Madison

Active Adut: Spring Tea Celebration

Food & Drink Giving Back Other

The Happy Hive Hallway Club Makes Over Hanover Park Hallways

April 22, 2018

EAST HANOVER, N.J.- The Hallways of Hanover Park High School  are alive with the creativity of the Happy Hive Hallways Club.  Ms. Kristina Rovtar, founder and advisor explains how the club came about, “I decided to start the Happy Hive Club in the 2015-2016 school year because I wanted to add some color and further beautify the hallways at HP. Our first ...


Beverly Jean (Charlton) Weimar, of Ship Bottom, and Florham Park, New Jersey passed away on March ...
Read more

Take A Chance on the Livingston Library To Conclude

April 20, 2018

LIVINGSTON, NJ — The Friends of the Livingston Library’s annual “Take A Chance on the Library” Auction & Raffle will be ending Tuesday, April 24  when the public is invited to the Library’s Program Room as winners are announced, beginning at noon. The event invites all members of the community to “take a chance on the library” by ...