Government

Flemington Council Takes Step Towards Union Hotel Condemnation in Tense Meeting

6c3a43fa10cca84dd1b5_phil_greiner.jpg
Flemington Mayor Phil Greiner Credits: Curtis Leeds / TAPinto Flemington file photo
a35417a8ed88a1ecde9d_betsy_driver_3.JPG
Councilperson Betsy Driver at last night's Flemington Council meeting. Credits: Curtis Leeds
76f816d8b90457f88b07_michael_harris_2.jpg
Councilperson Michael Harris at last night's Flemington Council meeting. Credits: Curtis Leeds
9bba71f350ad7301a553_steve_tuccio.jpg
Flemington resident Steve Tuccio Credits: Curtis Leeds / TAPinto Flemington file photo
8c0a946ee8b60b5f373f_alan_brewer_4.jpg
Flemington resident Alan Brewer at last night's Borough Council meeting.
6c3a43fa10cca84dd1b5_phil_greiner.jpg

FLEMINGTON, NJ – A divided Borough Council voted to take the next step toward invoking eminent domain and condemning the Union Hotel at its meeting last night.

Councilpersons Marc Hain, John Gorman and Brooke Warden voted in favor of the action; Councilpersons Susan Peterson and Michael Harris voted “no.” Councilperson Betsy Driver voted, “Hell, no.”

Mayor Phil Greiner voted to break the tie and direct “the Planning Board to conduct the necessary investigations and to hold a public hearing” to determine if the Union Hotel and other properties “qualify as a ‘Condemnation Redevelopment Area,’ ” according to the resolution.

Sign Up for E-News

Greiner said it would likely be August before a public hearing would be held on condemnation.

While the mayor told the public that, “We’re not taking anyone’s property here, this is a study,” Harris said the condemnation process “puts a gun to the head of the current property owner.”

Harris said that no approvals – including approval of the pending financial agreement between the borough and redeveloper Jack Cust – should be granted to Cust “until we have negotiations. Eminent domain interferes with negotiations.”

“The fact is we have no recourse” if Cust abandons the deal, perhaps even after buildings have been demolished, said Councilperson Betsy Driver. Under condemnation, the borough would take ownership of the hotel “even if only for a brief period of time. If Mr. Cust decides to walk at that point, we’re stuck owning more buildings on Main Street. I think that’s a really bad financial decision for the borough.”

Driver said Cust should be required to post a performance bond. Echoing the sentiment of Harris and resident Al Brewer, Driver noted that the liquor license Cust is required to hold is registered under a separate legal entity, which the three think is a violation of the redeveloper’s agreement.

“I have real big issues with even taking this step” towards condemnation, Driver said, “when Mr. Cust can’t even bother to transfer the liquor license.”

The hotel is the cornerstone of the Cust’s Flemington Center Urban Renewal, LLC redevelopment plan. But it, the adjacent “Potting Shed” building and its parking lot are owned by Raritan Township resident Steve Romanowski. Romanowski and Cust have not been able to agree to terms of a sale.

“Everyone including me has consistently said eminent domain is not something anyone wants to do,” Greiner said. “Frankly, I don’t think we’re going to wind up doing it. (But) we need the option.”

“If you don’t think you’ll use it, you don’t have to make the decision to keep the option open,” said resident Joey Novick.

Resident Steve Tuccio challenged Hain, who’d previously stated that he opposed invoking eminent domain. “Were you lying then or lying now?” Tuccio asked. “Trustworthiness is key.”

“Steve when you talk, do people listen to you?” Hain responded. “No,” he said, answering his own question, “because you talk out your (expletive) at times.”

The remark prompted an outburst, with Hain explaining that while he does oppose condemnation, when he was campaigning in the recent election primary, “The residents made it clear, they want that project done. ‘I don’t care what it takes,’ ” he said they told him. “Get the project done.”

Hain apologized for his remark, but he is not the only Council member who has spoken against condemnation.

“We are both very much against eminent domain as a redevelopment tool and don't know anyone who is in favor of taking away an individual's private property to give to another private party,” said a primary campaign statement from Hain and Warden. “We've both stated this publicly several times on the record and quite often in personal conversations with numerous folks, including private conversations with our opponent," a reference to Brewer.

As a candidate, Brewer ran consistently against condemnation. "Al Brewer knows how we feel about eminent domain, yet chooses to misrepresent our true values because he thinks that will get him votes," the statement from Hain and Warden said. "Al has no record of his own to run on so he chooses to fabricate the records of his opponents.”

Brewer said that Hain and Warden's vote in favor of condemnation was "disingenuous" and proof that he didn't misrepresent their position.

Harris has introduced position papers on the hotel which he is publishing on his Facebook page. In the first installment of what he says will be a 10-part series, Harris wrote he'll “show that the Borough’s Redeveloper Agreement with Flemington Center Urban Renewal, LLC, was a bad deal for the Borough. I am providing this information as my colleagues on the Borough’s Redevelopment Committee continue to seek project approvals ahead of negotiating.

“If we really want development, then we need to fix the Borough’s agreements with its developer,” Harris wrote.

Politics are a part of the tension over condemnation. In November, Greiner will be challenged in the mayoral election by Driver. Brewer ran in the primary for a Republican nomination to Council, but lost to Warden and Hain. Novick will be on the ballot as an independent seeking a Council seat. Democrats Christopher Runion and Caitlin Giles-McCormick will also be seeking Council seats.

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News

Flemington/Raritan

Proposal for Flemington Candidates' Forum

July 17, 2018

To The editor,

This is an open note to Flemington Mayoral candidates Phil Greiner and Betsy Driver; and Borough Council candidates  Marc Hain, Brooke Warden, Chris Runion Caitlin Giles-McCormick

Re: Proposal for Candidate Forum[s] in Flemington

Folks,

Seeing how this is an extremely important election with many significant issues facing Flemington, I propose all ...

Malinowski Supports NJ Infrastructure

To the editor,

I support Tom Malinowski in the election to represent New Jersey’s 7th district this November because he will support infrastructure investments that are essential to the continued prosperity of this district.

Tom recognizes this district’s dire need for infrastructure appropriations, and he knows how essential the Gateway Project is for not only those who commute ...

Upcoming Events

Mon, July 23, 9:00 AM

Flemington Public Library, Flemington

Coding Camp at Mediatech

Education

Tue, July 24, 9:00 AM

Flemington Public Library, Flemington

Coding Camp at Mediatech

Education

Wed, July 25, 9:00 AM

Flemington Public Library, Flemington

Coding Camp at Mediatech

Education

AtlantiCast

AtlantiCast: Episode 18

On this week’s AtlantiCast, you’ll find out how accessing care at Atlantic Health System is now easier, more affordable and closer to home than ever, learn which item from the produce aisle could be the newest weapon against cancer, see what Atlantic Health System, the New York Times and Instagram all have in common and much more.

 

 

Proposal for Flemington Candidates' Forum

July 17, 2018

To The editor,

This is an open note to Flemington Mayoral candidates Phil Greiner and Betsy Driver; and Borough Council candidates  Marc Hain, Brooke Warden, Chris Runion Caitlin Giles-McCormick

Re: Proposal for Candidate Forum[s] in Flemington

Folks,

Seeing how this is an extremely important election with many significant issues facing Flemington, I propose all ...

Notice of Hearing, Raritan Township

July 16, 2018

A public hearing will be held before the Raritan Township Zoning Board of Adjustment at the Municipal Building, located at 1 Municipal Drive in the  Committee/Court Meeting Room on Thursday July 19 at 7:30 p.m. on the following application: The above applicant is requesting approval of and any and all variances and waivers as may be required by the Board for an 28.56 kw Ground Mounted P.V.