Police & Fire

Prosecutor Dismisses Criminal Charges Against 'Flemington Four' in Union Hotel Case

f8093ce19874124bc028_union_hotel_3.jpg
Flemington's landmark Union Hotel Credits: Curtis Leeds / TAPinto Flemington file photo
f8093ce19874124bc028_union_hotel_3.jpg

FLEMINGTON, NJ -  It became a legal hot potato.

In January, police here charged local residents George Eckelman, Richard Giffen, Steve Romanowski and Gary Schotland with criminal trespass charges and disorderly persons offenses after the group entered the landmark Union Hotel and posted video of its interior to Facebook.

Romanowski now owns the hotel, which was in foreclosure at the time of the incident. He entered the building with a key, according to those involved.

Sign Up for E-News

Police said they were alerted to the video by borough construction official Jeff Klein. The video’s purpose was to inspect the hotel’s interior and while inside, discussions were made to post the video “to inform the public on the condition of the building,” police said.

But police said no one was properly hired to complete the task.

In addition to the criminal charge, the four were also charged by Klein with “entering an unsafe structure.” That case was heard in April before the county’s Construction Board of Appeals. The Board cleared the four of the charges, concluding that the unsafe structure notice hadn’t been properly posted on the building, that their purpose was “performing qualified professional evaluation and assessment” and noting in its decision that the four “should not have been cited.”

The criminal matter was first heard in February by Judge Eric Perkins in Flemington Municipal Court, who transferred the case out of his courtroom.

After that, the county Prosecutor’s Office got involved. It was asked “to review and to prosecute these matters in municipal court because of perceived conflicts,” according to a letter sent to the defendants’ attorneys last week by First Assistant Prosecutor Michael J. Williams.

“We will dismiss these charges,” the letter states. The decision follows what it called a “comprehensive review ... and after consultation with Flemington Borough.”

Williams wrote that “the municipality does not wish to pursue these charges” and that a process is now in place “for accessing the Union Hotel when necessary.”

It isn’t clear who in the borough sought the dismissal of the charges.

When resident Robert Shore asked at last week’s Borough Council meeting about their status, Mayor Phil Greiner said the matter “doesn’t flow through the Borough Council or mayor at all ... that’s strictly a law enforcement matter, a court matter at this point.” Greiner said he read about the Construction Board of Appeals decision on TAPinto.

Prosecutor's Office spokesperson Paull Approvato said in a statement this morning that, "In consultation with borough officials, the Prosecutor made the decision to dismiss the charges. The Prosecutor also provided information to the defendants about the permit process required to access the property."

Williams’ letter does not please Eckelman. In an interview, Eckelman said Prosecutor Anthony P. Kearns, III told him the charges would be dismissed “because he can’t prove the case.”

 

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News

Flemington/Raritan

A Man of 'Deep Pockets, Sterling Character'

June 19, 2018

To the editor:

At a meeting of Flemington Borough Council earlier this year, Mayor Phil Greiner described Jack Cust as a man of “deep pockets and sterling character.” He seemed to be attempting to justify his basis for selecting a new redeveloper, after the first two selected by a committee he was part of, or led, failed at the project. Initially the project was to find someone to ...

End 'Gun Free Zones,' Harden Soft Targets

To the editor:

In response to the Governor's recent signing of legislation restricting law-abiding gun owners to 10 rounds of ammunition and rejecting calls to address the uneven playing field existing vis-à-vis some single mom alone with her child fending for herself against some armed assailant packing who knows how many rounds is something a Politburo thug would appreciate! The ...

Voter Turnout in Raritan Township

To the editor,

We want to share our admiration for all of the Raritan Township residents who came out to vote in the June 5 Primary Election. Additionally, we want to say "thank you" to our Democratic supporters for their votes.

As we look to the General Election on Nov. 6, we reflect on the importance of this election for our children, seniors and all those in between as we ...

Alzheimer's is Public Health Crisis

To the editor:

 

With more than 5 million Americans now living with Alzheimer’s and with more than 15 million acting as caregivers, Alzheimer’s has become the nation’s most expensive disease. This year alone, it will cost $277 billion to take care of those stricken. The Alzheimer’s Association predicts that, by 2050, more than 14 million Americans will be ...

Candidates 'Weaponized' News Article

To the editor:

I was dismayed to see my 2014 news reportage inaccurately weaponized by council members Marc Hain and Brooke Warden in their campaign flier attacking Al Brewer. The headline “School security at issue: Flemington-Raritan board member accused of leaking secrets” is less than a half-truth, given the ensuing revelation.

Marc and Brook ignored my follow-up report in ...

Upcoming Events

Mon, June 25, 9:00 AM

Flemington Public Library, Flemington

Coding Camp at Mediatech

Education

Tue, June 26, 9:00 AM

Flemington Public Library, Flemington

Coding Camp at Mediatech

Education

AtlantiCast

AtlantiCast: Episode 16

Summer is in the air, and the latest episode of AtlantiCast is ready to help you enjoy some fun outdoors while staying safe! This week’s episode opens with tips for sunscreen usage from Atlantic Health System’s Chief Medical and Academic Officer, Dr. Jan Schwarz-Miller. You’ll also learn about how Atlantic Health System is advancing the future of health care through ...

A Man of 'Deep Pockets, Sterling Character'

June 19, 2018

To the editor:

At a meeting of Flemington Borough Council earlier this year, Mayor Phil Greiner described Jack Cust as a man of “deep pockets and sterling character.” He seemed to be attempting to justify his basis for selecting a new redeveloper, after the first two selected by a committee he was part of, or led, failed at the project. Initially the project was to find someone to ...

Driver, Runion, Giles-McCormick, Kick-Off Campaign

June 19, 2018

FLEMINGTON, NJ — Borough Mayor candidate Betsy Driver and Borough Council candidates Chris Runion and Caitlin Giles-McCormick have joined their campaigns in advance of the Nov. 6, 2018 election.

Since winning her campaign to become a Borough Councilperson, Betsy Driver has already passed resolutions to get Council meetings streamed live and videotaped for later viewing; a tuition credit ...