Did the NJSIAA Have to Fix Football Playoff "Problem" Now?

HASBROUCK HEIGHTS - The New Jersey State Interscholastic Association took a giant step closer to crowning one champion in each of the seven groups in high school football.  Wood-Ridge Athletic Director gave praise to the committee for all the work they did to get the vote to go through, with 75 percent of the schools voting for the proposal.

The Non-Public Schools will play to a group champion, while each of the five Public Groups will have co-champions, or a North & Central/South Champion - the specifics have been lacking a bit, but we have time. To do so, they will condense they will start the season a week earlier.

The Non-Public schools, usually the most unpopular kid at the party when the NJSIAA gathers, came out ahead.  They get a true state champ.  The “Publics”, a little better, but not so much.

Sign Up for E-News

Either go the full way or don’t go at all

But was it time and effort well spent?  Was this another case of Nero fiddling while the Rome burned?

With the other problems that are facing the state in football, was this really something that people should have been focusing on.  And if you are not sure what the problems are, you have obviously not been paying attention to high school football this season.

More and more high schools are having trouble fielding competitive teams each week. I don’t just mean wins and losses.  I am talking about fielding rosters with enough depth not get kids hurt, where a few injuries or an outbreak of the flu could cause teams to forfeit.  Every school goes through up and down periods.  But programs are falling by the wayside, and the problem could get worse before it gets better.

(Granted it is not a problem in Hasbrouck Heights, and Wood-Ridge looks stronger under the leadership of Charlie Trentacosti than I remember in a while.  With both teams making the state playoffs and having good numbers in the feeder programs, both teams should be okay for the foreseeable future.)


Ridgefield High School for the second time in three years, was unable to field a varsity program, and played a junior varsity schedule.  Rumors of whether or not they play next year at a varsity level, or even want to, are almost beside the point.  Playing at a junior varsity level, lost to the Hasbrouck Heights junior varsity team 21-0 this season.  

Their junior program, used to be in the Meadowlands Football League, left two years unable to field a team in the 7th and 8th-grade level, and their fifth and sixth-grade level team had to abandon after just five games due to lack of competitiveness.  It doesn’t look that the talent is on the way to save the program.

Coming back to get beat up again at a varsity level helps no one.  Kids get hurt.  Kids get discouraged.  Support for the program drops, and the cycle continues.

But Ridgefield is not the only program that is on hard times.  Throughout the NJIC there are programs that seem to be bottom dwellers every year, picking up their lone wins in the NJIC Bowl Series, when they get to play similarly bad teams.  The Bowl Series was advertised as the way to crown a true league champion, which it does, but also guarantees that there will only be one team that is winless in throughout the entire year.

The issue is not just in the NJIC, as in late October the cause celeb in high school football was Irvington’s 80-0 victory over Belleville.  There seemed to be a greater disparity in the levels of the have’s and have-nots in high school football than ever before.

Officiating is another area that should be a concern for the NJSIAA, and for all we know, it is.  But whenever the conversation of officiating came up, most observers stated it was worse than ever remember seeing it.  Officials not only blew calls, but seemed like they did not even know what the right call was supposed to be.

And I was not even referring to the controversy at the Hasbrouck Heights - New Milford game.  At the Wood-Ridge - Becton game a five-minute discussion over a holding call being declined, giving Wood-Ridge a touchdown, but Becton a shot at tying the game on a final possession, another ridiculous case of referee confusion was forgotten.

A kickoff that may or may not have had a player step into the end zone (the officials could not agree) resulted in a five-minute debate over where the ball should have been placed. The officials went back to days of old when we all played after school for the call -a "do-over" with Wood-Ridge, now winded, kicking off to Becton. .  

The fact that the Becton returner was placed in a dangerous position by a weak whistle from one official, was forgotten by game's end.  As was the fact that he could have easily been injured by the Wood-Ridge kickoff coverage team coming at full-speed, and the sportsmanlike play of the Wood-Ridge team for pulling off the returner and not taking a full-speed shot at a player who had stopped playing.

If New Jersey somehow wins its case in the Supreme Court concerning sports betting an interesting proposition bet would be the over-under of how many penalty flags are picked up each game.  Through midseason, most public address announcers were following the phrase there is a “flag on the play” with an implied question mark.  

In Hasbrouck Heights’ season-opener against St. Mary, five times penalty flags were picked up by the officiating crew.  It was as if Enrico Palazzo had invaded a football game.  

But, the day after the end of the football season, when teams were still celebrating titles, trying to figure out when they were going to get measured for their championship rings, the state had moved on to finding a solution for a “problem” that really only realistically impacted 25 percent of its membership.  


The opinions expressed herein are the writer's alone, and do not reflect the opinions of TAPinto.net or anyone who works for TAPinto.net. TAPinto.net is not responsible for the accuracy of any of the information supplied by the writer.

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News

Hasbrouck Heights/Wood-Ridge/Teterboro

Food to Travel For - Two Jersey Shore Dining Hot Spots in National Limelight for Specialty Eats

May 12, 2018

BELMAR, NJ — Two Belmar specialty eateries have made the national food-hopping map. Coney Waffle Ice Cream and Sweet Shop on Ocean Avenue and Hoagitos in Belmar Plaza are featured this month on television shows touting what makes them stand out from the rest.

The over-the-top ice cream creations of Coney Waffle are in the spotlight in Viceland’s “The Ice Cream Show” in ...

Vehicular Homicide Charges for Driver of Paramus School Bus

May 24, 2018

MORRISTOWN, NJ - The driver of a school bus involved in a crash on Route 80 last week that killed two people faces two counts of second-degree vehicular homicide/death by auto, it was announced today.

The driver, Hudy Muldrow, 77, of Woodland Park, attempted to make an illegal U-Turn on the highway in an attempt to find his way to Waterloo Village, the planned destination of the bus that was ...

Mayor LaBarbiera Issues Statement to Grieving Community, #ParamusStrong

PARAMUS, NJ – Thursday evening, Mayor Rich LaBarbiera released the following statement to his community in regards to the horrific accident that affected so many.

"Today, our community was shaken by a horrific accident resulting in two tragic, senseless deaths of a teacher and a student. As a father of three sons, I cannot fathom the level of pain and despair that the family of the ...

Tour of Somerville Weekend: Quarter-Mile Sprints Add High-Speed Dynamic

May 23, 2018

SOMERVILLE, NJ  - The grand daddy of ‘em  all, the 75-year-old Tour of Somerville 50-mile bicycle race, anchors a weekend of world class cycling in Bound Brook and downtown Somerville May 24-28, with a new event added Sunday night to draw more spectators downtown.

Spectators this year will see an additional day of racing beginning with the Bound Brook Criterium on ...

Travels Hero Spotlight - 70-Year-Old Grandfather Completes 1,500-Mile Bicycle Ride from Key West to Morristown

MORRISTOWN, NJ – You are never too old to set another goal or dream a new dream and 70-year-old Morris Township resident Paul Kiczek proved that this weekend as he completed a 1,500-mile bike ride from Key West, FL to his hometown. He was joined by his family at the end of the final leg of his month-long trek and was even joined for the last quarter-mile by his five grandchildren in ...

Port Authority Names New Police Superintendent

NEW YORK, NY The Port Authority named Edward Cetnar – the agency’s Deputy Superintendent of Police since November 2014 – as the new Superintendent of the Port Authority Police Department, in a press release Monday afternoon.

Cetnar replaces Michael Fedorko, who announced his retirement last week after serving as Port Authority Police superintendent since 2009.

In his ...

Funnel Cloud Appears over South Plainfield

SOUTH PLAINFIELD, NJ - A line of heavy thunderstorms roared through South Plainfield Tuesday evening with a resident capturing a funnel cloud twisting down west and north of Spring Lake Park. The photo captures the funnel cloud which can be seen in the  left-hand side of the photo.

The photo captures a school bus driving by, and the South Plainfield Volunteer Fire Department ...