Colts Neck Cougars Give it Their All, Come Up Short in State Tournament Against Moorestown

#18 Kaitlyn Pierce takes a swing at the plate. She had a fielder's choice to plate Colts Neck's first run of the game in the fifth inning.
#5 Olivia Sardoff high fives #14 Briana Clementi after scoring a run to give Colts Neck a 3-2 lead. Colts Neck lost to Moorestown 9-6
#12 Mya Mancini prepares to field a ground ball at shortstop. Mancini had an RBI double in the loss for Colts Neck.
#13 Ava Metzger throws a pitch during the first inning of Monday's state playoff game. Metzger had a team-high three hits in the loss for Colts Neck.

COLTS NECK, N.J. - The situation was perfect for the No. 7 seed Colts Neck High School softball team. Leading No. 10 Moorestown 3-2 going into the seventh inning of Monday’s opening round game of the NJSIAA Central Jersey, Group 3 Tournament, Colts Neck had a shot to close the deal and advance to the quarterfinals. What happened in the top of the seventh inning was not what Colts Neck hoped for. Moorestown struck for seven runs, which ultimately led to the Quakers ending Colts Neck’s run in the state tournament with a 9-6 victory.

“We shot ourselves in the foot in the seventh inning,” said Colts Neck softball coach John Corrado. “We needed three outs, but couldn’t get them.”

Through the first four and half innings of play, nothing was going the Cougars’ way. Moorestown was able to jump out to an early lead thanks to leadoff hitter Erika Heffernen. Hefferen scored the game’s first run on a wild pitch in the first inning and then extended Moorestown’s lead to 2-0 in the top of the fifth with a bloop shot that fell in for an RBI single.

Sign Up for E-News

Down two entering the bottom half of the fifth, the bats started to come alive for the Cougars.

After Felicia Kuegler ripped a double into the gap in left center, Colts Neck had runners on second and third with one out. Kaitlyn Pierce got the Cougars on the board by smacking a single to center to plate Kuegler and tie the game at 2-2.

“I knew we had shot to tie the game and I was looking for pitch to hit to get the game tied up for the team,” Sardoff said.

A steal by Sardoff to get into scoring position helped set up Ava Metzger for an RBI single in the next at-bat, giving Colts Neck its first lead of the day.

Metzger kept the 3-2 lead in place for Colts Neck in the sixth inning, using a houdini act to get herself out of a bases loaded no out jam.

Missing out an opportunity to add to its lead in the bottom half of the frame by leaving the bases loaded, the Cougars only had a one-run lead to protect in the seventh and, unfortunately, Colts Neck and Metzger couldn’t keep the lead safe.

A double by Heffernen leading off the inning, put the tying run in scoring position for Moorestown. An infield single by Elena Illadis moved Heffernen to third and in the next at-bat, the Quakers’ center fielder recorded her second run scored in the contest, scoring on a pass ball to tie the game at 3-3.

Another ball that got past Colt Neck’s catcher Erica Cunningham, two at-bats later, allowed Illadis to score to give Moorestown back the lead and so began the seven-run rally by the Quakers.

An RBI single by Asha Bezwada gave Moorestown a 5-3 lead. Bezwada later scored on a throwing error by Cunningham when trying to throw out Jami Fiore at first on a bunt to make it a three-run lead for Moorestown.

Fielding troubles hurt Colts Neck again in the at-bat with another error allowing two runs to score for Moorestown to make it a 8-3 game.

“We had a lot of unforced errors in that last inning,” Sardoff said. “That allowed them to score a couple more runs than they should of.”

Heffernen ended her great day on the diamond for Moorestown with an RBI double to put the Quakers up 9-3 going into the bottom of the seventh. She accounted for four of the Quakers’ nine runs in the game with two runs score and two RBIs.

“I just went out there and played my game,” Heffernen said. “I’m happy that my leadoff double in the seventh inning helped the team get a rally going. Feels great to contribute to the team’s win.”

Down six runs, the Cougars didn’t go away quietly. A leadoff double by Metzger led to Briana Clementi knocking her home on an RBI single to cut the Moorestown lead to 9-4.

Metzger had a team-high three hits, an RBI, a run scored and four strikeouts in her complete game performance on the mound for Colts Neck.

Mya Mancini continued the Colts Neck rally with an RBI double to cut it to four-run deficit. Mancini later scored on an RBI single by Catherine Grillo to make it a 9-6 game.

That was as close, though, as Colts Neck could get to Moorestown as Kuegler flied out to right field to end the game, allowing the Quakers to advance to the quarterfinals.

“We didn’t give up and made great effort to get back in the game at the end,” Corrado said. “Our team has shown this year that we can come back from some big deficits. Unfortunately we couldn’t come back in this one.”

With the loss, Colts Neck drops to 13-10 on the season. The Cougars’ season is not over as they have earned a spot the Shore Conference Tournament, which they will begin on Tuesday against Monmouth Regional at home.

Corrado believes his team can make a nice run in the tournament.

“If we can play strong and shake off the mistakes we made against Moorestown, I think our team can win some games in the Shore Conference Tournament,” Corrado said.

Follow TAPinto Holmdel & Colts Neck on Twitter @holmdelcntap

Follow Steven Bassin on Twitter @SBassin_Sports.


TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News

Holmdel & Colts Neck

Upcoming Events


Mon, June 25, 10:00 AM

Bayshore Medical Center, Holmdel

Blood Donation Drive Addresses Critical Shortage

Health & Wellness


Sun, July 1, 8:00 PM

Marine Park, Red Bank

New Jersey Symphony Orchestra

Arts & Entertainment

Wed, July 25, 6:45 PM

Holmdel Public Library, Bell Works, Holmdel

If Only I Won the Lottery!

Congressman Smith Lauds BPU Action Rejecting Power Line Plan

June 22, 2018

WASHINGTON—Congressman Chris Smith (R-NJ), who represents much of Monmouth County, applauded Friday’s ruling by the New Jersey Board of Public Utilities rejecting the proposal of Jersey Central Power & Light (JCP&L) to construct a high-voltage power line between Red Bank and Aberdeen.


“Today’s decision is a vindication for local residents who fought ...

Bayshore Medical Center Welcomes David M. Junkin, M.D. Board Certified Orthopedic Surgeon

Holmdel, NJ –  Hackensack Meridian Health Bayshore Medical Center in Holmdel, NJ, is pleased to welcome David M. Junkin, M.D., to its team of physicians. Dr. Junkin is a board certified orthopedic surgeon, providing care for patients in need of treatment for sports medicine injuries or fracture, and has a special interest in knee and shoulder ...

Riverview Hospital: Nominated as One of the Most Beautiful Hospitals in the Nation

Riverview Medical Center Nominated as One of the Most Beautiful Hospitals in the U.S. in National Competition
Medical center seeks community support to claim top spot.

Red Bank, NJ – June 18, 2018 – Hackensack Meridian Health Riverview Medical Center in Red Bank, has again been nominated as one of the most beautiful hospitals in the U.S. in an annual competition run by Soliant ...

Holmdel Chamber: Sommelier and Restauranteur Chantelle Corbo Shares Bell Market Background and Culinary Inspirations

June 24, 2018

HOLMDEL, N.J. - How do you build and maintain your business? Staying visible and active in the communities you wish to do business is high on the list. Another key element is being part of an ecosystem that helps nurture your business and adds value over time. That reflects the monthly meetings of the Holmdel Chamber of Commerce.

The May meeting of the Holmdel Chamber of Commerce ...


Aug 28, 1938 - May 22, 2018
Karen A. Brooks, 79 of Colts Neck, passed away on Tuesday, May 22nd at Silver Care Center ...
Read more
Feb 2, 1936 - May 20, 2018
Margaret M. Woj, 82, of New Smyrna Beach, FL. passed away on Sunday, May 20th, 2018 in Port Orange, ...
Read more

Cool Ways to Save Money This Summer

As the summer temperatures rise, home cooling costs rise as well. But there are ways to help save money without sweating the heat:

To increase your cooling system’s efficiency by as much as 20%, get it checked out for summer.  A technician will clean the condenser, make sure you have the optimal amount of refrigerant, and ensure the airflow over the coil is ...