Business & Finance

Lawsuit Filed Against Livingston Planning Board, TMB Partners in Approval of South Orange Avenue Development; Hall Named Litigator


LIVINGSTON, NJ—A Short Hills-based organization, the Livingston Short Hills Coalition, last Thursday filed a lawsuit in Essex County Superior Court seeking to reverse the Livingston Planning Board’s approval on June 19 of a housing complex proposed by TMB Partners, a New Jersey limited liability company that lists its office address as Hollywood, Fla.

The site of the proposed complex straddles the Livingston-Millburn border line on South Orange Avenue.

According to the suit, the coalition is a limited liability company whose purpose “is to promote safe and appropriate land use development within Essex County as well as promote activities that are consistent with environmental preservation and conservation.”

Sign Up for E-News

TMB seeks to construct 62 multi-family homes on the former Tutor Time site at 650 South Orange Avenue, near White Oak Ridge Road. It proposes to set aside 12 of the units for rental to low-and-moderate-income families with the remainder going for market rates.

The Township of Livingston fought the development, contending it was not appropriate for the site, but TMB brought suit against Livingston in Superior Court under the New Jersey Council on Affordable Housing guidelines. In August 2010, the township council agreed to a settlement of that suit. That settlement eventually landed TMB before the planning board for approval and that approval was granted this June.

In addition to the housing units, the proposed complex would include a swimming pool, two levels of underground parking and common areas that are solely for the use of the residents of the market rate units.

According to the suit, the affordable units would have “an exterior parking lot separate from the underground parking reserved for the market rate building.”

In its litigation papers the coalition contends that the “economic segregation” of the amenities in the complex from the low-and-moderate-income tenants is “inconsistent with the settlement agreements and COAH requirements.”

The coalition also contends the stormwater management plan for the site approved by the planning board does not meet state requirements.

It cites planning board testimony by stormwater management expert, James Cosgrove, that the site’s system did not meet state requirements because it would fail.

This failure, according to the suit, would occur because the TMB plans calls for stormwater discharge into a vegetated area and this would cause “severe effects of erosion caused by the steep slope of the contours of the site.”

The coalition suit also notes, citing the planning board’s approval resolution, that the Township of Millburn provided wastewater sewage service to the site under an agreement with Livingston expressly precluding service for the apartment houses.

In addition, according to the litigation papers, Millburn had not agreed to accept the wastewater from the site if developed at the time the planning board approved the TMB application.

The suit also notes that TMB has filed suit against Millburn to compel that township to provide the sewage service.

Under state law, according to the coalition, an amendment to the wastewater management plan for the site would have to be adopted so that wastewater could be treated as proposed in TMB’s application.

This amendment, according to the suit, requires “numerous governmental approvals, including approval from the New Jersey Department of Environmental Protection. These approvals could take several years to obtain and there is no guarantee that they are obtainable at all.”

The litigation papers also criticize testimony before the Livingston Planning Board that sewage service by Millburn would be much more practical for the site than service by Livingston because of infiltration and inflow problems in the Livingston system.

According to the coalition, these problems were exaggerated because “these problems have already been budgeted for correction and the record does not support the current observation that there were infiltration and inflow problems on the side of the Township of Livingston where this project is proposed.”

The suit also contends TMB’s proposal to have the trash enclosure placed in the front yard of the affordable building, thus requiring garbage trucks to pick up trash from dumpsters located on South Orange Avenue would create an unsafe traffic condition and violate Essex County rules and regulations.

Calling the planning board approval “arbitrary and capricious,” the suit claims the approval is not supported by the record, is inconsistent with municipal land use law, inconsistent with the settlement agreement between the township and TMB, and inconsistent with COAH rules and regulations and state environmental law.

The coalition seeks to have the June 19 approval resolution declared arbitrary, capricious and unreasonable and to have the resolution reversed.

It also seeks award of its “reasonable attorneys’ fees and costs and such other relief as deemed just and equitable by the court.”

The Livingston Planning Board, at its meeting on Tuesday evening, approved the appointment of Gary Hall, who had served as the township’s counsel on COAH matters, as litigation counsel for the board in connection with the lawsuit against the board and TMB.

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News


Local Children Invited to Register for Essex County Summer Camps

February 19, 2018

WEST ORANGE, NJ – Children of all ages are invited to participate in spring and summer camp opportunities at the Essex County Turtle Back Zoo, Essex County Codey Arena and the Essex County Environmental Center.

The zoo has several weeklong camp adventures that will introduce children to the extraordinary world of animals, nature and science. Campers and their parents/guardians are ...

How Do I Decide Which College to Attend?

Now that college acceptances are rolling in, how do I decide which to attend?

Your hard work in high school has paid off. You took your SAT/ACT exams, got the best grades you could, and filled out as many applications as you needed to. Acceptance letters are starting to come in and you need to make a decision on where you will go in the fall. It's hard to decide!! Here are some tips and ...

NJ Governor Signs Executive Order to Fly Flags at Half-Staff to Recognize Parkland Florida Victims

February 20, 2018

New Jersey Governor Phillip D. Murphy signed Executive Order No.1 on Monday ordering the flag of the United States of America and the Flag of the State of New Jersey to be flown at half-staff to recognize and mourn the passing of the victims in Parkland, FL.

The order is for all state offices, agencies and municipalities, including schools for Tuesday, Feb. 20.

Upcoming Events


Wed, February 21, 10:00 AM

Estelle Finkel Center for Learning, Livingston

Estelle Finkel Center for Learning Presents ...


Wed, February 21, 6:00 PM

Livingston Public Library, Livingston

Free CASA Essex Volunteer Information Session

Giving Back Law & Justice


Sat, February 24, 4:00 PM

Lobby - Office Building, Livingston

Gun Violence Prevention & Congressional Candidates


Livingston Public Library Prepares for NJ Makers Day

February 12, 2018

LIVINGSTON, NJ — The Livingston Public Library will host its third annual Makers Day on Saturday, March 10. Last year, 350 people attended Livingston Library’s Makers Day and enjoyed a variety of interactive activities ranging from sewing and paper crafts to robotics and circuitry.

Makers Day is a statewide initiative designed to celebrate, promote and introduce ...

Let the Games Begin

I am truly awed by the Olympics.  Watching these superb young athletes on TV inspires me to renew my membership to the gym and pursue my lifelong dream of taking home the gold.  


The problem is that in my deluded head, I can see actually see myself standing atop the podium.  I am wrapped in a puffy designer ski coat with a huge piece of bling slung around my neck ...

In the Driver's Seat

Honey, I am going to take the Roadster out for a quick spin around the sun. I’ll be back in a few million years.


That’s nice dear. While you are out, could you pick up a gallon of milk?


In what has to be the greatest road trip of all time and space, Elon Musk, the visionary inventor, engineer, and billionaire investor loaded his very own red Tesla ...