New Jersey School Ethics Commission Finds Granata, Granatir and Calcado Violated State Law and Code of Ethics; Recommends Censure

LIVINGSTON, NJ – The New Jersey School Ethics Commission recently ruled that Livingston Board of Education members Chuck Granata, Bonnie Granatir and Tony Calcado violated New Jersey law when they released to the media the Board’s ethics complaint against former Board member Sheri Goldberg and willfully made a decision contrary to the educational welfare of Ms. Goldberg’s son by failing to sufficiently redact the complaint to protect his identity.  The Commission recommended a penalty of censure “…to impress upon these respondents the seriousness of their breach of duty to abide by the Code of Ethics for School Board Members.”

The 14-page decision details testimony provided before the Commission.  Click here to read the full decision.

Reached for comment, Ms. Goldberg provided the following statement:                                           

Sign Up for E-News

The State of New Jersey Department of Education School Ethics Commission dismissed all 8 of the ethics violations alleged against former Livingston Board of Education member Sheri Goldberg in 2010 and, in 2011, found three current Livingston Board of Education members Chuck Granata, Tony Calcado and Bonnie Granatir guilty of willfully committing two school ethics violations.

The School Ethics Commission stated in its written decision issued on February 23, 2011, that Charles Granata, Antonio Calcado, and Bonnie Granatir were guilty of willfully releasing confidential information which needlessly injured a student and willfully making a decision contrary to the educational welfare of a student by failing to take the time to protect a student’s identity when they released a partially redacted ethics complaint to the news media a week before the 2010 school election.  The School Ethics Commission stated it “does not rule out the complainant’s contention that the release of the complaint was strategically timed for days before the April election.”

“By recommending a penalty of censure, the Commission seeks to impress upon these respondents the seriousness of their breach of duty to abide by the Code of Ethics,” the February 23, 2011 decision stated.

In its July 28, 2010 decision, the School Ethics Commission dismissed all charges that alleged Goldberg disclosed confidential information. In fact, the Ethics Commission determined that private conversations between Goldberg and the superintendent did not breach confidentiality, since the superintendent is an ex officio member of the Board.

At a public meeting, Goldberg had revealed that Chuck Granata had secretly taped her telephone conversations.  The Ethics Commission determined this disclosure was not a violation, pointing out that no Federal or State law, regulation, court order, or policy requires that the surreptitious taping of Board Member’s conversations remain confidential. 

The Commission declared that Goldberg did not make any decisions contrary to the educational welfare of children. Instead they noted that she “respectfully” asked that the Board draft policies “to say exactly and precisely what we mean, so that there is no room for different interpretations.” Likewise she was not found guilty of improperly using any student’s transcript. 

In dismissing the charges, the Commission concluded that Goldberg did not surrender her independent judgment to any special interest group, nor did she use the school for personal gain or the gain of her friends.  In addition, the Commission found no evidence that Goldberg took action that resulted in undermining, opposing, compromising or harming any school personnel.

“The Ethics Commission decisions speak for themselves. “ Goldberg says about the July 28, 2010 and February 23, 2011 School Ethics Commission decisions.  

Ms. Granatir, Mr. Calcado and Mr. Granata released the following statement to The Alternative Press:

We appreciate the efforts of the School Ethics Commission in providing a balanced review of the facts and are gratified to see that in its decision, the Commission seriously questioned the credibility of the former Board member and doubted that our actions were politically motivated. We have consistently maintained that our March 2010 complaint was filed in response to improper behavior of our former colleague. The decision speaks for itself and outlines just one facet of this individual’s behavior, namely and ironically, the improper use of another student's transcript.

The SEC found that we violated two subsections of the School Ethics Act in releasing an inadequately redacted version of our original complaint to the press. First, the decision states that we violated the confidentiality of a student and second, that we did so willfully. It did not, as was previously reported, find us in violation of providing inaccurate information.

While we believe there basis for an appeal, we take away the same lessons we teach our children: honesty, integrity and doing what is right even in the face of adversity. We never, as can be seen by the decision, denied our actions and as such, we accept full responsibility for the findings of the Commission.

Members of the public who are interested in reviewing the SEC's decision may access it on the New Jersey School Ethics Commission's website as a matter of public record.


Read the February 28, 2011 decision here.

Read the July 28, 2011 decision here.

Editor’s Note:  Because The Alternative Press is specifically discussed in the context of the decision, we believe it would be a conflict of interest for us to provide an analysis of the decision.  We have chosen instead to provide both ethics decisions in their entirety so that the public can read them for themselves and we have also chosen to provide the statements by Ms. Goldberg and the respondents in full, as well. 

TAP Into Another Town's News:

Sign Up for E-News


Local Children Invited to Register for Essex County Summer Camps

February 19, 2018

WEST ORANGE, NJ – Children of all ages are invited to participate in spring and summer camp opportunities at the Essex County Turtle Back Zoo, Essex County Codey Arena and the Essex County Environmental Center.

The zoo has several weeklong camp adventures that will introduce children to the extraordinary world of animals, nature and science. Campers and their parents/guardians are ...

How Do I Decide Which College to Attend?

Now that college acceptances are rolling in, how do I decide which to attend?

Your hard work in high school has paid off. You took your SAT/ACT exams, got the best grades you could, and filled out as many applications as you needed to. Acceptance letters are starting to come in and you need to make a decision on where you will go in the fall. It's hard to decide!! Here are some tips and ...

NJ Governor Signs Executive Order to Fly Flags at Half-Staff to Recognize Parkland Florida Victims

February 20, 2018

New Jersey Governor Phillip D. Murphy signed Executive Order No.1 on Monday ordering the flag of the United States of America and the Flag of the State of New Jersey to be flown at half-staff to recognize and mourn the passing of the victims in Parkland, FL.

The order is for all state offices, agencies and municipalities, including schools for Tuesday, Feb. 20.

Upcoming Events


Wed, February 21, 10:00 AM

Estelle Finkel Center for Learning, Livingston

Estelle Finkel Center for Learning Presents ...


Wed, February 21, 6:00 PM

Livingston Public Library, Livingston

Free CASA Essex Volunteer Information Session

Giving Back Law & Justice


Sat, February 24, 4:00 PM

Lobby - Office Building, Livingston

Gun Violence Prevention & Congressional Candidates


Livingston Public Library Prepares for NJ Makers Day

February 12, 2018

LIVINGSTON, NJ — The Livingston Public Library will host its third annual Makers Day on Saturday, March 10. Last year, 350 people attended Livingston Library’s Makers Day and enjoyed a variety of interactive activities ranging from sewing and paper crafts to robotics and circuitry.

Makers Day is a statewide initiative designed to celebrate, promote and introduce ...

Let the Games Begin

I am truly awed by the Olympics.  Watching these superb young athletes on TV inspires me to renew my membership to the gym and pursue my lifelong dream of taking home the gold.  


The problem is that in my deluded head, I can see actually see myself standing atop the podium.  I am wrapped in a puffy designer ski coat with a huge piece of bling slung around my neck ...

In the Driver's Seat

Honey, I am going to take the Roadster out for a quick spin around the sun. I’ll be back in a few million years.


That’s nice dear. While you are out, could you pick up a gallon of milk?


In what has to be the greatest road trip of all time and space, Elon Musk, the visionary inventor, engineer, and billionaire investor loaded his very own red Tesla ...