Home & Garden

Rezoning Ordinance in Livingston Voted Down Following Resident Objections


LIVINGSTON, NJ — A proposed ordinance to create a new residential zone permitting a mix of home types with inclusionary, affordable components in the area of Trombley and Thurston Drive in Livingston was unanimously voted down by the mayor and council on Monday after dozens of residents from the affected area attended the final hearing to voice their concerns.

Although the comments made by dozens of residents were thoroughly considered in their final decisions, members of the council said that perhaps the most effective argument came from one resident who simply asked all those who would be negatively affected to stand. Ultimately, despite having the option to table the ordinance and send it back to the planning board for review, all members of the council—with the exception of Ed Meinhardt, who recused himself because he lives in the area—said the residents’ comments were enough to persuade them to vote it down altogether.

Mayor Shawn Klein, having recently walked the property, said “the character of this neighborhood is not the same as the other side of McClellan [Avenue],” and that it was “an easy ‘no’” for him.

Sign Up for E-News

“As soon I got on the property, this was an easy ‘no’ to vote on because I knew that this was not the right property for this [project],” said Klein. “I didn’t want to throw this back to the planning board—I wanted to vote on this tonight and I vote no.”

Having heard from planning board president Peter Klein earlier in the evening, Councilman Al Anthony said that perhaps the “more prudent thing to do would be to throw it back to the planning board to go over the numerous issues here,” but also voted against the ordinance after hearing from residents.

“It’s just the wrong project in the wrong area at the wrong time,” said Anthony. “Instead of throwing it back to the planning board, I think I’ve heard enough here tonight, so I’m going to vote ‘no.’”

Councilman Mike Silverman, who talked about the many times he’s been to the area over the last 51 years, also voted “no” based on the turnout of residents and their comments even though he did not know how he was going to vote coming into the meeting. Councilman Rudy Fernandez, before also voting against the ordinance, thanked the residents for presenting their arguments in a thoughtful and respectful manner.

“It’s nice when everybody can come out and really help us to learn more about the issues and understand them better,” said Fernandez.

Klein, reiterating these thanks, also wanted residents to know that the council works extremely hard to “be transparent” and work with the affected residents before coming to a final decision on any issue.

“That’s what this meeting is about, that’s why we listen so carefully to everybody,” said Klein. “We’ve had multiple issues that have come up over the course of the last couple years where we had special meetings just to make sure that we hear everyone out, so that we can hear everyone’s point of view…and we try to do a good job in adjudicating these issues.”

According to the ordinance, the Master Plan recommended and the council enacted an ordinance in 2005 to create the BN Neighborhood Business District for mixed-use zoning that included two-family residences. Development approval for such residences with an affordable component has been granted, the ordinance states.

The properties that would have been rezoned by this ordinance are on the opposite side of East McLellan Avenue from the BN District, where two-family housing with an affordable component has already been approved.

Amongst some of the common complaints from residents of that area were about traffic and noise concerns, excess water, density issues and more.

Seth Cohen, a Livingston resident since 2005 and a four-year resident of Thurston Drive, said he became “a part of the fabric of this community” and “understood the strength of this community” 18 months ago, when he was affected by a personal tragedy.

Cohen thanked the council for its service and for “doing what you do for putting our community first,” and, on behalf of his neighbors, asked the council to “put the community first” again by voting “no” to the proposal. He stated the following, followed by an applause from his neighbors:

“Community matters—and if we ignore the dialogue of our community, it is not who we are as a town, it is not who we are as people,” said Cohen. “What you heard tonight were concerns: you heard concerns about traffic, you heard concerns about our schools, you hear concerns about water drainage or tension—These are all legitimate, and taken individually, they matter and they should create enough pause for concern that this should not pass.

“What you did hear from my neighbors and friends is very important, too,” he said. “You did not hear a group of people who are anti-development. We all recognize and understand that a builder has a right to build—it’s why we came to the table so many years ago; it’s why 10 years ago we reached agreement on what could e built, what should be built, what is appropriate to be built on these three lots.

“The proposed is inconsistent with that. It is inconsistent with the value of that dialogue, it is inconsistent with the value of our town.

“Our town is great—not because of our development, our zoning—it’s great because of our people. It’s great because in times of success, we support one another…Our community involvement is worthy of being listened to. It’s worthy of consideration, it’s worthy of making the decision tonight that benefits our community.”

Cohen was one of the last of the many residents to comment on the ordinance at Monday’s council meetings. The final hearing went on for nearly two hours before the mayor and council voted against the ordinance and the hearing was closed. 

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News


Upcoming Events


Mon, March 19, 2:00 PM

Livingston Town Hall, Livingston




Mon, March 19, 7:00 PM

Livingston Township Hall, Livingston

Livingston Township Council Conference Meeting



Mon, March 19, 7:30 PM

Livingston Township Hall, Livingston

Livingston Township Council Regular Meeting


West Orange Restaurant Week Heads Into Weekend; Don't Miss These Offers

March 16, 2018

WEST ORANGE, NJ — Restaurants and eateries from throughout West Orange are currently participating in the Downtown West Orange Alliance’s (DWOA) second annual Restaurant Week, which wraps up on Saturday.

There will also be an opportunity to win $250 in restaurant gift certificates for purchases made during Restaurant Week.

For every purchase made at ...

Valyrian Steel: Where is it All? Should We Still Care?

There is a glaring hole in recent Game of Thrones seasons that needs to be addressed: the ability of Valyrian steel to destroy White Walkers has not been acknowledged since before Jon Snow’s death.

In fact, it hasn’t been mentioned since the Season Five finale when Jon Snow reveals this discovery to Sam Tarly. Jon has cared about little more than the war between the living and ...


Jennifer Feinberg September 28, 1969 - November 7, 2016   Jennifer Stulberger ...
Read more
LIVINGSTON, NJ - Kristine Marie Mount Wells, 48, passed away peacefully, with her loving family by ...
Read more
LIVINGSTON, NJ - The family of Ilan Altman, a 1986 LHS graduate and long-time Livingston resident, ...
Read more
LIVINGSTON, NJ - Ilan Altman, 46, of Livingston died on March 28, just shy of his 47th birthday, ...
Read more
LIVINGSTON, NJ — Colgate University Golf is currently collecting gifts in memory of a ...
Read more
LIVINGSTON, NJ — Today we honor Jane Chesner. Our beloved Jane Chesner passed away ...
Read more
LIVINGSTON, NJ — The Livingston Police Department and longtime Livingston residents are ...
Read more

Health Alert: Child with Measles Traveled to Newark Airport on March 12

March 15, 2018

TRENTON, NJ — Anyone at Newark Liberty International Airport on Monday, March 12 between 12:45 and 9 p.m. might have been exposed to measles and should contact their health care provider, according to the New Jersey Department of Health (NJDH).

The NJDH has issued a public health alert after a child with a confirmed case of measles—a highly contagious ...

Komen North Jersey Pink Tie Party Set For March 16

March 12, 2018

SUMMIT, NJ - The annual Susan G. Komen North Jersey Pink Tie Party fundraiser affair is coming up.

The event, which will be held Friday, March 16 at The Grove in Cedar Grove, is focused on raising funds to support Komen’s BOLD GOAL:  to reduce the number of breast cancer deaths in the U.S. by 50% by the year 2026, by improving access to quality and ...

Get Smart

I don’t want to be on a first name basis with my refrigerator.


Oh don’t get me wrong, I am all for cool technology—when it works—but I draw the line at talking to appliances.  I have enough trouble carrying on conversations with humans.  


But in what must be one of the truly great technological oxymorons of our time, the dawn of the ...