Township Salary Comparison - Manager is Unresponsive

August 28, 2013 at 9:00 PM

Dear Editor,
 

At a recent conference meeting of the Mayor and Council, Michele Meade was requested to prepare an analysis comparing salaries paid to Livingston employees with other municipalities.  I was surprised by the Township Manager's reply.  She indicated that it would be difficult given the lack of cooperation with other communities.

Some governments post the salaries they pay on the internet.  All salary information is available immediately with an Open Public Records Act (OPRA) request. That is exactly what I did.  For comparison purposes I selected the seven (7) municipalities that the Manager identified as "peer communities" (Westfield, Summit, Montclair, Montville, Millburn Maplewood, and the Township of Morris)  I received 100% cooperation.  Unlike OPRA requests that I submit to the Township of Livingston, I didn't have to file a Denial of Access Complaint with the State Government Records Council to get compliance.  I provided our elected officials with all the raw data I received.

Sign Up for E-News

The following are a few highlights of my research that I reported to the Livingston Mayor and Council:

  • Livingston's Manager's 2012 salary was 25.4% higher than the average of the other seven (7) communities.

  • Only four (4) communities had the title of Deputy or Assistant Manager. Livingston's pay was the highest and was 69.3% higher than the average of the other three (3)

  • Livingston's pay for Tax Collector, Health Officer and Engineer was the highest of all the other municipalities.

  • Besides Livingston only one (1) other community reported having the title of Purchasing Agent or Director of Human Resources.

I am not an expert on employee compensation.  There are a lot of variables involved like fringe benefits, education, experience, responsibilities, length of service etc.  I cautioned our elected officials to treat the information I received as a rough comparison and a starting point for further investigation.

Questions should be raised about the priorities and directions given to our Director (and assistant) of the new Department of Human resources.  I know they have created a Personnel Manual that lacks information on merit increases and policies on the personal use of Township vehicles.  I have asked and received no answers about if the $85,860 that was spent to automate sick and vacation records have been fully implement in the last two years.

With salary and wages plus fringe benefits making up the largest component of the operating budget, how can the Mayor and Council make informed decisions without basic comparative information? How are contracts negotiated?

I thought I had problems getting answers. The Township Manager seems equally unresponsive to questions from elected officials.


Sincerely,


Larry A. Kohn

The opinions expressed herein are the writer's alone, and do not reflect the opinions of TAPinto.net or anyone who works for TAPinto.net. TAPinto.net is not responsible for the accuracy of any of the information supplied by the writer. Click here to submit a Letter to the Editor.

TAP Into Another Town's News:

TAP Into Another Town's News:

Sign Up for E-News

Livingston

Livingston Football's Tyrell Garnes Named First Livingston Athlete of the Week

September 19, 2016

LIVINGSTON, NJ — In a 48-7 victory over Millburn on Sept. 10, Tyrell Garnes, a junior receiver/kickoff returner for the Livingston High School football team, had four receptions for 171 yards and two touchdowns. He also had a 92-yard kickoff return for a touchdown, earning him the title of Athlete of the Week on TAPinto Livingston.

Livingston Head Coach Robert Breschard said Garnes ...

Joint Chiropractic of West Caldwell to Offer Free Adjustments to Area First Responders During First Responders Week

September 25, 2016

WEST CALDWELL, NJ — In conjunction with First Responders Week, Sept. 26-30, the Joint Chiropractic of West Caldwell is offering a free adjustment to all police, firefighters, emergency medical technicians and the families that support them as a token of our thanks for their everyday bravery.

“The benefits of chiropractic care include relief from the back and neck pain that can ...

Police Investigate Second Attempted Luring in Roselle

September 23, 2016

ROSELLE, NJ - Another attempt to lure a youth in Roselle occurred Thursday afternoon, Sept. 22, when a 16 year old girl was approached on the 500 block of Walnut st. around 4:30p.m by a man in a silver SUV style vehicle. According to Roselle Police Chief Gerald J. Orlando, the man exited the vehicle and grabbed the girl around the waist, but the girl was able to break free and run ...

Upcoming Events

Sun, September 25, 10:00 AM

Trinity Covenant Church, Livingston

Sunday School begins for Fall 2016

Religions And Spirituality

Carousel_image_2430242f91084c038d98_5k

Sun, September 25, 10:00 AM

Township of West Orange Municipal Building, West Orange

26th Annual Mayor's 5K RUN/Walk "Break the ...

Community Calendar Giving Back

Livingston League of Women Voters to Host Public Debate for Livingston Board of Education

September 22, 2016

LIVINGSTON, NJ — The Livingston League of Women Voters will hold a free public debate for the Livingston Board of Education on Tuesday, Sept. 27 at 8 p.m. at the Livingston Community Center, 204 Hillside Avenue. 

Since incumbent Arthur Altman dropped out of the race this week, there are now four candidates running for two open positions: Barry Funt, Samantha ...

Why Have Pre-Season Physicals

The purpose of this annual event is to ensure the athlete is safe to play his/her sport. The idea is to identify any condition that could lead to an injury.

In the young athlete, the leading cause of death is sudden cardiac death. Screening for cardiovascular risks is a critical component.

The two parts of the pre-season screening is the history and physical. The history is a questionnaire, ...

LTV Studio Classics

In this LHS TV Studio Classic, Two students break the rules and decide to make some renovations to the LHS TV Studio. An LTV throwback from June 2014.

 

 

You’re Only as Old as You Dress

“Do you think this is too young for me?” asked a voice from behind me. I turned from the dressing room door where my teenage daughter was trying on clothes.

The “this” in question was a super-clingy, lycra mini dress in a black and purple animal print.

The “me” who was asking, was a 40-something year-old mom.

I was, quite literally, at a loss for ...