Township Salary Comparison - Manager is Unresponsive

August 28, 2013 at 9:00 PM

Dear Editor,

At a recent conference meeting of the Mayor and Council, Michele Meade was requested to prepare an analysis comparing salaries paid to Livingston employees with other municipalities.  I was surprised by the Township Manager's reply.  She indicated that it would be difficult given the lack of cooperation with other communities.

Some governments post the salaries they pay on the internet.  All salary information is available immediately with an Open Public Records Act (OPRA) request. That is exactly what I did.  For comparison purposes I selected the seven (7) municipalities that the Manager identified as "peer communities" (Westfield, Summit, Montclair, Montville, Millburn Maplewood, and the Township of Morris)  I received 100% cooperation.  Unlike OPRA requests that I submit to the Township of Livingston, I didn't have to file a Denial of Access Complaint with the State Government Records Council to get compliance.  I provided our elected officials with all the raw data I received.

Sign Up for E-News

The following are a few highlights of my research that I reported to the Livingston Mayor and Council:

  • Livingston's Manager's 2012 salary was 25.4% higher than the average of the other seven (7) communities.

  • Only four (4) communities had the title of Deputy or Assistant Manager. Livingston's pay was the highest and was 69.3% higher than the average of the other three (3)

  • Livingston's pay for Tax Collector, Health Officer and Engineer was the highest of all the other municipalities.

  • Besides Livingston only one (1) other community reported having the title of Purchasing Agent or Director of Human Resources.

I am not an expert on employee compensation.  There are a lot of variables involved like fringe benefits, education, experience, responsibilities, length of service etc.  I cautioned our elected officials to treat the information I received as a rough comparison and a starting point for further investigation.

Questions should be raised about the priorities and directions given to our Director (and assistant) of the new Department of Human resources.  I know they have created a Personnel Manual that lacks information on merit increases and policies on the personal use of Township vehicles.  I have asked and received no answers about if the $85,860 that was spent to automate sick and vacation records have been fully implement in the last two years.

With salary and wages plus fringe benefits making up the largest component of the operating budget, how can the Mayor and Council make informed decisions without basic comparative information? How are contracts negotiated?

I thought I had problems getting answers. The Township Manager seems equally unresponsive to questions from elected officials.


Larry A. Kohn

The opinions expressed herein are the writer's alone, and do not reflect the opinions of or anyone who works for is not responsible for the accuracy of any of the information supplied by the writer. Click here to submit a Letter to the Editor.

TAP Into Another Town's News:

TAP Into Another Town's News:

Sign Up for E-News


Livingston Cross Country's Erin Chang Named Livingston Athlete of the Week

October 19, 2016

LIVINGSTON, NJ — New to the Livingston High School cross-country team this year, freshman Erin Chang has been named Livingston Athlete of the Week.

Chang decided to try a new sport when she entered LHS this fall, and the cross-country coaches are happy she did. The freshman opened up the season by winning her first-ever 5K race, approximately 3.1 miles, in the Super Essex Conference ...

Turtle Back Zoo “BARKtoberfest” Pet Adoption Event to Benefit Friends of the Livingston Animal Shelter

October 20, 2016

WEST ORANGE, NJ – The Turtle Back Zoo welcomes Essex County residents to meet adoptable dogs, cats, puppies and kittens while supporting local animal shelters and rescue groups during “BARKtoberfest,” scheduled for Saturday, Oct. 29 from 11 a.m. to 3 p.m.

The event will take place in the Zoo’s Berson Learning Center, located directly off Northfield Avenue.

Willowbrook Mall Evacuated Due to Bomb Threat

October 12, 2016

WAYNE, NJ - A note found at Willowbrook Mall Monday evening forced an evacuation after details stated there were multiple bombs planted.

One shopper took to social media to describe her experience stating that officers rushed in with "big guns" drawn, instructing patrons to exit immediately.

After the evacuation, police officials stated that there was no threat ...

Upcoming Events


Sun, October 23, 8:00 AM

ADP Corporate Headquarters, Roseland

The 2016 Greater Northern New Jersey Heart Walk

Giving Back Sports

Sun, October 23, 11:00 AM

Reeves-Reed Arboretum, Summit

Celebrate Fall Family Festival at Reeves-Reed ...

Arts & Entertainment

Sun, October 23, 12:00 PM

Montclair Art Museum, Montclair

do it

Arts & Entertainment

Dr. Bill Kristol Speaks at Cooperman Lecture at Congregation B'nai Jeshurun

October 17, 2016

Congregation B’nai Jeshurun of Short Hills will welcome Dr. Bill Kristol as this year’s Cooperman Family Distinguished Speaker on Tuesday, October 18, at 7:30 p.m. His topic for this evening is What Do We Seek in This Election?

Dr. Kristol is the founder and the editor of the political journal the Weekly Standard.  He is a regular panelist on Fox News ...


A concussion traditionally occurs due to a force to the head or neck during a sporting activity. There are a group of symptoms that can be associated with a concussion and players, coaches and families should be aware of them.  If experienced or witnessed, then the athlete should be removed from play.  The most common early symptoms include:

1. Headache

2. Amnesia ( to the events ...

TapInto LTV: October 20th-26th

LTV's new schedule is out! And it's All About Livingston...
Your community channel televises a mix of local talk shows, sports, entertainment, town affairs and more. Plus, our new and updated Bulletin Board features info about upcoming events. Tune in to Comcast 34 or Fios 26.


Do you have an event you want to promote on ...

Why Worry?

The President of the United States and a designated Military Aide with top level security clearance are riding on Air Force One.


President: Reluctantly, I have decided to drop the bomb.


Aide: Yes, sir.  You will need this.  It’s the Nuclear Football.


President: It looks like a black briefcase with an antenna.


Aide: It is, ...

Going Toe to Toe

There are a lot of body parts I’m not particularly happy with (you thighs know who you are), but the one part of me I’ve never been bothered by is my feet. Not to be conceited, but I’ve always thought I had pretty nice feet, as far as feet go. They are not too fat or too thin, my arches are not too high or too low, and my toes all line up nicely in descending order. I ...