Real Estate

Lakefront Residents Feel Singled Out by Reval

Counter-clockwise, from left: Doty Ryan, Elisa Grotto and Jim Libby Credits: Bob Dumas

MAHOPAC, N.Y. - Residents of the lakefront community Mahopac Point believe that they and other lakefront property owners were singled out by the revaluation project and saddled with inaccurate assessments and untenable tax hikes.

Mahopac Point resident Jim Libby said it was a calculated move.

“I think they found a population of people they think they can milk for a lot of money because we live on the lake,” he said. “I think it was calculated. But we are not going away. There is going to be a class-action lawsuit if that is what it takes. Everyone is willing to contribute to get good lawyers to bust this out.”

Sign Up for E-News

Here’s an up-close look at Libby and two of his neighbors and the challenges they now face in the wake of the revaluation project.

Gertrude ‘Doty’ Ryan 
Doty Ryan is 88 years old and has lived in her Sycamore Road home on Mahopac Point since 1961. The old house was built nearly 100 years ago and sits on .37 -acre lot on the lake.

“I always thought I would spend my final days here,” Ryan said. “But I might have to leave my house and that’s heartbreaking.”

Prior to the townwide revaluation, Ryan’s house was assessed at $350,000. Now, the new assessment says its worth $1.2 million. As a result, her taxes will double from $20,000 to $40,000 and she doesn’t understand how that happened.

“When the assessor came, the first thing he said was, ‘This house is old!’” Ryan said with a laugh. “He said this place hasn’t had much work done on it since it was built. I told him we never had the money to do anything to it.”

Ryan taught in the Mahopac School District for 30 years before retiring in 1994.

“I taught first, second and third grade,” she said. “I taught [Supervisor] Ken Schmitt and [Councilman] John Lupinacci.” 

Ryan said if her assessment stands, she will likely have to sell her house and move upstate and stay with her son. But even that plan is problematic. 

“If every house on the Point and around the lake goes on sale, you won’t find a lot of buyers,” she said.

Ryan said in all her years teaching, she never once sent a student to the principal’s office. Now, she says, she feels like she’s being sent there.

“We have to fight it somehow and I want to be part of that,” she said. “But, no, I’m not too optimistic we’ll win.”

Jim Libby
Jim Libby, 73, and his wife, Patricia, have owned their home on Mahopac Point for 37 years. Their 92-year-old colonial features five bedrooms and 2,268 square feet of living space.

Prior to the revaluation it had a market value of $375,000. Now it’s set at $1.3 million.

“My taxes will go from $8,000 to $38,000,” Libby said. “That’s an extra three grand a month.”

Libby is retired and his wife will retire next year. Libby said she was devastated when they received their revaluation numbers and what it might mean.

“My wife cried for two days after we got that,” he said. “She didn’t know what to do. She literally wept for two solid days. She never lived in a house of her own until we bought this. Her family lived in apartments. So she loves this house.”

Will the Libbys have to sell if their revaluation numbers hold up?

“We haven’t gotten that far yet but I think we would consider it,” he said. “But if I had to put that house on the market, it’s not going to sell for a million-three. We would probably take a bath.”

Libby said they don’t want to leave. They cherish the neighborhood and their children and grandchildren love to visit.

“I have six grandchildren and they love the lake. It’s what keeps us here,” he said. “We can have our whole family here. It is a gathering place.”

Libby is hard pressed to figure out why his property revaluation has changed so dramatically.

“There have been no changes to the house at all. It’s like it was; we just took great care of it,” he said. “We haven’t a fabulous remodel of the kitchen or changed the blueprint.”

Elisa Grotto
For Elisa Grotto, her home on Mahopac Point is not just a house made of wood, glass and concrete. It’s a monument to a life she once had and symbol of her perseverance.

“My husband bought this property in 1988,” she explained. “We came up [from Yonkers] on weekends and fixed up the house. We got married in 1999 and then in 2000 I was widowed.”

Devastated by the loss of her husband, Grotto had some hard choices to make.

“I didn’t know what I was going to do. Do I sell the house? Do I keep it?” she said. “I was told not to keep the property, but I said no, I was going to keep it. My husband loved it; he loved the lake. It was a memory I wanted to keep.”

Grotto was determined to make it work. She was a teacher, and she worked to get her master’s degree and then a Ph.D., sometimes working two or three jobs. The more people told her owning and maintaining the house would be too much, the more resolute she was to prove them wrong.

“I worked hard to keep this house; it’s been my life,” she said. “I love it and I love the community. It’s like my family. Where would I go? I don’t know if I would find what I have found here.”

Grottos house, a two-bedroom bungalow built in 1920, had been assessed at $223,800. It jumped to $929,600. Her taxes are set to increase from $11,200 to $27,632.

“If nothing changes, it means I would have either file bankruptcy or try to sell but I won’t get what I need because my house is basically a tear-me-down. There is no way I could pay and it’s upsetting.”

Grotto doesn’t understand how the assessment could have increased so radically.

“It’s a steep slope and a lot of it’s unusable,” she said. “I have 42 steps to go down to get to the house on just .24 acres.”

Grotto said she will follow the grievance process that the town has laid out, but if she can’t find relief, she will join the class action lawsuit her neighbors are planning.
“We are going to fight,” she said. “This impacts everyone. We are not millionaires.”

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News


Cuomo Shores Up His Left Flank (at Our Expense)

We keep hearing how the Republicans are bought and paid for by the NRA. I recently explained to you the truth about this myth. The reality is the Democrats are the ones who are bought and paid for. Not by the NRA, but the environmentalists.

You thought I was going to say public sector unions, didn’t you? Well, they own both parties in New York. However, the environmentalists pull the ...

The Hatch Act and Immigration Updates

This is for information purposes only. So, when you see headlines like the recent “Kellyanne Conway cited for two violations of the Hatch Act,” you will have a working knowledge of what it means. First off, what is the Hatch Act? This has nothing to do with Orrin Hatch, senator from Utah. Simply put, it states one cannot advocate for or against candidates while serving in an official ...

The ‘Feminist’ President ... Ha!

Incredibly, it wasn’t until 1987 that Congress finally acknowledged the part women have played in the great movements of American history, declaring March to be National Women’s History Month.

And each year since, as March rolls around, U.S. presidents have stood at the lectern, extolling the virtues of American women. In President Trump’s statement, released last week, he ...

To Harrison, L'Chaim!

At long last, the smile of spring approaches, as an angry winter recedes into good riddance. Our spirit is ready to be re-charged. Damn the power outages, full speed ahead!

For my wife, Elyse, daughter, Elissa, and me, this otherwise exuberant time of year brings a confusion of mixed emotions. In 2003, on the opening day of spring, March 20, which happens to be my birthday, our 15-year-old son ...

A Half-Baked Column

“I think it’s time we retired this oven,” I said to my husband as I displayed a sheet of blackened sweet potato fries. “Even the dog won’t eat these.”

“Sure he will,” he said, tossing some fries on the floor. The dog immediately sucked them down.

“Not my point,” I said.

We had known that our oven was on its last burners for ...

When It's Not OK to Ask If Everything's OK

There is this thing that I do that annoys the heck out of my family. Well, to be honest, there are a lot of things I do that annoy the heck out of my family, but I am thinking of one thing in particular.

Whenever someone is in the bathroom for what I determine to be an abnormally long period of time, I stand outside the bathroom door and yell,


I ...

I'm All Pumped Up

This time last year, I struggled with my New Year’s resolution to go to the gym.

This year, I have made significant progress. I am going to the gym on a semi-regular basis. And by semi-regular, I mean, I go often enough that I actually remember where it’s located between visits.

The bad news, however, is that my workouts are just, how would you say it? Lame. Yes, they’re ...

Upcoming Events


Sat, March 24, 2:00 PM

South Putnam Animal Hospital, Mahopac

PCDOH Free Rabies Vaccination Clinic

Health & Wellness

Sat, March 24, 2:00 PM

South Putnam Animal Hospital, Mahopac

PCDOH Free Rabies Vaccination Clinic

Health & Wellness

Sun, March 25

First Presbyterian Church of Yorktown, Yorktown Heights

Holy Week at First Presbyterian Church of Yorktown

Religions And Spirituality

NYSEG Needs to Be Investigated

March 22, 2018

[Editor’s note: This letter exceeds the maximum word count (300 words) allowed by Mahopac News, but due to the content, we have made an exception to that rule.]

To the editor,

Friday, after seven days without electrical power, I contacted the office of the Putnam County executive where I found a sympathetic ear willing to prod New York State Gas and Electric (NYSEG) to restore ...