Lawsuit Seeks to Overturn ZBA Decisions


MAHOPAC, N.Y.— An Article 78 lawsuit has been filed against a local developer and the Carmel Zoning Board of Appeals demanding that a series of variances issued for a mixed-used project that would include retail space and a housing development on the Mahopac-Somers border be annulled.

An Article 78 is part of the state’s Civil Practice Law and Rules, which allows citizens to challenge decisions of administrative agencies such as the ZBA.

The suit was filed on Thursday, Feb. 16, by Michael Barile, a longtime Mahopac resident, businessman and developer. Barile told Mahopac News earlier this year that he intends to seek the Republican nomination to run for Town Board in November.

Sign Up for E-News

Barile is questioning variances issued by the ZBA for a project known as Union Place, which has been proposed by Baldwin Hills Realty LLC. That corporation is part of Camarda Realty Investments, which is owned by local developer Paul Camarda.

The property in question is located at 150 Route 6 near Baldwin Hills Road.

The lawsuit states that the project calls for the construction of new buildings with just over 1 million square feet on approximately 290 acres for retail and retail service space, community space, a corporate park, a hotel and 180 residential rental units.

Court documents state that Baldwin Hills Realty originally created a legal two-lot commercial 12.9 acre subdivision on one of six contiguous parcels. Shortly thereafter, the documents contend, Camarda obtained site-plan approval and started construction of a bank branch on one of the lots. In 2016, the suit says, Camarda reapplied to the Carmel Planning Board to re-subdivide the same parcel, reduce the size of both commercial lots so they become non-conforming, create a new entrance way, and add a new 172-acre parcel located to the west.

The suit goes on to contend that Camarda planned for a large multifamily housing development on the 172-acre parcel and needed to provide access and egress through the previously approved two-lot subdivision. He also wanted to move certain amenities (a pond, walking path, bike path, comfort station) from the previously approved lot to the proposed multifamily development.

The Planning Board then recommended a zone change from commercial to multifamily to accommodate the developer. The ZBA granted area variances to create the two non-conforming commercial lots, one of which now has a building constructed on it, and an entrance way to the newly created but undesignated, lot.

Barile’s suit contends these proceedings were marked by “irregularities, procedural shortcuts, and a rush to accommodate the developer all while disregarding the applicable rules, regulations and code provisions and legitimate neighborhood concerns.”

The suit notes that on Nov. 3, Camarda told the ZBA that the proposed lot-line adjustment was under review by the Planning Board. Camarda sought approval for an adjustment for the two-lot commercial subdivision of the 12.93-acre parcel to reconfigure the commercial lots to accommodate their future improvements while merging the remaining acreage to the 172-acre parcel to the west in consideration of future development plans

“Of course, the Town Board, the Planning Board and [Camarda] planned a large multifamily housing project on the new 172-acre tract, but this was not mentioned,” the lawsuit states.

The suit contends the town attorney, town engineer, building inspector and ZBA failed to notice several impediments:

• There was no valid, existing “Baldwin Subdivision”—the plat was never filed and the conditional approval expired.

• Town code “lot-line adjustment” does not permit the creation of non-conforming lots; the reconfiguration of commercial lots for “future use;” the addition of land (172 acres) to an existing subdivision; or the “merger of remaining acreage” to another parcel.

The suit goes on to say that Camarda went back to the Planning Board Dec. 21, 2016, to obtain re-approval of the original “Baldwin Subdivision,” which had lapsed and for which no map had been filed. Nonetheless, the Planning Board voted to reapprove the expired subdivision as per the original conditional approval granted Aug. 16, 2015. However, the suit contends, this was an “approval” not a denial and did not constitute a “decision” appealable to the ZBA.

The next night, the suit states, Camarda returned to the ZBA requesting the area variances but there were several impediments:

 There was no board “action” to appeal. Since the original subdivision approval had lapsed, the proposed re-subdivision map rejected by the Planning Board on Sept. 28, 2016, was invalid. The Planning Board had no jurisdiction to “reject” the re-subdivision of a plat that had expired and did not exist. The Planning Board re-approval the night before was a different map, not the one appealed from, and was an approval, not a denial.

 The application to the ZBA was incomplete. The map submitted to the ZBA did not show the entire proposed new subdivision and omitted lot#3 where the multifamily housing is planned. The ZBA was only informed about the creation of two new non-conforming lots and a “merger” of the entrance way and “lands to the west” with the Camarda’s other holdings. Nevertheless, the ZBA considered the application.

In his presentation, Camarda said he needed the “variances in order to provide amenities to the new multifamily development he is planning on the rear property. He also told the board that Putnam County wanted a new access to the William Koehler Senior Center located adjacent to the subdivision.”

The lawsuit goes on to say that, “Nearby residents expressed concern about the future use of the property, the planned multi-family housing development and the present traffic congestion in Baldwin Place. Several residents asked that the application be held over until January because many concerned homeowners were unavailable due to the proximity of Christmas. Their request for the adjournment was denied. After a presentation by [Camarda] and his engineer, the ZBA voted unanimously to grant the variances.”

The lawsuit contends that: the ZBA had no jurisdiction in the matter; the application to the ZBA was not complete; the application to the ZBA was in violation of the conditional approval; the necessary parties did not go before the ZBA, such as representatives from Putnam County; the ZBA lacked authority to grant a conditional variance; and the ZBA failed to make a SEQR determination.

Former Carmel Town Supervisor Frank Del Campo, who has been following the matter since the project was first proposed, said he and neighboring residents are concerned because of the impact the plan would have on its neighbors. He notes that the area where the Union Place project is planned has no viable sewer or water infrastructure. He said, in a recent letter to residents and the press, that neighboring properties are already suffering from water shortage and septic issues and Union Place would compound them. He also writes that it would negatively impact traffic issues along that stretch of Route 6.

“The state Department of Transportation has indicated to me…it has no intention of widening Route 6 now or in the near future,” he wrote. “Because of water, sewer and traffic issues in this area, any residential development would be devastating to the surround properties.

Del Campo is holding an informational meeting on the Union Place proposal at the Mahopac Library’s community room on Monday, March 6, at 7 p.m.

Mahopac News reached out to Camarda regarding the lawsuit and he agreed to an interview. We will publish his reaction to the suit in our March 2 issue.

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News


The Hatch Act and Immigration Updates

This is for information purposes only. So, when you see headlines like the recent “Kellyanne Conway cited for two violations of the Hatch Act,” you will have a working knowledge of what it means. First off, what is the Hatch Act? This has nothing to do with Orrin Hatch, senator from Utah. Simply put, it states one cannot advocate for or against candidates while serving in an official ...

There Is Always More to the Story

If you are getting your information from CNN, MSNBC, The New York Times or others in the mainstream media, you would think the Russians are no good dirty scoundrels, colluding with Trump to steal the election from the rightful heir, Hillary Clinton.

The leading Democrats in New York are all on board with this scenario, as are Democrats representing states across the country. You have heard ...

The ‘Feminist’ President ... Ha!

Incredibly, it wasn’t until 1987 that Congress finally acknowledged the part women have played in the great movements of American history, declaring March to be National Women’s History Month.

And each year since, as March rolls around, U.S. presidents have stood at the lectern, extolling the virtues of American women. In President Trump’s statement, released last week, he ...

To Harrison, L'Chaim!

At long last, the smile of spring approaches, as an angry winter recedes into good riddance. Our spirit is ready to be re-charged. Damn the power outages, full speed ahead!

For my wife, Elyse, daughter, Elissa, and me, this otherwise exuberant time of year brings a confusion of mixed emotions. In 2003, on the opening day of spring, March 20, which happens to be my birthday, our 15-year-old son ...

Anytown USA's Reality TV Show

Nowhere is the raw power of our Constitution’s First Amendment more earnestly practiced than in thousands of town halls across the land every time a citizen steps up to the podium to say his piece.

That also is where reality television can be seen at its rawest, as town meetings are televised to the local populace. All the familiar production values of reality TV are there in full color: ...

When It's Not OK to Ask If Everything's OK

There is this thing that I do that annoys the heck out of my family. Well, to be honest, there are a lot of things I do that annoy the heck out of my family, but I am thinking of one thing in particular.

Whenever someone is in the bathroom for what I determine to be an abnormally long period of time, I stand outside the bathroom door and yell,


I ...

I'm All Pumped Up

This time last year, I struggled with my New Year’s resolution to go to the gym.

This year, I have made significant progress. I am going to the gym on a semi-regular basis. And by semi-regular, I mean, I go often enough that I actually remember where it’s located between visits.

The bad news, however, is that my workouts are just, how would you say it? Lame. Yes, they’re ...

Upcoming Events

Sat, March 17, 7:30 PM

First Presbyterian Church of Yorktown, Yorktown Heights

Concert March 17: Songs of the Heart and the ...

Arts & Entertainment


Sat, March 24, 2:00 PM

South Putnam Animal Hospital, Mahopac

PCDOH Free Rabies Vaccination Clinic

Health & Wellness

Sat, March 24, 2:00 PM

South Putnam Animal Hospital, Mahopac

PCDOH Free Rabies Vaccination Clinic

Health & Wellness

Safety Is Schools' Top Priority

March 14, 2018

To the editor,

[Editor’s note: The following letter was sent by School Superintendent Anthony DiCarlo to Mahopac families and the school community.]

We are all saddened by the tragic events that took place in Parkland, Fla., several weeks ago, Mahopac’s collective thoughts and prayers for healing and strength are directed toward the families and students of Parkland.

I want ...