Pros and Cons of Timed Tests

Dear Dr. Linda,

Eddy, our son, is a 10th grader who is taking advanced math. He’s an excellent math student and wants to become an engineer. However, he’s not doing well this year because the teacher gives timed tests. You wrote about the issue with “math-a-minute” for elementary students once. I remember reading it—Eddy was one of those kids who loved math but hated to be timed. It still makes him nervous because he processes slowly.

I’ve spoken to his math teacher many times because Eddy knows the subject, but he often doesn’t get credit for it because he simply can’t go that fast. The teacher argues that if my son is in advanced math he should be able to think quickly and that if he can’t, he can come up with strategies that will help him. He even said that if he can’t think quickly, he shouldn’t be in advanced math. I just don’t agree with him.

Sign Up for E-News


Dear Pat,

There are two sides to this issue. The educators who argue for timed tests feel that timed tests push students to become more fluent mathematicians. They believe that scientists and mathematicians need to think quickly when working on complicated projects. They argue that eventually, in the workplace, basic math facts and formulas should be second nature, whether it’s in algebra, geometry, trig or calculus. And, to some extent, this is true. The more often we practice anything mentally, the better and stronger the associated neuronal connections are and the faster those neurons “fire.”

Those who argue against timed tests think that because of them, we are losing many students who are excellent in math and have great prospects for STEM-related jobs in the future. And they’re right. There is some evidence that timed tests cause some children’s brains, especially those in first and second grade, to change in a negative way—producing math anxiety and resultant low math achievement. The anxiety instead of the math fact is what gets learned.

Much of this phenomenon begins with “math-a-minute” in the early grades. This is when children are graded on how quickly they can do the addition facts or the times tables. A common task is for children to do 100 addition or multiplication facts in one minute. For children who process information more slowly, even if they understand the concepts, math becomes a nightmare. The effect is similar for children who create wonderful stories but “fail” writing because their handwriting is poor. I wonder sometimes how many able writers we have lost because of a teacher or parent having them rewrite and rewrite because the handwriting wasn’t neat.

So, what do good teachers do? Many teachers have timed tests, but don’t grade them. Some teachers use timed tests as a perfect Friday afternoon activity and allow kids to compete against their own prior times—not the times of other students. This gives all students the opportunity to come up with strategies to improve their timing without the stress of grades. Kids who process information more slowly get the best of both worlds this way.

Children learn the most through games, socialization and repetition. This way, being timed isn’t negative, it’s part of a fun activity with their classmates. Plus, the math student who processes slower than his peers, but understands math just as well, is not penalized.

The issue is grading based on the results, when the grade should reflect understanding of the material taught, not the speed with which it can be demonstrated. Unfortunately, college entrance exams and most standardized tests are timed and many people freeze when taking them, overwhelmed by anxiety. That’s why SAT and ACT scores aren’t the only criteria used by some colleges for admission. And, in the work world, even in jobs that involve mathematical computations, no supervisor will be standing over these kids with a stopwatch.

Dr. Linda

If you have a question, contact Dr. Linda at

The opinions expressed herein are the writer's alone, and do not reflect the opinions of or anyone who works for is not responsible for the accuracy of any of the information supplied by the writer.

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News


Old? Sick? Disabled? Die Broke!

Immediately after passing the $1.5 trillion tax reform bill last December—further enriching the “one-percenters” and exploding the national debt—House Speaker Paul Ryan spoke to a throng of fellow conservative legislators in the U.S. Capitol rotunda as they congratulated themselves on their dubious achievement. 

“House Republicans will aim to cut spending on ...

You’ll Get a Kick out of Musical Classic ‘Anything Goes’

I’ve loved Broadway musicals since I was smaller than a piano bench. That’s one reason I enjoy writing about local productions in this space. The more people who go to musicals, the happier it makes me.

I didn’t realize how old-fashioned about musicals I could be, though, until my wife Elyse and I at long last saw “Wicked.” It only took us 15 years to get there.

A (Burnt) Toast to Love and Marriage, on the Rocks

In its first few moments, sitcom-style comedy “Clever Little Lies” grabs audience attention right away, with one of the most revealing wardrobe changes you’ll ever see on stage. It is done modestly but just provocatively enough to elicit vocal appreciation from amused patrons.

The fast-paced play, starring Richard Kline of TV comedy classic “Three’s ...

The Adventures of Superdog

I was always very impressed that my dog could bark on command and come when I called his name, until I read in the newspaper about a dog that saved his owner’s life by calling 9-1-1. Apparently, when his owner had a seizure, the dog pushed a speed-dial button for 9-1-1, barked into the receiver for help, and then opened the door when the responders arrived.

Honestly, though, it’s ...

Upcoming Events

Wed, July 25, 7:30 PM

Carmel Cinema 8, Carmel

Screening: “Suicide: The Ripple Effect”

Health & Wellness

Fri, July 27, 12:00 PM

Putnam County Veterans Memorial Park, Carmel

Putnam County 4-H Fair

Arts & Entertainment Community Calendar Education Food & Drink


Sat, July 28, 10:00 AM

Hubbard Lodge, Cold Spring

PCDOH Free Rabies Clinic

Health & Wellness

Three from Houlihan Lawrence Named ‘America’s Best Real Estate Agents’

July 20, 2018

John Kincart, Douglas Dill and Annette Cicinelli have been named among America’s most productive sales associates as a part of REAL Trends America’s Best Real Estate Agents, the newly issued ranking report produced by REAL Trends and sponsored by Zillow Group. They are now members of the “America’s Best Real Estate Agents.”

REAL Trends America’s Best Real ...