The Pros and Cons of Study Guides

Dear Dr. Linda,

My ninth-grade son gets study guides from some teachers, but not from all of them. He doesn’t know what to study from—his textbook, his class notes (which neither of us can read) or his homework.

I emailed the teachers who don’t give out study guides to ask why. One teacher responded by telling me that he will not give out study guides because they limit students’ learning. I think that’s just an excuse, that he’s just too lazy to put a guide together. What should I do to get them to do their job?

Sign Up for E-News

Krissy

Dear Krissy,

First of all, preparing study guides is not part of a teacher’s job. Study guides are a rather recent phenomenon that began with your generation. They became popular in the late 1970s—those who graduated from high school before then wouldn’t recognize the term.

As with everything else in life, there are pros and cons to the use of study guides. If the teacher gives you exactly what will be on a test and you memorize it, you’re likely to get a high grade. But, since many middle- and high-school students haven’t yet fully developed the skill of identifying the most important ideas, concepts, skills and information a teacher wants them to learn and know, study guides for some kids are much better than relying on notes. Some students are good at taking notes; some aren’t. Some students comprehend what they read more easily than others. Study guides give everyone in the class the same opportunity to do well on tests.

With this said, however, there are many cons. To begin with, many students become dependent on them. They zone out during class and learn little, if anything, from homework assignments. I can’t count the number of students I’ve worked with who told me, “I don’t have to know this. I’m getting a study guide before the test.”

Most teenagers don’t yet connect the dots. They see trees, but not the forest. They get the individual facts, but don’t understand the context. When the teacher said study guides “limit students’ learning,” that’s probably what he was talking about. It can become far too easy to rely only on a study guide, make good grades on tests, and learn absolutely nothing.

Teachers who provide study guides are generally trying to kill two birds with one stone—to help students develop higher-order thinking skills in class and use the guides to remind them what facts and concepts are important to review for a test.

Before attacking the teachers for not doing their job, observe your son. Talk to him about the topics he’s studying. Find out if he’s come to rely on the study guides just to make good grades or if he’s seeing the forest as well as the trees. Either way, your focus should be on learning what you can do to help your son grow cognitively as well as focusing on the test next week.

Dr. Linda

For information on a wide range of educational topics, visit DrLindasBlog.com.

The opinions expressed herein are the writer's alone, and do not reflect the opinions of TAPinto.net or anyone who works for TAPinto.net. TAPinto.net is not responsible for the accuracy of any of the information supplied by the writer.

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News

Mahopac

How Far Down the Rathole Will New York Go?

Boy oh boy, Governor Cuomo must be wetting his pants over being primaried on his left by Cynthia Nixon. In his continued lurch leftward to stave off this challenge, last week Cuomo issued an executive order to allow parolees the right to vote in New York. That is right. Now all 55,000 parolees, which include murderers and rapists, will be able vote. The Legislature wouldn’t pass this, so ...

What Is Cambridge Analytica?

Cambridge Analytica is a research organization. Apparently, it is funded by the Mercer family, second only to the Koch brothers on the liberal hit list. Both, through their philanthropy, spend millions on various needy organizations like hospitals. What makes them liberal targets is their funding of various conservative think tanks and candidates. I digress.

Cambridge Analytica used Facebook ...

Trump Dumps on Amazon; I Dump on Trump

President Trump attacked the online retail giant Amazon earlier this month, accusing the behemoth corporation of paying “little or no taxes to state and local governments,” and taking advantage of the United States Postal Service and “causing tremendous loss to the U.S.”  

Not true! Since April 2017, Amazon has collected sales taxes in all states that levy ...

Time to Crank It Up!

It’s easy to get upset these days for any number of reasons. Still, hope springs eternal (even when we’ve given up hope of seeing spring). We live in a time of such grace and deference toward each other that a wimpy word like snowflake is the toughest insult that bullies can muster.  

We’ve all heard of the Bully Pulpit. That’s when somebody uses his leverage ...

‘Sister Act’: A Musical Like Nun Other

Of all the Broadway musicals I’ve seen over the years at Westchester Broadway Theatre, only a handful have elicited the noisily enthusiastic audience response I observed at the recent opening night of “Sister Act.”

There were outbursts of applause in the middle of some numbers, and several clever turns of phrase sprinkled in the dialogue landed squarely, to the delight of big ...

Closet Case

Not too long ago, if you said you had a room the size of a closet, it meant the space was probably pretty darn small. These days, however, it’s not uncommon to have a closet the size of a living room, with more sliding drawers, revolving racks and custom shoe trees than Barney’s or Bloomies or Kim Kardashian. So nowadays, if you tell someone you have a room the size of a closet, the ...

Cleaning the Empty Nest

Part of the shock of being a part-time empty nester is when the kids come back to visit and I have to watch my house transform overnight from a pristine haven of OCD goodness to a place that looks like an explosion happened at Forever 21.

After my kids moved mostly out, I put away whatever tchotchkes they chose to leave behind and then I put on a hazmat suit and cleaned their rooms until they ...

Upcoming Events

Sat, May 19, 10:00 AM

FDR State Park, Yorktown Heights

BluePath Service Dogs 2nd Annual Walkathon

Giving Back

Sun, May 20

Franklin D. Roosevelt State Park , Yorktown Heights

2nd Annual Northwell Health Walk at Westchester

Arts & Entertainment Giving Back Health & Wellness

Thu, May 24, 6:30 PM

Mahopac

College Admission Webinar

Education