Police & Fire

Town Board, Seniors Debate Alarm Permit Fees

Jack Bell, a Retreat at Carmel resident, discusses alarm permit fee issues with the Town Board last week. Credits: Bob Dumas

MAHOPAC, N.Y. - How do you define an “alarm?”

The was at the core of the debate between some senior citizens and members of the Carmel Town Board at last week’s meeting, as the residents claimed the $40 alarm permit fee they were being charged was not in the spirit of the law.
In December 1992, the Town of Carmel passed a local code that calls for residents to pay an annual alarm permit fee—currently $40—if such a device is installed in their home.

Chapter 37 of the code, Alarm Devices and Systems, states that no residence or business shall “install or maintain any police and/or fire alarm device… without having obtained a permit from the permitting authority.”

Sign Up for E-News

The code defines an alarm device as “any device which when activated by fire or other emergency, transmits a prerecorded message or other signal by telephone, radio, central alarm station, audible signal and/or visible signal designed to cause notification of the police department and/or fire department for a response.”

The group of senior residents at last week’s meeting reside at The Retreat at Carmel, where they say they are being charged the annual alarm permit fees for their pull-string alarms; alarms, which, when activated, will set off an audible alarm and flash a light, but are not connected to a central alarm station that would directly notify the police, fire department or EMS. They pointed out that senior communities throughout Carmel and Mahopac have similar pull-string alarms, and none of them should be included under Chapter 37’s edicts.

“The $40 pull-string fee—we consider it an attack,” said Jack Bell, a Retreat at Carmel resident. “This is not about $40. It’s about principle.”

Bell said that the law’s permit fees were intended to be a way to reduce the cost of false alarms. But since the pull-string alarms aren’t connected in any way to first responders, they should be exempt from the fee.

“They are not connected to a central station,” Bell said. “I believe the town is taking advantage of these regulations.”

Supervisor Ken Schmitt said he doesn’t view the code as ambiguous and feels that the reason for the complaints is because of the money.

“I see no reason to eliminate pull alarms from the code,” he said. “They are designed to notify someone if there is an emergency. This is a $40 fee. If there was no fee attached, no one would care.”

Councilman John Lupinacci agreed, saying the complaints were all about the money.
“We have gotten angry letters telling us, ‘we don’t care about your fees; we won’t pay your fees!’” he said. “If you want to tighten up the language [of the code], I love it. But let’s talk about what this is really about. It’s about 11 cents a day. Is it an alarm—yes or no?”

Lupinacci said the pull-string devices fall under the code as defined: even though they are not wired into a central station, they cause an “audible signal and/or visible signal designed to cause notification of the police department and/or fire department for a response,” even if it is done by someone who observes the signals and then calls 911.

Councilman Frank Lombardi, who has visited The Retreat at Carmel and spoken with the residents about their complaint, said he’s not so sure about the code’s interpretation. 

“I am not sure that the indirectness of it makes it an alarm,” he said.

The board discussed devices such as the Medic Alert bracelets and medallions seniors can wear and press for help should they fall and can’t get up. Lombardi said he felt they didn’t fall under the code, but Lupinacci insisted they did.

Schmitt said representatives from The Retreat have been meeting with him for some time on the issue and were not happy with the answers he was giving them.

“You weren’t satisfied with the answers you got from me, so you lobbied other board members who would listen to you.”

“You just gave me the bum’s rush,” Bell shot back.

Bell said if one goes by the way “alarm” is defined in the code, it can reach absurd proportions.

“We have people with Life Alert, ADT, car alarms—where does it stop?” he asked. “Next week we will be back here talking about alarm clocks.”

Jerry Ryff, another Retreat resident, said that the pull-string alarms should not fall under the code because “they don’t do anything.”

“Someone has to recognize it (the sound or flashing lights) and then do something [such as call 911],” he said. “It doesn’t initiate anything on its own. The purpose of the fee is to compensate the town [for false alarms]. This system doesn’t [create false alarms].”

Councilman Suzi McDonough was absent from last week’s meeting, but the remaining four board members seemed evenly divided on rewriting the code and whether to eliminate the pull-string alarms from permit requirements. They said they would revisit the matter with McDonough present and if a majority felt the code needed amending then it could be pursued.

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News


I Do Not Make Stuff Up!

A couple of weeks ago, I wrote in my column, “Watergate analogies apply to Obama, not Trump,” that President Obama’s Justice Department planted a spy in the Trump campaign. I said I used the term “spy” because this was a counter-intelligence operation, not a criminal investigation, where the term informant would have been proper.

That statement has been brought ...

Here's What You Missed Last Week

Last week, the Daily News ran a headline, “When is our father coming home?” This dealt with a person here illegally, married to an American woman with a family, who was arrested at an Army base while delivering pizza. You are supposed to think that U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE), under Trump, is tearing families apart. As usual, it was a crock of cow pies. It was ...

Reagan on Trump

The party of “Honest Abe” has now become the party of Dishonest Don, and what follows are some disturbing displays of a Republican Party that has become devoid of conscience:

• More than 4,600 American citizens dead in Puerto Rico—a postscript to the government’s abysmal response to the widespread devastation of Hurricane Maria; 
• The underhanded ...

The Rich Get Richer, and We’re Paying For It

According to a Harvard University study published late last year, most Americans believe that the richest 20 percent of Americans own just half of the nation’s wealth. Wrong! The top 20 percent own 93 percent of the nation’s wealth, and the top 1 percent own 40 percent of that wealth. Additionally, the top 10 percent of earners in 2017 took home more than half the nation’s ...

What Kind of Sports Parent Are You?

Social media recently showered a lot of likes and love on a high school pitcher in Minnesota whose team was playing in a regional final that would send the winning team to the state championship game.

After the last batter of the game struck out, the pitcher did something unheard of. Rather than spontaneously join his teammates in an on-field celebration, as is customary, the pitcher ...

Competing—Against Yourself

This is the time of year when students are recognized at public ceremonies for notable achievements in their studies, their sports and in their extracurricular pursuits.

Where we live, there are awards in various sports that are named for our son, who also is memorialized by town ballfield Harrison Apar Field of Dreams and a charitable foundation of the same name.

Due to a rare dwarfism, ...

Packing Heat

“Are you leaving me?” asked my husband one night as he surveyed the contents of my closet on our bed.

“What? No!” I said. “Why would you think that?”

“Every single article of clothing you own is laid out on our bed,” he replied. “So I have to assume you are either leaving me or you have joined the armed services and if that’s the ...

I Come from the Land Down Under

I know this is a family column, so I’m going to put this in as delicate terms as possible.

This morning I woke up and I knew, as sure as the sun shines over Bora Bora, that something was very, very wrong in that place in my body where the Bora Bora sun doesn’t shine.

It’s that place I used to refer to my daughter as her hoo-hoo. But it certainly wasn’t a happy ...

Upcoming Events


Wed, June 27, 9:00 AM

Putnam County Department of Health, Brewster

PCDOH Free HIV Testing Day

Health & Wellness