Opinions Differ Over Columbia High School Swimming Pool Proposal

October 25, 2013 at 12:29 PM

SOUTH ORANGE, NJ - The Board of Education (BOE) hosted a community forum to discuss capital plans and Columbia High School (CHS) renovations on Thursday evening in the CHS library. The discussion focused on the decision of whether to build a swimming pool addition at CHS.  The existing pool is in a state of disrepair and it also no longer conforms to requirements for use in interscholastic competition, which makes repairing it unreasonable. 

The session, which included members of the South Orange Board of Trustees, the Maplewood Township Committee and the general public, hinged on the issue of the expense of a new pool versus the benefits of having one. 

Building a new pool would cost taxpayers approximately $8.1 million, in addition to the $5.9 million it will cost to repurpose the existing pool area into classrooms, which are needed to accommodate the growing student population. 

Sign Up for E-News

Should the district decide not to build a pool, it would mean eliminating swimming from the physical education program as well as creating challenges for the school’s swim teams, which would have to rent pool time elsewhere and travel by bus to every practice and meet.

Resident Sue Goodman presented information regarding the potential revenue the district could recoup from having a pool.  Based on her research, nearby pools are in high demand for lessons and swim team usage.  She estimates that after expenses, a pool could generate a positive cash flow of approximately $96,000 annually.

She also expressed that swimming is a life skill that all should possess, and that roughly 30% of incoming freshmen cannot swim.  A pool would serve those students as well as the swim team and the community.

South Orange Trustee Steven Schnall said that the township is looking into upgrading its recreation facilities and has talked about the possibility of an indoor pool being a part of that plan.  However, the talks on that subject are only in preliminary stages.

Maplewood Committeeperson Kathleen Leventhal asked the BOE what the increased cost to the average homeowner would be if the new pool is built.  Cheryl Schneider estimated that the incremental cost is difficult to predict, but would probably cost the average household $20 more each year for 30 years, the life of the bond.

Maplewood Mayor Vic DeLuca asked people to think about the impact the decision will have on parents’ decisions about keeping their children in our public schools.

“If we have less than superior facilities, then that factors into their decision to walk,“ DeLuca said.  “People don’t like to pay taxes, but if people think their kids are not getting value out of their education, that is even worse.”

Resident Ed Cerny said, “A pool that people can swim in year-round is a pretty critical piece of municipal infrastructure, and it’s almost a bit of a strange discussion for this to be at a Board of Education meeting, because in a lot of towns, the pool does not have to be at a school, but that’s what we’ve got.”  He is an advocate in favor of a new pool.

David Cutler, current co-captain of the CHS swim team, told the Board that this year’s team must practice in Union four days each week from 8:30 to10 p.m., and the additional travel time to and from practice impacts study time and the ability to seek out teachers for help after school.

“Every year, we are going to see a decline in the number of students who join the swim team if it’s at an offsite pool,” Cutler said.  “Last year we had two freshman boys come out for the team, and we are losing eight seniors to graduation. There will only be seven or eight boys on the team next year if we can’t recruit any freshmen this year.”

High school freshman and competitive swimmer Brad Therol told the board that he decided to go to school elsewhere because of the lack of adequate swimming facilities at CHS. 

Roy Greenman spoke as a representative of the CHS Athletic Hall of Fame committee, who are unanimous in feeling a new pool should be built and that the swim program would be jeopardized if it is not.

South Orange resident Marion Cutler raised the issue of money.

“We can’t afford this. We are looking at, based on your projections, a $17 million shortfall in four years,” Cutler said. “It is disrespectful to say ‘Oh, it’s only $20 more.’ It’s a lot of money and we as a district cannot afford this.”  She suggested that the pool should be a municipal issue, not the BOE’s.

The financial concerns were echoed by resident Sabina Hack, who has four children who swim competitively, but feels that using limited resources to fund a pool “will result in the elimination of vital educational programs.” She said it would be foolish to spend so much on a resource used by so few.  She also suggested that swim team members could be given physical education credit for participation and could use the time during the day that would normally be spent at gym class on academic work.

Residents Michael Healy, Theresa Burns, Risa Olinsky and swim coach Maggie Singler spoke in favor of the pool.

Walter Fields said the school’s other athletic facilities that are utilized by a larger number of students are inadequate and should be addressed instead of a pool.  He points out that the fencing team and the girls’ basketball team cannot play in the CHS gymnasium because it is not large enough.

“Before you jump off this cliff, I sincerely hope you will take a comprehensive look at the total needs of the physical education department at Columbia High School,” Fields said.

BOE members offered comments to wrap up the forum:

Sandra Karriem: expressed that swimming is a life skill and that it should be taught in school; would like to see more research into revenue models of a pool; and wants to consider fund-raising effort to help fund the pool.

Wayne Eastman: said there is a very wide variety of things that could be done with $8 million and that he could not look taxpayers in the eyes and say this should be the priority for that much money.

Madhu Pai: said that in an ideal world, we would want a new pool, but questions how a fiscally strapped district can afford it when there are so many other educational priorities that must come first; she also called for private funding or a donation campaign to help pay for it.

David Giles: said he tends to support building the pool; said it would be a community draw and an important asset for the school; and that the pool could be used to teach swimming to younger children and would be a good investment for the community.

Jeffrey Bennet: said the projected shortfalls of tax revenue versus operating expenses must be considered; while the capital improvement budget and the operating budget are separate, taxpayers only care about the bottom line; higher taxes will limit the growth of other programs and he cannot support the pool.

Bill Gaudelli: said there is shame associated with not knowing how to swim, and that while budget concerns are real, a new pool will enhance the school and the community at large, making him lean toward support of the pool project.

Andrea Wren-Hardin: Although leaning toward supporting the pool, not entirely convinced; Sees the positives associated with it, but sees the budget concerns as well; Does not want other educational experiences to be compromised by fiscal constraints, but believes a pool would be well utilized.

Beth Daugherty: Said the budget deficit is real, but cost-saving measures are being explored; Does not want to raise taxes, but also sees revenue potential of the facility; Said what happens in the classroom is the most important thing, but sees a pool as something that sets CHS apart and could be a point of pride.

The slides presented at the forum are posted on the BOE website here:  The BOE will most likely vote on this issue at their next meeting in November.  Comments may be emailed to the BOE at  

TAP Into Another Town's News:

TAP Into Another Town's News:

Sign Up for E-News


October 24: The Face House in Maplewood

The "Giant Face House" on Sommer Ave. in Maplewood is a Halloween favorite for many in SOMA.

For a full list of houses decorated for Halloween, click here.

TAPinto SOMA's Photo of the Day highlights people, places, and events in and around South Orange and Maplewood. To be featured as a Photo of the Day, please send photos to Anna Sandler ...

WWII Vet in Need Unable to Keep Township Committee’s Attention

October 19, 2016

At the Maplewood Township Committee (TC) meeting on October 4th, a 91-year-old WWII Veteran implored the TC to take action to clean the “Durand Gully” behind his home. A resident of 50 years, he cited numerous calls to Town Hall and visits from various officials which offered promises but no action. Mayor De Luca assured the resident that the town would investigate and get back ...

South Orange Police Blotter; Two Burglaries Reported

October 25, 2016

South Orange Police Blotter as of October 25

Burglary to garage - An Elm Ct. resident stated that sometime between 7 a.m. and 5:30 p.m. on October 19, an unknown actor(s) had entered her garage by breaking a rear window and once inside removed a Cannondale bicycle that was locked and chained to the wall. The lock and chain was found to be cut and lying on the floor ...

Maplewood Police Blotter: Update on Carjacking on Oct. 16

Update to previously reported carjacking on October 16:
The Maplewood Police Department and its detectives have been working diligently to solve the carjacking from last week (more information here). Through their efforts, they have been able to develop probable cause as well as get complaint approval from the Prosecutor’s Office in order to charge a 13 year old. The same 13 ...

South Orange: Recent Ordinance on Leaving Pets Out in Cold Weather

October 25, 2016

From the Township of South Orange website

With winter fast approaching, the Township of South Orange Village wants to remind residents of a recent ordinance concerning leaving pets out in the cold. Here is a copy of ordinance 69-2(B):

B. Animals left outdoors- It shall be unlawful for any person to leave any animal outdoors and unattended for a continuous period of time without water and a ...

Town Halloween Celebrations in South Orange and Maplewood to be Held on Monday, October 31

SOUTH ORANGE AND MAPLEWOOD, NJ - Halloween is here on Monday, October 31, and both South Orange and Maplewood have festivities planned for that afternoon. 


The annual South Orange Halloween Festival takes place from 4 p.m. to 6 p.m. on Halloween in "Spooky" Spiotta Park on South Orange Ave.There will be music, games, an appearance from Wanda the Giant ...

South Orange - Maplewood Board of Education Candidates Forums and Events

There are five candidates for three open positions on the South Orange - Maplewood School Board: Susie Adamson, James Davis & Stephanie Lawson-Muhammad, Tony Mazzocchi and Johanna Wright.

The following Board of Education Candidates Forums and Events are scheduled:

Candidates' Open Houses - Four Sundays, Oct. 9, Oct. 16, Oct. 25, and Nov. 30, from 2 p.m.

Upcoming Events


Tue, October 25, 7:00 PM

Bane Haunted House , Livingston

Buy Your Tickets Now for Bane Haunted House

Arts & Entertainment Food & Drink

Tue, October 25, 7:30 PM

Bloomfield Civic Center, Bloomfield

Historical Society of Bloomfield Presents 'Native ...

Arts & Entertainment Education

Wed, October 26, 1:00 PM

SAGE Eldercare, Summit

Brown Bag Medication Review

Health & Wellness


Wed, October 26, 7:00 PM

Bane Haunted House, Livingston

Last Weekend for Bane Haunted House - Buy Your ...

Arts & Entertainment

Obituary: Edmund Krause, Longtime Elementary School Principal at South Orange Maplewood Schools

October 25, 2016

Edmund Krause, 86, beloved husband, father, brother and zayde, passed away peacefully at home on October 14. 

Born in Pittsburgh and raised there and in Queens, he received his BA in Education and MA in Administration from Brooklyn College.  Following graduation, he served in the U.S. Army during the Korean War, until his honorable discharge in 1953.  His intrinsic love of ...

Obituary: Lorraine F. Ashley, Age 91, of Maplewood

Born in Irvington, NJ on Oct. 14, 1925
Departed on Oct. 20, 2016 and resided in Maplewood, NJ.

Lorraine F. Ashley (nee Tingley), 91, of Maplewood, N.J., died peacefully on Oct. 20, 2016, at Inglemoor Care Center in Livingston, N.J. 

Relatives and friends are invited to attend the funeral service at Morrow Memorial Church, 600 Ridgewood Road, Maplewood, on ...

McGehee will 'Pair Responsible Decisions and Innovations'

October 23, 2016

It is with great enthusiasm and thoughtfulness that I submit my endorsement for Frank McGehee for the Maplewood Township Committee (TC) this November.  

Looking at what Frank is campaigning for, there are many things that I agree with, he is looking to think outside of the box and try and pair responsible decisions and innovations while trying to make sure that the TC can find solutions ...

Endorsement of Frank McGehee for Maplewood Township Committee

Over the past year and a half I have had the pleasure of getting to know Frank McGehee as the result of our work for the community through the Community Coalition on Race. I have been impressed by Frank's vision, intellect, drive and willingness to take on a leadership role on key organizational policy issues notwithstanding the fact that he is a relatively new trustee. When I learned that ...

In Your Community

Community Discussion on "Being Mortal"

Together, Kent Place School and Overlook Medical Center invite the community to a free film screening of the PBS Frontline film, “Being Mortal: Medicine and What Matters in the End,” on Tuesday, October 25 from 7:00 to 9:00pm.  The screening will be followed by a discussion with Atul Gawande, MD, MPH, a professor of Health Policy and Management at the Harvard School of Public ...

Is There a Conspiracy to Stick Nails in Tires?

Here’s the Sitch …

A customer recently brings her tire to a dealership for repair after finding a nail lodged into the rubber. She gets that it’s her fault and the Service Tech Dude fixes the tire. Three weeks later, the customer returns, this time waiving her hands wildly, wondering why the “check tire pressure light” had come on, forcing her to return to the ...

Staging for the Holidays

If you're thinking of selling your home during the holidays, now is the time to consider the proper amount of decorating to compliment your staging.


First, consider all of the senses. Take advantage of the fall scents to make your home feel inviting from the moment a buyer steps inside. Some ideas for infusing fall scents are heating some apple cider in a small crock ...

Free Holiday Season Parking in Downtown Millburn Begins Oct. 29

October 23, 2016

MILLBURN, NJ - Millburn Mayor Ted Bourke announced Wednesday evening at the Millburn Township Committee meeting that free parking in downtown Millburn and lots around town will begin next Saturday, October 29, and last through the holiday season. The suspension of parking fees in downtown have traditionally started on Black Friday, but shoppers will get an extra month in response to the ...

Community Meeting Held to Discuss Development of Old Hawk’s Tavern Site in Vauxhall

October 22, 2016

UNION, NJ – About fifty local residents attended a community meeting Thursday night, Oct. 20, to get information on the proposed development of the old Hawk’s Tavern site at 2140 Springfield Avenue in the Vauxhall section of Union.

Located at the corner of Springfield and Crestview Avenues, the proposed development includes a Spanish-themed restaurant on the ground floor ...

Five Halloween Hacks Every Parent Needs to Know

I’ve been celebrating Halloween with my kids for over a decade now, and as a result, I’ve got a few Halloween hacks for parents to share.

1. Go to the pumpkin patch early. Some might take this advice a step further and skip heading out to the over-crowded pumpkin-slash-apple-slash-pony-ride-slash-corn-maze extravaganza entirely, but not me. Those fall pumpkin ...

Pass me a Flagel with Cream Cheese, Please

“Ummm, this is good,” said my husband with a mouthful of food. “What is it?”

I looked up from the kitchen sink where I was doing dishes.  “It’s a cronut.”

“A what?”

“A cronut.  It’s part croissant part doughnut.”

He looked at me like I had two heads.

“I was actually going to get some duffins, ...

‘Mama’s Boy’ Explores the Life of Lee Harvey Oswald

NEW BRUNSWICK, NJ – Despite the Warren Commission, an Oliver Stone movie and various speculations, in the long run it seems that Lee Harvey Oswald acted on his own in assassinating President John F. Kennedy on Nov. 22, 1963. But Oswald was killed by Jack Ruby before his motives could be explored.

Rob Urbinati’s play, now at George Street Playhouse in New Brunswick, delves into the ...

Four Day Trip Ideas for this Weekend

October 11, 2016

There are only a few short weeks left until the fall weather turns brisker and festival season comes to an end. Don’t miss out on all the family-friendly fun available throughout the North Jersey area this coming weekend.

Annual Harvest Celebration

In Downtown Chester, the city is celebrating the season with a weekend-long fall festival taking place October 15 and 16. Highlights ...

Weekend Events in New Jersey to Entertain the Family

As Halloween quickly approaches, there are only a few weeks left to enjoy the festival season in North Jersey. If you are looking for something for the entire family to do this upcoming weekend, there’s plenty of food and fun to be found in the Garden State.

Brick Fest Live

It is no secret that children and adults alike love LEGOS. Brick Fest Live is a one-of-a-kind fan experience ...

South Orange-Maplewood Adult School Presents 'Choice 2016: The Rise of Trump'

October 21, 2016

The South Orange-Maplewood Adult School presents the Fall 2016 Redpath Lecture on Monday, Oct. 24, at 7:30 p.m. The lecture costs $10 and will be held at Columbia High School’s Black Box Theatre.

How We Got Here and How the Corporate News Media Missed It

For years, the corporate news media reported we were recovering from the Great Recession ...

The Gallery at 1978 Maplewood Arts Center New Exhibition: Pure Photography from Film to Digital

The Gallery at 1978 Maplewood Arts Center invites you to our new exhibition, Pure Photography from Film to Digital.

This exhibit will be an exploration and grand retrospective look into photographic art in its natural, purest form – from the days of film to the more recent digital process.  Acclaimed photographer, Barry Gray curates works from five renowned ...

Studio 509 Seeks Vendors for their 2017 Sip and See Trunk Show

Studio 509 is seeking vendors for their 2017 Sip and See Trunk Show on Friday, December 2.

If interested in being an exhibitor, email Studio 509 at

Studio 509 is located at 509 Valley Street in Maplewood. To learn more, visit