Millburn Board of Education Moves Election From April to November Despite Public’s Objections

The Millburn Board of Education met Monday night to discuss the election and budget process. Credits: Daniel Eckert
MILLBURN, NJ – Public outcry was loud during Monday night's Millburn Board of Education meeting when the board passed a resolution in a 6 to 3 vote to move school board elections to the first Tuesday November.
Board of Education President Michael Birnberg, Vice President Eric Siegel and board members Samuel Levy, Jeffrey Waters, Rona Wenik and Mark Zucker voted in favor of the resolution. 
Board members Regina Truitt, Jean Pasternak and Lise Chapman, who also proposed a resolution to table the resolution until a further date, which was rejected by the board in a 6 to 9 vote, sided with the majority of the public’s opinion and voted to not move the school board election from the third Tuesday of April to the first Tuesday of November.
Millburn is one of many area school districts that voted to move the elections after a bill, signed by Gov. Chris Christie last month, gave individual districts the power to move their school board elections to November instead of April. This decision can either be made by the voters, the board of education or the township council.

If the election is moved, the public will also not get to vote on the district's budget if it are at or below the state-mandated 2 percent cap. In addition, the board of education may submit an amount in excess of the cap to the voters. Also, current board members that are in their final term will serve on the board until the January 2013 reorganization meeting. The election will remain in November for at least four years.
Those in support of this bill say that a November election would save districts the cost of having an April election, which costs Millburn about $30,000, and may lead to greater turnouts at the voter poll because it is around the same time that town-wide elections take place. It also eliminates the time and effort of the board to publicize the budget and persuade them to vote on it.
Opponents say the measure takes away the only opportunity the voters have to vote on their tax bills. Also, it gives the power of other parties to take away the authority of the school board in an unprecedented manner, among other things.
The issue was of hot debate with more than a dozen residents coming up during the public comments portion before the resolution was passed to speak on the issue. Many were proponents to not changing the election because of the fact that it will take the school budget vote out of resident’s hands.
“We need a right to vote on the budget to make sure that our money is being spent properly,” Millburn resident Jeff Diecidue said at the meeting.  “We can’t just leave it to administrators and board members. I think we should have the right to vote how the money should be spent."
Resident Abby Kalan, who sat on the Millburn Board of Education several years ago, addressed comments from a few board members who said that moving the elections to November has been discussed in the town “for years” and that the public was kept in the loop on this.
Kalan said that the public not having the right to vote on a budget presented under the cap was never tied to moving the school board election; a point which was backed by many other speakers. She also reminded the board that the last time a school budget was defeated in the district was 1993.
“This is a terrible way to look at the budget process," Kalan said. "The vote belongs to us too. I have a lack of confidence in this group as a whole,” she said, receiving a loud round of applause from the public.
Another issue brought up in opposition to the passed resolution was that a few years from now the board of education may consist of a few, several or all different members who may not make responsible decisions on the budget.
Diecidue said that he has seen poor boards in the past that have created a budget that was “completely out of whack.”  He also reminded the board and the public that the district has about $8.5 million in surplus because of poor budgeting practices by past boards.
Siegel, Levy and Zucker’s seats are up in January of 2013 in which time they have the option to be re-elected to the board.
“We don’t have any insurance that the next three board members will have the conviction of keeping the budget low, as the three of you do, and we don’t know what is going to happen in the future,” resident Josh Scharf, who also previously sat on the board, said.
One of the few residents who was in support of the resolution was Jay Mattlin. A candidate in the 2011 school board election, Mattlin expressed that he believed the resolution would not “take the right to vote away.”
He added that the public has the right to vote on board members who will make the best decisions on managing a responsible budget and keeping it under the mandated two percent cap.
Before the public expressed their concerns, several board members explained their side on the issue.
Board member Truitt said that she believed the public should have the final say, not the nine board members. She added that while moving the election to November will save the district $30,000, the “real cost” to the community may be greater than that.
Board member Chapman brought up the fact that the Princeton Board of Education recently voted down Christie’s bill because of its hypocrisy in not allowing residents to vote for the budget, but at the same time allowing them to have a say against the application of charter schools.
Supporting the resolution, board member Waters maintained that he feels everyone involved with the budget process will continue to work hard to keep the tax levy low.  He said that the budget issue will still, in effect, be “taxation with representation” and that he sees no correlation between the budget vote and charter school applications.
Birnberg said that there was no right or wrong answer in this issue and the budget process will continue the way it is going now and won’t change with the elections moving. He stressed that board members should have more confidence in the public to identify and vote for proper board members in the midst of town wide elections going on.

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News

Millburn/Short Hills

Video: Scoutmaster Ken Fineran Street Dedication Ceremony

May 21, 2018

MILLBURN, NJ - Millburn Township and Boy Scout Troop 17 of St. Rose of Lima honored the life and accomplishments of late Scoutmaster Kenneth W. Fineran on Sunday, May 20. Troop 17 Scouts, in conjunction with Millburn Township and St. Rose of Lima Church.

Vehicle Stolen from Residence; Millburn Police Department Investigating

May 10, 2018

On May 2, 2018 Millburn Police Officer Barbosa responded to Neiman Marcus on a theft report. Neiman Marcus personnel report a black male wearing a black jumpsuit with the word “Kappa” on the front, and a black male wearing a blue shirt with the word “Champion” on the front each took a backpack valued at $1195.00 each and left the store without making payment. The incident ...


AtlantiCast: Episode 15

On this week’s AtlantiCast, learn some important tips for controlling and avoiding diabetes from an Atlantic Health System expert, see how Atlantic Health is advancing cutting-edge research, hear what’s being done to keep health care environmentally friendly and much more!


Upcoming Millburn Township Committee Primary Election

May 12, 2018

Dear Fellow Millburn and Short Hills Residents,

Having given the selection of a candidate for the upcoming Millburn Township Committee primary election some serious thought, I have come to the conclusion that Corey Biller has the credentials to move the Township forward in a positive manner.

I know that Corey will bring a new and positive sensibility to the Committee, one that is ...

Upcoming Events


Wed, May 30, 6:15 PM

Millburn High School (Back grass fields), Millburn

Millburn Color Run

Arts & Entertainment Education Giving Back Other


Thu, May 31, 9:00 AM

Galloping Hills Golf Course, Kennilworth

Millburn Fire Department Golf Classic


Thu, May 31, 7:00 PM

Par 440 Restaurant & Lounge, Millburn

Rocky Marciano, Jr. Unveils Rocky Marciano Wine ...

Arts & Entertainment Food & Drink

Beyond Speed Bumps! Alternatives for Traffic Calming: Free Conference June 9 at Seton Hall University

May 25, 2018

South Orange Neighborhoods Association (SONA) in conjunction with South Orange Seniors and North Jersey Neighborhoods Connected (NJNC) will be sponsoring "BEYOND SPEED BUMPS - Alternatives for Traffic Calming," a free conference at Seton Hall University on June 9 from 12:30 p.m. to 3:30 p.m.

Not every town can afford to put in a speed bump! And they can't do it on ...

Grand Opening of Lightbridge Academy in Millburn

Mark your calendars and come join us at our Grand Opening on Saturday, June 9th from 10:00 AM to 2:00 PM!! Get ready for games, crafts, music, and so much more!

Book House to Welcome Children's Author Billy Baldwin

MILLBURN, NJ -Local Author, Millburn resident and bookstore owner Nadege Nicoll, welcomes children’s book author, Billy Baldwin, of Sag Harbor, to share his wonderful picture book “Wipeout The Wave” at her new book store, The Book House at 281 Essex Street in Millburn, NJ. 

Local children ages 4 to 9, are invited with their parents to come to the store on Saturday, June ...