Millburn Township Planning Board Holds First Hearing on Mack-Cali Development

Ken Leiby, Chairman of the Millburn Township Planning Board Credits: Jonathan Sym
Edward Buzak, Millburn Township Planning Board Attorney Credits: Jonathan Sym
Millburn Township Deputy Mayor Ian Mount, member of the planning board Credits: Jonathan Sym
Richard Hoff, attorney for Mack-Cali Credits: Jonathan Sym
Lisa DiGerolamo, civil engineer and expert witness for Mack-Cali Credits: Jonathan Sym
Jack O'Connell, Vice President of Development, at Roseland.  Roseland is a Mack-Cali company. Credits: Jonathan Sym
Attorney Bette Grayson Credits: Jonathan Sym
Feng Qi, asking environmental impact questions. Credits: Jonathan Sym
Ken Ettinger, a Short Hills resident, expressing flooding concerns. Credits: Jonathan Sym
Sonali Ganti, a Short Hills resident, asking about the development's impact on the school system Credits: Jonathan Sym
Marshall Sherman, a Short Hills resident, discussing Canoe Brook Rd. with Jack O'Connell. Credits: Jonathan Sym
Aerial map of the proposed development. Credits: Jonathan Sym

MILLBURN, NJ – The highly anticipated Planning Board meeting to hear testimony from Mack-Cali witnesses in regards to the proposed Short Hills development drew hundreds of township residents to the Millburn Free Public Library Wednesday evening.

It was the first Planning Board hearing to publicly discuss and gather testimony from the applicant, 233 Canoe Brook Associates a.k.a. Mack-Cali, about the proposed mixed-use re-development of approximately 14.26 acres adjacent to The Mall at Short Hills. 

The developer intends to build a 200-unit rental complex of which 15% will be reserved for low and moderate income households, a hotel containing 246 rooms and a new two-story parking garage. The existing office building at 150 JFK Parkway will remain.

Sign Up for E-News

Attorney Richard Hoff, representing the applicant Mack-Cali, began the proceedings with an overview of the project, the witnesses who intend to provide expert testimonies and a summary of their presentation.

“The application as you will hear tonight, with the exception of perhaps a fence which we will address and resolve, is a variance free, waiver free application.” Said Hoff. “ From this understanding and belief, we have complied with each and every provision of the OR-3 zoning district as well as all applicable township zoning and design provisions.”

The hearing then proceeded with detailed explanations and testimony of the engineering aspects of the project by the applicant’s civil engineer Lisa DiGerolamo.  Her presentation discussed existing and planned design features associated with the property.  She also pointed to facets of the development that require compliance to zoning ordinances such as setback, frontage and building height requirements.

The planned four-story residential rental complex, which would be built in the southwest area of the development, will consist of 49 one-bedroom, 145 two-bedroom and six three-bedroom units.  The building will also contain a two-story, mostly below grade parking structure to accommodate a total of 421 stalls when combined with the surface lots.  The number of vehicle stalls was generated from the State’s Residential Site Improvement Standards as a guideline.

The 246-room hotel which is expected to be built north of the residential building will be five stories in height and will accommodate 394 vehicles also in a largely below grade, two-story parking structure. 

The new parking structure, at the far easterly end of the property, will accommodate 683 vehicles.

DiGerolamo also went into detail presentations as how the development will manage storm water, sewage, garbage removal, potable water, power and electricity before responding to board queries and questions from the public.

Attorney Bette Grayson representing two individuals, Stan Kerzwell and Janet Lesko, appeared before the board.  Pointing out that several questions by her and the public could not be answered at that time, she commented “maybe this whole meeting is pre-mature because all of this should have been presented.”  The comment drew large cheers from the audience. 

It was explained that Wednesday’s meeting was the first of many steps in the detailed approval process.  It is not expected that an applicant have all pertinent information at the very first meeting, particularly in a situation as complex as this one.  By the end of the process, all questions and concerns will have been addressed. 

Marshall Sherman, a Short Hills resident asked about the status of Canoe Brook Rd. and it’s continued closure.  Jack O’Connell, Vice President of Development at Roseland, a Mack-Cali company, responded, “We have zero interest to open the road.  Zero.”

Though the applicant’s traffic expert was prepared to testify, Chairman Leiby adjourned the three and a half hour long hearing until the next meeting of the planning board scheduled on March 16.

A Township Committee sponsored information session to learn more about affordable housing legislation and municipal development issues will be held on Feb. 10 @ 7:30 p.m. in Town Hall.  Residents are encouraged to attend.

Note:  Click images in the photo carousel to enlarge by 4X.

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News

Millburn/Short Hills

Millburn Recreation Accepting Memberships for Pool, Tennis and Golf

February 19, 2018

MILLBURN, NJ - The Millburn Township Recreation Department announced that it is accepting memberships for the township pool, tennis and golf facilities. The memberships are available to all Millburn Township residents and the applications are available online.

The membership application can be accessed at or go ...

Letter to the Editor: New Jersey’s Out-of-Network Bill is a Huge Blow to the Middle-Class

April 8, 2018

As Trenton currently looks to balance the budget, once again it’s our state’s hardest working citizens who will be left holding the bag. This time, though, it will be the hardworking office and ancillary staff from our small business private medical practices.  A bill called “The Out-of-Network Consumer Protection Bill” A-2039/S-485 looks poised to make ...

Upcoming Events


Thu, April 26, 11:00 AM

Bow Tie Cinema , Millburn

Encore Presentation of the 2018 Millburn Film Fest


Thu, April 26, 6:30 PM

Millburn High School Gym, Millburn

Millburn Art Celebration Thrusday: “Millburn ...


Fri, April 27, 6:00 PM

Millburn Township Fire HQ, Millburn

Millburn Firefighters Host Cook-off for Brain ...


Fri, April 27, 7:00 PM

Millburn Middle School, Millburn

MMS: Shrek The Musical

Vote for Millburn's Own Powdered Elephants "Monster" Today

April 25, 2018

Vote for Millburn's Own Powdered Elephants "Monster" Today


This is the last day to help Millburn students by voting for the drug-prevention song written by three of our high school juniors, Kyle Farscht, Danielle Benna, & Jessica Yeager. You can vote as often as you like. Voting ends April ...

Millburn Recreation Pool, Golf & Tennis Memberships

The Millburn Recreation Department is accepting Online and mail in registration for Pool, Golf & Tennis memberships.  Registrations are restricted to Township residents except for a limited number of employed in town and non-resident memberships for the Par 3 Golf Course.  Those who register for the pool by May 1st are provided six free pool guest passes per family or 3 free pool ...

Millburn Firefighters Host Cook-off to Benefit Opportunity Project

Millburn Firefighters Host Cook-off for Brain Injury 

The Millburn Police Department accepted the challenge made by the Millburn Fire Department to cook the ultimate slider in a Cook-off to raise funds for Opportunity Project, a local non-profit that assists individuals recovering from brain injury. 

 Firefighter Dave Hammond, who has taken home the prize in various cooking ...