Community Life

Back When The Mall at Short Hills was Out in the Open

The Mall at Short Hills started out as an open-air mall Credits: Millburn-Short Hills Historical Society
The Mall at Short Hills had a walkway to the parking lot in 1962 Credits: Millburn-Short Hills Historical Society
Artist rendering of B. Altman and Company Credits: Millburn-Short Hills Historical Society

DID YOU KNOW....

The Mall at Short Hills was originally an open-air mall? And that in the late 1960s the NJ Symphony Orchestra performed on the mall for an audience of more than 5,000 lawn chair-carting fans?

It all began in 1949 when the Prudential Insurance Company of America purchased the land where the mall now sits, including a parcel that is now part of the Canoe Brook Country Club. Seven years later, B. Altman & Company, an upscale department store chain, relocated its East Orange store to the Mall property. In 1961 Bonwit Teller became the second anchor store. Stauffer’s Restaurant along with 35 smaller stores including FAO Schwartz, Brentano’s, Jug Hill Mountain Smoke House and a branch of U.S. Post Office completed the Mall at Short Hills by 1962.

Sign Up for E-News

The mall was comprised of a landscaped, shaded campus-like setting 52 feet wide by 435 feet long. Set on two levels, stores were located in four separate air-conditioned buildings connected by sidewalks, stairways and escalators. The buildings were a light grey-beige brick, all with a uniform depth. The two department stores were three stories high and situated for visibility from the two highways passing by to the south, Route 24 and JFK Parkway.

Advertising for the new mall touted it as “5th Avenue in the Suburbs” and featured a caricature of a limo driver in uniform riding a 4-seater bike with two wealthy ladies and a young boy seated behind him.

In 1967, Bloomingdales became the third anchor store at the mall. It was Bloodmingdales’ largest branch, with one whole floor dedicated to furniture and home décor.

As the local population grew, the highway system became more developed, leaving shoppers with more options. This, coupled with competition from the new enclosed Livingston Mall that drew customers from a broader income range, caused business to suffer at the Mall at Short Hills. In the mid 70s, Prudential teamed with The Taubman Company (the current owners of the mall) to consider the feasibility of enclosing the Mall.

In 1980, after two years of construction costing $100 million, the enclosed Mall at Short Hills opened with new retailers including Gap, The Limited, Godiva Chocolatier and Black, Star & Frost. Abraham & Strauss joined as the fourth anchor store the following year. The new multi-level enclosed mall linked the anchor stores through a zigzag configuration, totaling approximately 1.2 million square feet of gross leasable space. Food operations in the new Mall were limited to restaurants serving sit-down food with re-usable plates, avoiding the food court scenario.

In 1990, B. Altman & Company filed for bankruptcy protection and closed all of its stores, including the Short Hills location.

The Mall at Short Hills began a major two-phase expansion in 1993. Phase one brought the addition of Saks Fifth Avenue, a complete renovation of Bloomingdales and the conversion of A&S to Macys. The second phase in 1995 premiered two new anchor stores, Neiman Marcus and Nordstrom, plus an infusion of new specialty stores including Tiffany, Fendi and Polo Ralph Lauren.

In the fall of 2016 Saks Fifth Avenue shuttered its Mall at Short Hills location and plans to open a store in the American Dream Meadowlands (formerly Xanadu) sometime in 2018. Local curiosity remains high as to what store/stores will move into the vacated Saks space. At this time, The Taubman Company has released no details about plans for that space.

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Like

Sign Up for E-News

Millburn/Short Hills

Millburn Pool Closes Doors for 2017 Season

September 4, 2017

MILLBURN, NJ - The Millburn Pool closed its gates for the final time Monday as the 2017 season came to an end. Around 750 patrons and guests visited today for one last swim. This was one of the smoothest seasons since manager John Breheney came to the Millburn Pool in 2013.

Overall, the pool brought in around 29,000 people this summer, which was about 7,000 less than the 2016 season. This ...

Traffic Stops Lead to Multiple Arrests

September 16, 2017

On September 5, 2017 Millburn Police Lieutenant Ronceray stopped a 2006 Ford Pickup when the owner, 50 year old John Heatter out of Lyndhurst, was found to be driving with a suspended license and for an outstanding traffic warrant out of Clifton. Mr. Heatter was placed under arrest and issued a summons for driving while suspended. Mr. Heatter was released with a new court date.

On September 6, ...

Upcoming Events

Carousel_image_094d1ef58cc933f53fbe_top_story_bcc7491146219ca8839a_bcfaed8a9f35be06a27c_735034_489584854416048_65863320_n

Thu, September 21

Millburn

Millburn Public Schools - Closed

Carousel_image_762068182a56aad5ed4a_b003d84e709678ae2373_top_story_bcc7491146219ca8839a_bcfaed8a9f35be06a27c_735034_489584854416048_65863320_n

Fri, September 22

Millburn

Millburn Public Schools - Closed

Carousel_image_4bf531434e1287e4d9fc_51301c70885596fb2ed4_7aa9fd6b9425ef9f1a3e_57bfd8b7b3f238ed5035_fullsizerender-11

Sat, September 23, 7:00 PM

Millburn High School , Millburn

Millburn-Short Hills Desi Club

Carousel_image_66cf83dd963f13f49719_57193818b00d9d1b9574_img_2725

Sun, September 24, 11:00 AM

Millburn

Millburn Street Fair & Shredding Truck Event

Lance: Gateway Tunnel Funds Among Wins in Spending Bill

September 17, 2017

WASHINGTON, D.C. --- Congressman Leonard Lance (NJ-07) today announced the U.S. House of Representatives has passed the required government funding measures by the end of the fiscal year.  The package includes start-up funds for the Gateway Tunnel among other Lance priorities.

“Under the leadership of Appropriations Committee Chairman Rodney Frelinghuysen, the House of ...

Clawson Architects awarded gold medal for design excellence by peers at 22nd annual architectural awards

Michael Graves School of Public Architecture, Kean University, Elizabeth, NJ – Clawson Architects, LLC, of Maplewood, New Jersey, received a Gold medal for design achievements from the American Institute of Architects regional chapters. The Newark Suburban Chapter and The Architects League of Northern New Jersey chapter awarded the Maplewood-based firm the award this year for outstanding ...

Clawson Architects awarded gold medal for design excellence by peers at 22nd annual architectural awards

Michael Graves School of Public Architecture, Kean University, Elizabeth, NJ – Clawson Architects, LLC, of Maplewood, New Jersey, received a Gold medal for design achievements from the American Institute of Architects regional chapters. The Newark Suburban Chapter and The Architects League of Northern New Jersey chapter awarded the Maplewood-based firm the award this year for outstanding ...