Other NJ News

Chatham Resident says Moms Appearing on Fox News Made Chatham 'A Global Target'

Chatham Borough resident Tracey Tango stated that Chatham became a "Global Target" once Chatham moms spoke about curriculum on Fox News Credits: TAP Chatham
Chatham Borough Council member Peter Hoffman defended the first amendment rights of Chatham mothers who appeared on Fox News Credits: TAP Chatham
Chatham Borough Council member Len Resto authored the "Welcoming" Resolution passed by the council on Monday night Credits: TAP Chatham

CHATHAM, NJ - Chatham Borough resident Tracey Tango read a letter of thanks after the Borough of Chatham Council passed a "Welcoming" resolution on Monday night, but followed up with a counter-point to council member Peter Hoffman's statement, by asserting that two Chatham moms appearing on Fox News last month had made Chatham a "global target."

Chatham mothers Libby Hilsenrath and Nancy Gayer had appeared on Fox News' Tucker Carlson Tonight on Feb. 20 to discuss the emphasis on Islam in a 7th grade "World Cultures and Geography" class. That prompted a request by residents, who signed a petition asking for a "Welcoming" resolution.

The resolution authored by council member Len Resto had passed by a unanimous voice vote before Hoffman, who voted for the resolution, made a public statement about the resolution. (Full videos of all three statements are included below).

Sign Up for E-News

"I initially found it a bit ironic that we were talking about considering a resolution that stated that Chatham values all viewpoints and opinions, when at the same time the citizens who raised concerns to the school board about an issue of import to them had their character repeatedly besmirched and denigrated, often with some abhorrent labels leveled at them, by many citizens of the town we are about to re-affirm as “welcoming,” " Hoffman said in part.

Tango read a letter thanking the board, which had been written by resident Colleen Markley, and then followed with her own response to Hoffman during the public portion of the meeting.

"I feel I need to address Mr. Hoffman," Tango said. "What you said tonight in your statement. Yes, we all have a right to question any board. Yes, we are all neighbors. And being the Girl Scout leader that I am, we teach girls to treat each other with kindness at all times. And I feel it doesn't hurt to tell adults sometimes the same. I heard about the two women going before the board of ed and didn't question it. Just as many of my neighbors and friends didn't think twice about it.

"However, once they appeared on Fox News, to my knowledge, the majority of the community of people at that time felt that them questioning the religion of Islam and saying to be taken out of our schools, basically, going on the television, put Chatham students, parents and residents as a target. Not just a target in Chatham, not just a target in New Jersey, or the United States, it put us as a global target. And if you do read through many of the comments made, if you have gotten a hold of any of those emails through to the middle school, to the board of ed, they came from members outside of Chatham, not just inside of Chatham."

Tracey Tango, Chatham Borough residents, responds to council member Peter Hoffman's remarks

Hoffman read his own statement on the resolution after it was unanimously passed the regular meting on Monday night. His statement reads as follows:

I’d like to commend Councilman Resto for drafting a resolution which sets the right tone and sends the right message regarding the reaffirmation of what I believe is already generally the case, that Chatham is a welcoming town.

That being said, I am generally not a fan of passing resolutions which engage in the practice “virtue-signaling,” resolutions designed to proclaim our own good character or moral rectitude on a particular issue. I’m usually not sure of what the purpose of such resolutions are other than to make ourselves feel better about ourselves. I think the way we treat each other in actions and deeds speaks much more forcefully than do resolutions which are forgotten about the day after they are passed.

However, I do support this resolution because it expressly affirms the right of our citizens to question those in authority, including this governing body, the school board, etc. , and to ask for transparency of policy makers in a civil way in an appropriate forum.

I initially found it a bit ironic that we were talking about considering a resolution that stated that Chatham values all viewpoints and opinions, when at the same time the citizens who raised concerns to the school board about an issue of import to them had their character repeatedly besmirched and denigrated, often with some abhorrent labels leveled at them, by many citizens of the town we are about to re-affirm as “welcoming.” So because of the way these women were treated,

I do in fact think we need to reaffirm their right, and everyone’s right, to engage in civil discourse without being accused of bigotry or having other base insults flung at them just because others may find the concerns they are expressing uncomfortable. It’s critical to democracy that people express concerns and debate policy in civil way and attempts to shut down that debate with what is essentially name- calling is counterproductive.

Peter Hoffman reads his public statement on the "Welcoming" Resolution, which he voted for

Len Resto read the resolution he authored into the record. The full text of the resolution follows

RESOLUTION REAFFIRMING CHATHAM BOROUGH’S WELCOMING NATURE AND BOTH ITS DIVERSITY AND TOLERANCE OF DIVERGENT VIEWS

WHEREAS, the core strength of the Borough of Chatham lies in its rich diversity, in the welcoming nature of its residents, in the respect and dignity with which we treat each other; and

WHEREAS, the residents of the Borough of Chatham have proven again and again that they value all of its citizens and recognize that many ethnicities and many faiths have come together in a rich mosaic to give the Borough its strength of character; and

WHEREAS, the Borough of Chatham recognizes that there is strength in diversity and inclusivity; and

WHEREAS, the Borough of Chatham realizes that only through education can we learn about each other and that education builds bridges that overcome barriers.

BE IT RESOLVED, by the Mayor and Council of the Borough of Chatham that they and the residents of the Borough of Chatham respect the right of its citizens to express their views in accordance with the U.S. Constitution and shall not condone or tolerate any form of discrimination on the basis of race, color, religious creed, age, familial status, national origin, sexual orientation, gender, gender identity, physical or mental disability or veteran status.

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Like

Sign Up for E-News

Millburn/Short Hills

What Every Real Estate Agent (and Homeowner) Needs to Know About Insurance

Real Estate Agents take on a great deal of responsibility when they guide us through the process of purchasing a home; knowing the basics of property insurance to point clients in the right direction is an important part of confidently brokering a home sale.

Under what circumstances should a buyer be concerned about special coverage?

A Vacant Home

Vacant homes are at higher risk for most ...

Millburn Municipal Pool Opening Day

May 26, 2017

MILLBURN, NJ - The Millburn Pool will open for the season on Saturday, May 27.  The pool hours on Sat. & Sun. May 27 & 28 are 11 AM to 7 PM and on Monday, May 29 (Memorial Day) the Pool is open from 10 AM to 6 PM.

The pool will be closed during the school week and will open on weekends only in June through June 18.  The pool is closed on June 19 and on June 20, 21 & 22 ...

Millburn Police Department Investigating Motor Vehicle Theft from Victim's Driveway

May 23, 2017

On May 16, 2017 Millburn Police Officer Crawn responded to the area of J lot at The Mall at Short Hills on a report by Louis Vuitton personnel of a theft. Sharod Saunders, age 20 out of Irvington, was located and arrested after the investigation showed he took a $415.00 belt without making payment. Mr. Saunders was released with a summons.

On May 16, 2017 Millburn Police Officer Kostovski ...

Upcoming Events

Carousel_image_ac26890bb1acad0f5bd7_01c11bcd9cb9e3d67f2d_best_07302822c0eb96dd8aa4_lance_for_fri

Tue, May 30, 5:30 PM

Roy Smith Theatre at Union County College , Cranford

Lance 44th Town Hall Set For May 30

Government

Carousel_image_bf9ea104b9c313d5a9d1_fullsizerender__8_

Thu, June 1, 7:30 PM

Millburn High School, Millburn

MHS Spring Concert

Carousel_image_250b2c6d384e701f4454_f020525c2db6f212e846_p6040265

Sun, June 4, 9:00 AM

Gero Park , Millburn

Millburn Recreation 4 Miler Race

Carousel_image_ece5f06ad915f8919561_1474af31e1f7d3cb264d_orchestraphotostagemms6312

Sun, June 4, 4:00 PM

Maplewood Middle School, Maplewood

Society of Musical Arts Orchestral Concert ...

Lance 44th Town Hall Set For May 30

May 25, 2017

WESTFIELD, N.J. --- Congressman Leonard Lance (NJ-07) today announced he will host his 44th in-person town hall meeting on Tuesday, May 30 beginning at 5:30pm at the Roy Smith Theatre at Union County College in Cranford.
 
During the town hall meeting, Lance will take questions and discuss the important issues facing Congress and the American people, including health care reform, the ...

Tai-Chi for Seniors Class at Millburn Library

The Millburn Free Public Library will be holding a Tai-Chi class for seniors over the summer with Linda Sercarz. Ms. Sercarz has been teaching T'ai chi chih for over 15 years, earning her accreditation in 1998. Her class will be held for six weeks at the Millburn Library, starting on Thursday, June 8, from 10:30-11:30am. The class will run until Thursday, July 13. Register on the ...

Congressman Lance Offers Millburn High School Students Service Academy Opportunity

BRANCHBURG, NJ – High students throughout the New Jersey 7th Congressional District have the opportunity to attend Congressman Leonard Lance’s annual Service Academy Information Fair. Lance’s annual event draws dozens of interested high school students considering attending one of the service academies following high school graduation.

“The academy fair allows ...

Millburn-Short Hills Chamber of Commerce Seeking Candidates for Board of Directors

Millburn, NJ – The Millburn-Short Hills Chamber of Commerce is seeking candidates to be considered for serving on the 2017-2018 Board of Directors.  Candidates who are interested in furthering the Chamber’s mission with their time, energy, expertise and passion should complete the required on-line survey by April 19.

Rick Davis, President of the Millburn-Short Hills Chamber of ...