Guest Column

Senator Vitale’s S-1285 will not lower health care costs

Dr. Jonathan Lustgarten is the past president of the New Jersey Neurosurgical Society

Sen. Joseph Vitale and his supporters have promised our citizens substantial cost savings if his out-of-network bill, S-1285, becomes law.  He claims that by restricting how much emergency and trauma specialists get paid for saving human lives, New Jersey can save up to a billion dollars a year.

The entire medical profession in New Jersey, including our hospitals, opposes this legislation because it would result in dangerous shortages of these specialists. The health of our citizens would be jeopardized.
Elsewhere, legislators have promised cost savings by artificially lowering payments to doctors.  Have their promises been kept?  Not even in one case.  

Here are examples:  

Sign Up for E-News

In 2011, Illinois adopted severely restrictive legislation that capped out-of-network billing to in-network rates. Legislators and advocates in that State promised cost and premium reductions as a result. In reality, however, costs continue to soar.  This year, insurers in Illinois have purposed rate hikes of 45 percent.

In 2010, Maryland adopted out-of-network restrictions at 140 percent of Medicare. This year, Cigna has proposed a 37 percent increase in premiums.  CareFirst, Maryland’s largest insurer, will increase rates by 50.4 percent.

In New Jersey, as of Jan 1, 2017, plans sold in the Small Group markets were allowed by the state Department of Banking and Insurance to abandon the Usual, Customary, and Reasonable (UCR) standard for elective out-of-network reimbursement.  

As a result, these plans now pay out-of-network at 110 percent of Medicare.  Despite this massive reduction in physician reimbursement, premiums for these plans have already increased 10 percent in the first six months of 2017.

Reductions in physician reimbursement, wherever attempted, have never led to the promised reductions in premiums or total costs. Why?  Because physician reimbursement represents only a small fraction (approximately 8 percent) of health care spending. Put another way, even if you paid physicians nothing, costs would continue to spiral out of control.

In contrast, the insurance industry has diverted attention away from their own practices that drive up costs for all New Jersey citizens. By eliminating the hidden fees and commissions that insurers charge when they act as third party administrators to self-funded plans, the State Health Benefits Plan could potentially save $121 million per year. So can the union plans and large employers, amounting up to $1 billion in saving to New Jersey.

Eliminating these hidden fees will save our State money without the negative public health consequences of S-1285.  Other States have already done so.

Sen. Vitale promises large savings to the New Jersey health care budget by passing S-1285. Hold him accountable to this false promise. Make him produce even one example of where this kind of dangerous policy has worked in the past.

Jonathan Lustgarten, MD, is the past president of the New Jersey Neurosurgical Society.

The opinions expressed herein are the writer's alone, and do not reflect the opinions of or anyone who works for is not responsible for the accuracy of any of the information supplied by the writer. Click here to submit a Guest Column.

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News


Murphy’s Puerto Rico Relief Commission Looks to Connect Families to Resources

March 21, 2018

PERTH AMBOY - Stephanie Márquez-Villafañe, president of the student-based Puerto Rican action group Rutgers Unión Estudiantil Puertorriqueña, offers a sobering assessment of New Jersey’s Puerto Rican student community in the aftermath of Hurricane Maria, the worst hurricane to hit the U.S. territory in recorded history.

"University students have ...

Thumbs Up: Somerville Votes Yes on Tax Rate, Parking, Public Safety

March 21, 2018

SOMERVILLE, NJ - The Borough Council introduced the 2018 municipal budget at Monday night’s meeting which  reflects a 1.88 percent increase over the 2017 budget, and translates to a $45.88 annual increase in local property taxes.

The council also gave final approval to a bond ordinance that appropriates $1.5 million to purchase property for construction of an emergency services ...

Upcoming Events

Sat, March 24

Black Diamond Billiard's, Union

Ladies 9-Ball Pro-Am by the Garden State Pool Tour

Sat, March 24

Black Diamond Billiard's, Union

Ladies 9-Ball Pro-Am by the Garden State Pool Tour

Sun, March 25, 3:00 PM

Mayo Performing Arts Center, Morristown

New Jersey Ballet's Hansel & Gretel

Middlesex County Young Republicans Host "Road to Victory" Event at the Green Turtle

March 21, 2018

NORTH BRUNSWICK, NJ -  Middlesex County Young Republican Chairman John Steiner would like to announce the Middlesex County Young Republicans "Road to Victory" Reception, which will take place on March 22 at the Green Turtle in North Brunswick from 7:30 PM to 9:30 PM.

This event will serve as the official launch for the 2018 campaign season for the Middlesex ...

TAPintoTravel’s Local Player Josh Pauls and Team USA Top Canada for Paralympic Sled Hockey Gold Medal in Sudden Death OT, 2-1

March 21, 2018

PYEYONG CHANG, SOUTH KOREA - Declan Farmer scored the equalizer with just 37.8 seconds to play in the third period and tallied his second goal of the game 3:30 into overtime to lead the 2018 U.S. Paralympic Sled Hockey Team over Canada, 2-1,  and win an unprecedented third consecutive gold medal at the Paralympic Winter Games. 

Josh ...

In Cold Blood by Truman Capote

In Cold Blood by Truman Capote (Random House, 1965)


In Cold Blood is, quite simply, the grand-daddy of true crime writing, dubbed by Capote, himself, as the first non-fiction novel (although Norman Mailer argued the point when he published The Executioner's Song in 1979.) The conditions under which I read In Cold Blood for the first time were pretty weird, which was another ...

Ian Hockley Visits New Jersey to Introduce Program to Empower Youth

This week I am taking a departure from book reviewing to share an important program that has been introduced to New Jersey this week by Mr. Ian Hockley, founder of the Dylan's Wings of Change Foundation. On December 14, 2012, Hockley's five year old son, an autistic child named Dylan, was gunned down in his classroom in the Sandy Hook Elementary School shooting. Dylan, a shy and adorable ...

'Trying' explores age, youth and points of history in poignant production

‘Trying’ explores youth, age and points of history in poignant production

By Liz Keill

NEW BRUNSWICK, NJ – The George Street Playhouse presents an engrossing, two-character play based on the real life of Francis Biddle, former Attorney General.

Biddle, a Harvard educated lawyer, served under Franklin Roosevelt and later Harry Truman during the Nuremberg Tribunal. His ...