Beth's Book Review

Prayers the Devil Answers by Sharyn McCrumb


Prayers the Devil Answers by Sharyn McCrumb (Altria, 2015)


Years later, after the tragedy, someone remembered the Dumb Supper and what had happened there. That was the cause of it, they said, because the ritual wasn't a game after all. It really was magic, but magic has rules, and she broke them. Even when they call it a 'senseless tragedy,' people always try to find a reason for it.


Sign Up for E-News

The captivating opening scene of Prayers the Devil Answers by Sharyn McCrumb sets an ancient rite in motion that is meant to foretell the future husbands of mountain maidens. A Dumb Supper, as the ritual is called, traditionally was set on the pagan holiday of Samhain. A cadre of unmarried women would cook a supper intended for their corporeal or spiritual mates, and entice them to a deserted house in the woods at midnight, where in the secret ritual the girls would lay the table out, every step done in a backwards motion, in silence. The question that McCrumb throws out to the reader is what happens when the rite goes awry; something goes wrong . . . What becomes of the magic then?

The Dumb Supper sets the tone for McCrumb's artfully plotted novel, a book that is impossible to put down once the reader has begun the story. McCrumb, who grew up on the folk yarns of the Virginia mountains, gives a unique flavor to a time and space, shrouded in the American frontier past. Although Prayers the Devil Answers is set during the Great Depression in small town Tennessee, the roots of the hardy settlers are the thread that binds the fascinating characters of McCrumb's rich and wonderful tale.

Like many of McCrumb's works, Prayers the Devil Answers began with a kernel of truth. In the Acknowledgements McCrumb writes, “Although Prayers the Devil Answers was inspired by a true story, it was not intended to be an exact chronicle of the actual events. It is true that in 1936 in Owensboro, Kentucky a woman sheriff, appointed to serve out the term of her late husband was obliged to oversee the public execution by hanging of a convicted felon. It was the last public hanging ever carried out in the United States.” (p.339) Thus, McCrumb uses this specific moment in American jurisprudence on which to build the foundation of her story.

McCrumb's charm is that she is a gifted story teller, who creates sublime character portraits of people who are believable in their strengths, but even moreso in their flaws. Ellendor Robbins, the protagonist of Prayers the Devil Answers, is as gritty as a heroine comes. Ellendor and her childhood sweetheart, Albert, have left the cramped house on his family's farm, to try life in a rural town, hoping to give their two young sons, Eddie and George, an opportunity for a decent education and better life.

Albert, with his easy manner, first works for the railroad, and is then appointed sheriff of the small town. People know and like Albert's easy manner from his deputies to the diner waitress; he has a way with words, which his quiet spouse, Ellie, does not. Unspeakably shy and friendless, Ellendor is not really lonely. It is her family's way to be retiring and fiercely independent, which is why, when tragedy strikes unexpectedly, Ellendor must find a way to provide for her two sons and herself, or return to life on the mountain living under her sister-in-law's tyranny.

Ellendor, who helped her husband with his paperwork as sheriff, is an avid reader and naturally intelligent woman. She comes upon a solution for her dilemma that seems unthinkable for a woman in the 1930s. She approaches the banker responsible for helping Albert become the sheriff and asks to be appointed for the rest of her husband's term of office. Ellendor becomes a thrilling example of what a determined female can do to fend for her family against all the male odds that put opposition in her way. Ellendor's steadfast belief in her ability to command the men in her department without making them feel inferior helps the reader to see her as a woman of good judgment and strong character.

Celia Pasten, one of the participants of the novel's opening scene of the Dumb Supper, is another female character who has decided to live an independent life. A rather plain girl, Celia determines that she will become a school teacher and not have to rely on a husband's income to take care of herself. She enjoys her job, spends long hours grading papers, and planning students' lessons, until a handsome artist stumbles into the school one day, looking for a historical picture of a pioneer battle that he wants to paint on the wall of the local post office. Celia and her artist, Lonnie Varden, suddenly find a compatibility with one another that they had not expected or really wanted in the lives they had envisioned for themselves.

Lonnie is contented with married life for a time. McCrumb writes, “He was happy with Celia, and he would not say that sometimes he wished he didn't see his future as a straight line leading directly through the decades to the grave---no turns, no shadows, no surprises, except, perhaps, unpleasant ones. Maybe that was why he had done what he had---just to put a curve in that monotonous straight line.” (p.203)

And it is in that curve that Celia's and Ellendor's fates collide and puts their stories on a parallel course. The one thing on which the reader of a Sharyn McCrumb novel can depend is that the book's conclusion will bring with it a twist worthy of O.Henry, causing a chortle to rise in the throat in the satisfaction that karma's a bitch. It is in this way that the final sentence of Prayers the Devil Answers delivers that righteous punch that the reader can't quite predict.


Beth Moroney, former English teacher and administrator in the Edison Public School District, specialized in teaching Creative Writing and Journalism. Recently Moroney published Significant Anniversaries of Holocaust/Genocide Education and Human/Civil Rights, available through the New Jersey Commission on the Holocaust. A passionate reader, Moroney is known for recommending literature to students, teachers, parents, and the general public for over forty years. Moroney can be contacted at

The opinions expressed herein are the writer's alone, and do not reflect the opinions of or anyone who works for is not responsible for the accuracy of any of the information supplied by the writer.

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News


Carteret Police Department Investigated for Firearm Permit Irregularities

March 20, 2018

MIDDLESEX COUNTY, NJ - During a time when intense scrutiny is being placed on the sale, purchase, and registration of firearms, Middlesex County Prosecutor Andrew C. Carey announced today that an investigation is underway concerning the issuance of firearms permits by the Carteret Police Department.

The Middlesex County Prosecutor’s Office has learned that numerous Permits to Purchase ...

Hillsborough: Suspended HS Athletic Director Charged with Theft

March 20, 2018

HILLSBOROUGH, NJ - Suspended Hillsborough High School Athletic Director Michael Fanizzi has been arrested and charged with the theft of $10,704 in athletic event receipts over a four-year period from 2013-2017, according to Somerset County Prosecutor Michael H. Robertson.

Fanizzi, 53, a resident of Conover Way in Hillsborough who had been athletics director for 14 years,, had been suspended ...

Upcoming Events

Wed, March 21, 8:00 PM

Kidztopia, Matawan

Business Women Networking Event

Sat, March 24

Black Diamond Billiard's, Union

Ladies 9-Ball Pro-Am by the Garden State Pool Tour

Sat, March 24

Black Diamond Billiard's, Union

Ladies 9-Ball Pro-Am by the Garden State Pool Tour

Middlesex chamber to hold "Make It & Move It Middlesex" event on Tuesday

March 20, 2018

NEW BRUNSWICK — Middlesex County Freeholder Director Ronald Rios, Freeholder Kenneth Armwood and Freeholder Charles Kenny will be the featured guests tomorrow at “Make It & Move It Middlesex,” a four-part economic development series hosted by the Middlesex County Regional Chamber of Commerce. 

Make It & Move It Middlesex is designed to connect the ...

Millennials Embrace Family Travel - Move Over Baby Boomers

March 20, 2018

FLORHAM PARK NJ - 88 million Americans are planning to take family vacations this year, the largest group planning getaways are millennials.

"Just like generations before them, millennials see a family vacation as one of the best ways to create memories and reconnect with loved ones," said Rick Del Nero, AAA Northeast Vice President of Travel. "No matter their age, families ...

In Cold Blood by Truman Capote

In Cold Blood by Truman Capote (Random House, 1965)


In Cold Blood is, quite simply, the grand-daddy of true crime writing, dubbed by Capote, himself, as the first non-fiction novel (although Norman Mailer argued the point when he published The Executioner's Song in 1979.) The conditions under which I read In Cold Blood for the first time were pretty weird, which was another ...

Ian Hockley Visits New Jersey to Introduce Program to Empower Youth

This week I am taking a departure from book reviewing to share an important program that has been introduced to New Jersey this week by Mr. Ian Hockley, founder of the Dylan's Wings of Change Foundation. On December 14, 2012, Hockley's five year old son, an autistic child named Dylan, was gunned down in his classroom in the Sandy Hook Elementary School shooting. Dylan, a shy and adorable ...

'Trying' explores age, youth and points of history in poignant production

‘Trying’ explores youth, age and points of history in poignant production

By Liz Keill

NEW BRUNSWICK, NJ – The George Street Playhouse presents an engrossing, two-character play based on the real life of Francis Biddle, former Attorney General.

Biddle, a Harvard educated lawyer, served under Franklin Roosevelt and later Harry Truman during the Nuremberg Tribunal. His ...