Could New Ruling Affect 'Couch-Hopping' Montclair BOE Member's Residency Privacy Argument?


MONTCLAIR, NJ - Nearly a week has passed since a complaint was filed with the New Jersey Education Commissioner regarding the residency of Montclair Board of Education Vice President Franklin Turner.

As of Wednesday, David Herron, who filed the initial complaint, says that he is pleased with a recent court ruling. He wrote, "The NJ Supreme Court, ruled today, that home addresses of public official are not private."

The ruling Herron is referring to is, Brennan V. Bergen County Prosecutor's Office, which is referring to a case where Brennan demanded to know the names of vendors whom he alleges sold him memorabilia that wasn't authentic.

Sign Up for E-News

The ruling states: “To guard against possible abuses, the public has a right to know what property was sold, at what price, and to whom. OPRA’s plain terms call for disclosure of that type of recorded information, including the names and addresses of successful bidders,” Judge Rabner wrote.  “To hold otherwise would jeopardize OPRA’s purpose: to maximize public knowledge about public affairs in order to ensure an informed citizenry and to minimize the evils inherent in a secluded process.”

Herron alleges that the ruling in this case, supports his complaint against Turner.

Herron, a Montclair resident, filed a complaint on May 18 alleging that Turner does not meet the residency requirements for a board member.

In the complaint, Herron alleges that has been residing with various friends and family members since separating from his wife and is therefore ineligible to serve on the Board. Turner’s subsequent removal from the Board is requested, a position he has held since 2016. There has been no further movement on the complaint filed by Herron.

A BOE member must be a resident of the district for at least one year immediately preceding his or her appointment or election, NJ law states. 

According to N.J.S.A. 18A:12-3, whenever a member of a local Board of Education shall cease to be a bona fide resident of the district which he represents, his membership to the Board shall immediately cease.

When Turner was sworn-in in 2016, he used the Upper Mountain Avenue address. However, the complaint refutes this, claiming that Turner had been separated from his wife and did not reside there at that time.

The last known address for Turner is his family’s former address on Upper Mountain Avenue, which records indicate was sold in September 2017. According to Herron’s complaint, Turner lists 41 Watchung Plaza, Apt. 110, as his street address under seller's information on a State of New Jersey Seller's Residency Certification/Exemption form dated Sept. 6, 2017. 

The complaint further alleges that Turner has since been couch-hopping in an effort to continue to hold his position as a BOE member, indicating that he is also using a UPS mailbox as his address. 41 Watchung Plaza #110 is the address to the UPS store.

In a statement addressing the allegations during the May 16th BOE meeting, Turner maintains that he lives in Montclair. 

During the BOE meeting, Turner paraphrased a recent interview stating, “...I will not answer any more questions about my residency, I will not legitimize this interview or the allegations.” 







TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News


South Orange Middle School Students Have Photo Op With Rep. Payne in Washington, D.C.

June 16, 2018

WASHINGTON, DC - South Orange Middle School (SOMS) students on a visit to Capitol Hill as part of the 8th grade trip to Washington, DC. had the chance to meet with and take a photo with Donald Payne, Jr. on Friday. Payne is the U.S. Representative for New Jersey District 10, which includes South Orange and Maplewood.

Photos of the students with Rep. Payne were ...

Suspect Charged with Using Sword in Fight Over Parking Spot in NJ

June 19, 2018


SOMERVILLE, NJ  - A Manville man has been charged with aggravated assault and other charges after police say he attacked another man with a sword in a dispute over a parking space.

The victim had attacked the suspect, Jared Razzano, 35, of North 9th Avenue, with a contractor’s four-foot level, according to the Somerset County  Prosecturors Office, but he has not been ...

Upcoming Events


Tue, June 19, 11:00 AM

Montclair Public Library , Montclair

Roaming Readers- A Walking, Talking Book Club

Tue, June 19, 6:30 PM

70 South Gallery, Morristown


Arts & Entertainment


Tue, June 19, 6:30 PM

Montclair Public Library , Montclair

Josiah: A Forgotten Hero of the Abolitionist ...

Arts & Entertainment

To the Editor: Labor Unions Have Set Standards for Americans

June 5, 2018

To the Editor:

I want to alert every working American to a case now before the U.S. Supreme Court.  It is called “Janus vs. AFSCME” and it seeks to defund and cripple the same labor unions that, over decades, have raised every American’s standard of living.

Even if your workplace is not unionized, you can thank our American labor unions for locking in higher standards ...

Montclair Police Blotter: Thai Chef Burglarized, Four iPhones Stolen and More

June 13, 2018

MONTCLAIR, NJ -  The following police blotter was compiled by the Montclair Police Department on June 12, 2018:


06-05-2018 (Union Street) Burglary to an apartment.  Cash was taken in this incident.  Access was gained through an unlocked rear door.  

06-05-2018 (Union Street) Theft of a scooter from the rear yard of a residence.

06-05-2018 (Elm ...

ECLC of New Jersey Graduates Montclair Student

June 19, 2018

Dylan Brown of Montclair was among students who graduated on June 14 from ECLC of New Jersey’s school for students with special needs in Chatham.

The young adults received high school diplomas conferred by their hometown districts. During the ceremony, each graduate was given an opportunity to speak and deliver their "reflections," a school tradition for many years. In his ...