Food & Drink

The Difference Between Gelato and Ice Cream: A Lesson from Experts at Gelotti Ice Cream

cdd5b1cccabd32ab71e4_Blueberry_Basil.jpg
Credits: John Lee / TAPinto photographer
cdd5b1cccabd32ab71e4_Blueberry_Basil.jpg

PATERSON, N.J. - Time after time customers enter our stores with misconceptions of what gelato is, and what the difference is between gelato and ice cream. Unfortunately the food business can be a tricky thing to navigate, especially in the world of sugar free water, gluten free soda, and fat free products with dangerously high levels of sugar.

The Misconception

Have you ever heard the term in math that all rectangles are squares, but that all squares are not rectangles? Lets compare this to gelato and ice cream. All frozen desserts are gelato, but not all gelato is ice cream.

Sign Up for E-News

The word gelato comes from the Italian word "congelato" or to freeze, in Spanish it is similar in that they call ice cream "helado" and "congelado" is to freeze. The word gelato itself refers more to a product made by freezing, and there are less rules that govern gelato than ice cream. 

Background of the "Rules of Ice Cream"

In the Bronx, Emery Thompson invented the first horizontal ice cream batch freezer in 1903. A batch freezer is basically a large horizontal mixer whose walls are pumped with refrigerant from a compressor. As the ice cream mixes and get incorporated with air, dasher blades are scraping the frozen ice cream off of the walls to the beat of 200 revolutions a minute. 

When Gelotti first opened we started with two Emery Thompson machines back in 1984. Emery's son Steve Thompson sold Gelotti our machines, and continues to serve Gelotti with their latest versions. Fun fact, both Gelotti and Haagen-Daaz started with Emery Thompson machines in the 80's. Contrary to popular belief Haagen-Daaz started in the Bronx just down the road from Thompson's factory, the name was chosen because Swedish products like Ikea and Volvo were hot and catchy.

Thompson began to experiment with making large quantities in his machine and helped facilitate the ice cream crazy in the United States. One of the things that Emery soon came to find, was that whatever amount of ice cream mix he put in the machine, it would double in volume after the freezing cycle. This incorporated air is called "over-run" and gives ice cream the suspension it needs to be smooth, creamy, and keep the product soft enough to scoop from a container.

A politician from South Carolina got word of air being incorporated to ice cream, and in the early 1900's brought Thompson in front of a court because he feared this machine would "deceive" consumers, and people could end up with a cup full of air. Thompson testified before a court that just in the case of a meringue or whipped cream, air was an important part of the recipe. From this hearing the rules of ice cream were born.

When does Gelato become ice cream? What are the rules of Ice Cream?

From this hearing it was established in the United States, certain rules and measures to reinsure consumers were not getting ripped off. So when a gelato has over 10% or more in butterfat, and is 50% air or less, it is considered an ice cream. You may notice some ice cream trucks that use the word "soft-serve" alone without the word ice cream. This is because most trucks use 5% butterfat mix which is cheaper and closer to "ice-milk" so legally they cannot call it ice cream.

Frozen yogurt is another variety that gets around these rules. Today we think of frozen yogurt as a low fat alternative, but back when Gelotti started we used to serve "Columbo" yogurt. Back then when TCBY was huge, it was another way of not using the expensive liquid gold of butterfat.

Let's remember that the butterfat is the most expensive part of this whole equation. To understand let's think of a supermarket. A gallon of whole milk which is 3.5% butterfat is always about the same price as just a pint of heavy cream, which is about 30% butterfat. Those solids are literally what gives ice cream its creaminess.

Is butterfat related to quality?

Yes and no. Some of your favorite ice creams like Gelotti and Haagen-Daaz use 14% and 16% creams, which is on the higher end of ice cream mixes. These products tend to be smoother, more wholesome, warmer to the palette, and denser. Most homemade shops use a 12%, and almost all mass produced brands use 10%. However the percent of cream is like basing how nice jewelry is simply on what karat gold it is, which has nothing to do with the craftsmanship, creativity, or design.

Gelato for example is usually about 5% butterfat, and it it sometimes called "creamier" or "richer", although it contains less cream, and is a cheaper product to begin with. Gelato however uses culinary techniques such as aging mix to intensify flavor, fresh fruit and nut pastes, a slower churning method, and faster freezing. Gelato also uses more sugar, and texture improving agents like dextrose and sorbitol(fruit alcohol) which take the place of the fat.

In Italy gelato can refer to sorbet, vegan products, American ice cream, or anything in the gelato case. Most fruit gelatos are made with water and skim milk, and here in the US we would call that sorbet. To them it is all "frozen", and if you want to know what's in it, just ask the chef. In the US I assume we have more regulations, titles, and guidelines because most parlors do not make their own ice cream, and rather those guidelines are to help them keep their customers safe.

What is custard?

Every person who comes in called our soft-serve ice cream either yogurt, or custard. Both are wrong, and the reason is because some big chains use cute nicknames to make products seems better, or avoid using the word ice cream because they are using a cheaper butterfat product. Custard is supposed to be used in products that contain eggs. Some places do in fact make fresh custards, or use a mix containing eggs. When you see the word always ask especially if you have an allergy.

I want frozen dessert because its hot, should I have ice cream, gelato, yogurt, custard, sherbert, italian ice, sorbet, vegan or what?

Have whatever you like! Restaurants are always looking for ways to make more money, and frequently you will have ice cream served to you for a higher price as gelato, or homemade gelato that just wants to appeal to Americans called ice cream. Just taste, enjoy, pay attention to the difference, and always go to places that make their own because there is a huge difference. As far as calories and sugar, each product fluctuates the two, so no matter what you will be eating a fatty, sugary dessert. Try to stay away from fat free, or sugar free, unless you have a medical condition, and just eat smaller portions.

Life is short, so eat dessert first!

 

 

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News

Montclair

Philip Roth's Childhood Home Still Standing in Newark

May 24, 2018

Newark, NJ—The house at 81 Summit Avenue in Newark's Weequahic neighborhood is otherwise unremarkable expect for a sign attached to its faux flagstone facade noting that the home has been designated a historic site -- the childhood home of celebrated author Philip Roth, who died Tuesday at the age of 85.

There were no crowds outside the home to pay homage to the ...

Vehicular Homicide Charges for Driver of Paramus School Bus

May 25, 2018

MORRISTOWN, NJ - The driver of a school bus involved in a crash on Route 80 last week that killed two people faces two counts of second-degree vehicular homicide/death by auto, it was announced today.

The driver, Hudy Muldrow, 77, of Woodland Park, attempted to make an illegal U-Turn on the highway in an attempt to find his way to Waterloo Village, the planned destination of the bus that was ...

Upcoming Events

Tue, May 29, 7:00 PM

Studio Playhouse, Upper Montclair

Into the Woods Auditions

Arts & Entertainment

Wed, May 30, 6:00 PM

Hackensack Mountainside Medical Center, Montclair

Bladder Control Is No Accident: A Woman’s Guide ...

Health & Wellness

Letter to the Editor: Gum Litter and what YOU can do about it

May 16, 2018

Gum is non-biodegradable, meaning it doesn't’t break down ever….

Today, the unlikely problem surfaces. The average person chews 275 sticks of gum per year. With the amount of people in daily society, it’s no mystery why chewing gum is the second most littered item after cigarette butts.  Did you know that gum is banned in Singapore?

In addition to littering human ...

Montclair Police Blotter: Vandalism to Parked Cars, Mysterious Parking Meter Crash, and More

May 23, 2018

MONTCLAIR, NJ - The following blotter was compiled and released by the Montclair Police Department on May 22, 2018:

Arrest:
05-15-2018 (Orange Road) Mr. Danny Josama, 42yoa from West Orange, was arrested and charged with
DWI.
05-21-2018 (Wellmont Theater) Mr. Marcelo Dasilva, 40yoa from Montclair, was arrested and charged
with Burglary and Criminal Mischief for entering the Wellmont ...

'Turning Off the Morning News' brings comic twist

‘Turning Off the Morning News’ tackles today’s issues with a comic twist

By Liz Keill

PRINCETON, N J – Despite the late night comics, no one quite captures the insanity of the political/social status world like Christopher Durang.

His latest play, “Turning off the Morning News” hit the ground running.  John Pankow as Jimmy addresses the audience, ...

'To Kill a Mockingbird' Sustains Timeless Appeal

SUMMIT, NJ – The Summit Playhouse provides a stellar production of a much loved classic, “To Kill a Mockingbird.”

The Harper Lee novel, later a Gregory Peck film and now a stage production, retains all the warmth, intensity and integrity that made it such an appealing hit in the 1960s. And there will be a new production on Broadway in December with a script by Aaron Sorkin ...

Kick Off Grilling Season With Food Safety Tips

May 25, 2018

WASHINGTON, — For many Americans, the summer grilling and travel season begins this upcoming weekend. The U.S. Department of Agriculture’s (USDA) Food Safety and Inspection Service (FSIS) wants to make sure you and your family avoid food poisoning this summer. An estimated 128,000 Americans are hospitalized with food poisoning each year, but foodborne illnesses can be prevented during ...