Law & Justice

Judge Rules to Uphold MKF's Complaint Against Spiller; Spiller Responds

MONTCLAIR, NJ – On Friday, May 29, a civil case filed against Third Ward Councilor Sean Spiller was heard before Judge Thomas Moore. Moore denied Spiller’s legal motion to dismiss the ethics and conflict of interest violations alleged by Montclair Kids First (MKF). 

In a letter sent to an undisclosed numbers of recipients, MKF states, that Moore ruled in favor of MKF and has ordered that the "Montclair Education Association (MEA) must now produce key discovery information to the courts." 

Spiller asserts that three of the four complaints were dismissed. He said, "The judge dismissed three of four complaints. No documents have to be produced, as now we go back to court to determine if anything has to be provided for the one count remaining."

Sign Up for E-News

Since first bursting on the scene a few short months ago, MKF, a community-based group was newly formed in response to the growing concern among Montclair parents surrounding PARCC assessment. MKF, who first formed as an anonymous group of concerned parents, has since emerged with some vocal participants, such as Jon Bonesteel.

A group of parents and educators called Montclair Cares About Schools (MCAS), led by Michelle Fine, Regina Tuma and many others, have been vocally in opposition to the PARCC assessment. Since many of the MCAS members are also Montclair Education Association (MEA) members, MKF members have alleged seamless ties between the two. For the past year or so, MCAS has been vocal at Board of Ed. meetings and have hosted other community meetings on PARCC.

MKF members have withheld their vocal support of PARCC throughout the state and on social media. Instead of fighting their battles in an open forum like MCAS has for over a year, MKF has launched an email and legal battle in what MKF supporters say is to balance the argument.

On March 4, MKF filed a formal ethics complaint with Montclair Municipal Clerk Linda Wanat and then the Newark Superior Court on March 13 after the Township denied the MKF claim on March 12.

MKF’s legal challenge was to confront Spiller on his ability to serve as a representative on the Board of School Estimate (BoSE). The BoSE exists in towns that have an all appointed school board (Type I districts) as well as the one Type II district with a board of school estimate have a different process for budget approval. NJ State guidelines for BoSE state that after the school district prepares the budget (with the same format, guidelines and constraints of all other districts) the budget is submitted to a board of school estimate for approval.

Montclair is a Type I district where the board is composed of 2 school board members (appointed by the school board), 2 members of the governing body (appointed by it) and the mayor of Montclair. Spiller was appointed by his council colleagues to serve on the BoSE. Although the legal challege exists, many community members continue to support Spiller, regarding his position on BoSE and with NJEA an asset.

MKF has publicly held the position that Spiller’s position as a teacher in Wayne and subsequent election to Secretary of the NJEA, creates a conflict of interest. MKF followed their claims with a lawsuit paid for by private funds. 

Representing MKF at the hearing was Shavar Jeffries of Lowenstein Sandler. MKF informed the courts that they have more than seven members. Spiller has since retained legal council with the law firm of Zazzali, Fagella, Nowak, Kleinbaum, & Friedman and is pushing back in court. 

Spiller has since responded publicly stating that the claims are unwarranted. Having served on the BoSE since 2012, he has issued a formal statement stating, “Both the township attorney and my personal attorneys have reviewed the matter extensively and determined the claims to be baseless.”

Jon Bonesteel on behalf of MKF, stated in a letter, “Mr. Spiller’s ethics and conflict of interest initially began as a private matter between Montclair parents and Mr. Spiller some time ago.  Rather than address, or even acknowledge, these fair concerns, Mr. Spiller and the NJEA have escalated this issue and done everything possible to defend their own interests, rather than work with the Montclair community."

Bonesteel continued, “On Friday, Judge Moore denied Mr. Spiller’s motion to dismiss the ethics and conflict of interest complaints against him.  This is an important first step toward bringing greater transparency to our community and we greatly appreciate Judge Moore’s commitment to a fair and equitable process."

Bonesteel claims that the argument is that, “As the 3rd highest ranking official in the NJEA, Mr. Spiller’s fiduciary responsibility is to his union membership.  Mr. Spiller has used his appointment on the Montclair Board of School Estimate to strengthen the Union he represents, and he has done so at the expense of Montclair's children and taxpayers."

Spiller continued his commentary, “While this shadow group hopes to devolve our township discourse into personal attacks, my Council colleagues and the residents I serve know that I remain focused on actual issues impacting our community, such as our success in reducing township debt, increasing funding for early education, additional support for our library, putting more police officers out on the streets with community policing, and unprecedented funding for street and road improvements.”

On April 26, Spiller’s attorneys filed a motion to dismiss the case, of which Judge Moore has now denied. This has resulted in the MEA now having to produce requested documents in the given time frame.

Editor's Note: Councilor Spiller contacted TAPinto Montclair after publication to clarify that three of the four complaints filed by MKF were dismissed. He said, "The judge dismissed three of four complaints. No documents have to be produced, as now we go back to court to determine if anything has to be provided for the one count remaining."

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Like

Sign Up for E-News

Montclair

Mayor Baraka Hires Bridgegate Defense Lawyer, Michael Critchley

September 24, 2017

One of the state's top criminal defense lawyers who represented Bridget Anne Kelly in the Bridgegate trial was retained by Newark Mayor Ras Baraka to defend him in a civil suit brought by the city's former attorney.

Baraka filed a motion this week in U.S. District Court in Newark to replace attorneys Carmagnola and Ritardi with Michael Critchley of Critchley, Kinum ...

Sabattis Saved: Boy Scouts' Adventure Camp to Remain Open After Patriots’ Paths Council Executive Board Vote

September 24, 2017

CEDAR KNOLLS, NJ -- The Patriots’ Paths Council Executive Board met on Monday, Sept. 18 in a special session to discuss the future operation of Sabattis Adventure Camp, which was threatened with closure.

After thorough and thoughtful discussion, the Board voted to continue Sabbatis camping activities through the end of the 2019 summer camping season. The Board ...

Upcoming Events

Sun, September 24

The Wayrick Wildlife Gallery, at the Scherman Hoffman Wildlife Gallery, Bernardsville

NJ Audubon: The Wayrick Wildlife Art Gallery -- ...

Arts & Entertainment Education Green

Sun, September 24, 7:00 AM

Hopatcong State Park, Landing

Fifth Annual “LHF Lake Loop” Set For September ...

Giving Back Health & Wellness Sports

Sun, September 24, 12:00 PM

Montclair Art Museum, Montclair

Philemona Williamson: Metaphorical Narratives ...

Arts & Entertainment

To the Editor: EPA Cuts and Congressman Frelinghuysen

September 13, 2017

To the Editor:

The Environmental Protection Agency is under great threat. While chaos and confusion swirl around the Trump White House, and the public is distracted by the Russia Investigation, the egregious behavior of the president regarding Charlottesville, tweet upon crazy tweet and rallies, there is undermining of regulations in various departments. These regulations, passed by both ...

Sam Shepard's 'Simpatico' takes off

Sam Shepard’s “Simpatico” has a forceful workout at McCarter Theatre.

By Liz Keill

PRINCETON, NJ – If you’re at all familiar with the works of Sam Shepard, you know that he writes about gritty, unforgiving characters in what appear to be hopeless situations.

In “Simpatico,” we learn that Vinnie and Carter are former partners in a race horse ...

Worthy Women’s Entrepreneurial Seminar in Montclair, Sept. 28

September 24, 2017

Are you a new entrepreneur in your first five years of business? Are you struggling to identify your target market or has your market changed and you want to reach new customers? Are you having a hard time making money? Does your personal life get in the way of your business? 

If so, you must attend the Worthy Women's Entrepreneurial Seminar Series where we support women entrepreneurs ...